For the male MC looks, he needs to have some more wrinkles, not alot, some gray added to his hair, and his body needs to be thicker, as you age your body basically spreads out, and even body builders can't avoid that if they stay in shape. His hair should either be short and conservative, or long and flowing, the whole shoulder-length pixie look is something women do, but men tend to be one or the other.
The guests are looking good, it was well done changing them at the start rather than waiting and tossing in some changes way down the road to create a disconnect. The story so far isn't going to win oscar's, but honestly that's not a bad thing since oscars have lately gone to crap. The game is just enough fun with some forwards momentum, slow burns are nice and all, but the latest craze of games going for Glacial Slow Burns is rather meh, that only works if you have a Dean R Koontz or Stephen King level of story to tell so that player isn't outright bored and waits a few years for the story to get somewhere, glad to see instead steady progression here without all the T&D content so many are getting used to, heck I shut that whole line off in Midlife Crisis flat, don't want it elsewhere too.
So all in all, put it on my watched and favourited list to see how things go.