- Mar 26, 2024
- 169
- 155
Suzy is her child, but is not a child. She is a college-aged adult, and lives outside the home. This is an extremely wealthy family, and it wouldn't spark too much suspicion for a college student to ask their parent for money.
- Thread starter monroe
- Start date
How large a sum was asked for? I don't recall a number being given out by Suzi other than to ask for access to her money.
Sure, if you want to thrown the dictionary at 'inferences' versus 'implications', sure you win. The meaning is still the same. All three people that were there and lived it tell their information as much as the dev wants us to know. Whether you like it, or agree with it, is pointless as it's the only information given. Anything else is just wild speculation and trying to read between the lines of something not written.
And I never said sexual assault. Mental and physical abuses of any kind can be just as memory imprinting as sexual abuse is. So the point still stands. Suzi remembers very specific moments of her dad. Lucy remembers her step-brother. Charlotte remembers her ex-husband. Regardless of whether we like the given information is irrelevant as that's all there is.
Charlotte said he abandoned the family after Emma was born. Lucy, if I recall correctly, says roughly the same thing, and seems to detest him even more than Charlotte. Suzi has bad memories of her dad. Emma, likely parroting what Charlotte said also says her dad abandoned the family. Does the exact reason really matter? All three of them have reasonably consistent stories of him.
- Apr 8, 2024
- 2,343
- 4,023
I can't find this, what did Suzi say? Did she actually remember him specifically, or is she just talking generally?
For much of this, it's really not relevent. The father is gone, he's not coming back, the reasons for his departure are not pertinent to the story.
Depends on the amount of money. I doubt this jerk charged $10 for the photos. Again, Charlotte didn't even suspect anything, didn't even check it.
- Jun 30, 2018
- 2,845
- 3,471
Let me put it this way, with the caveat that I don't have children: When child #2, a wide-eyed-with-wonder clumsy kitten, gets stalked and you have a break-in into your house and you have to hire a bodyguard even though you're "afraid of men", then child #1, an independent college student who knows how to deal with stuff, asking for money doesn't reach S Tier on the priority list.
- Mar 26, 2024
- 169
- 155
The meanings are not the same, they are literally opposites. I am not arguing your point, though I disagree with it, because all we have are what we inferred from the information given so far, which is incomplete.
I'm sorry I jumped to my inference of sexual violence, if that's not what you were intending to imply.
Is he not coming back? Never say never. You are guaranteed not to return only from the grave. And Emma needs a father. That's why she's a pimp . (her mom and MС).
- Jul 25, 2017
- 12,248
- 15,900
I hope not I don't see any reason to include the father anymore than maybe talking about him in the story it isn't needed at all.
Unless I'm completely misunderstanding your point, I don't think that's the case. All I was attempting to say was the only 'information' we have is what Lucy, Charlotte, and Suzi say. Beyond that, we have zero information and what was given indicates it was not a happy and amicable separation. With no other information to go off of, that's what we have.
Based on what Lucy and Charlotte tell us about the dad, it sounds like there is a very near-zero chance of him returning, or being welcomed back.
The meaning of the statement, not the meanings of the word. The use of the word does not ruin the what was said as it can very easily be implied what the intent of it was.
- Apr 8, 2024
- 2,343
- 4,023
What about the first bit? You said Suzi was remembering her father while at the cafe? I had a search through the scripts to see what it was, but I couldn't find anything. What was said there?
If it wasn't intentionally worded that way, I'd agree with you.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 10,919
- 25,889
Jesus H Christ take it somehwere else. I'd ask wtf happened to this thread but given 2 of the culprits are on the list...I can't say I'm exactly surprised.
Lucy best girl.
Lucy best girl.
- May 22, 2017
- 3,164
- 7,823
I remember stuff from before I was 2 years old. I remember particularly brightly how I electrocuted myself before I was 2.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
There are a couple of more events I remember from when I was between 2 and 3 years old and I definitely remember all my family members.
So yes, I do think that it's plausible that a girl remembers her dad from when she was 2 years old and likely something as traumatic as her dad leaving them.
Last edited:
- Mar 26, 2024
- 169
- 155
This is the first thing that you've said that I can straight up agree with.
Lucy said that Suzi's short temper was inherited from her father. Suzi replied that she hated that asshole. You can't hate someone you don't know and haven't seen in the last 18 years.
- Jul 25, 2017
- 12,248
- 15,900
I disagree only on the context of who it is Suzi hates. I think you can 100% hate a father you never really met or got to know because he left. Especially if she never questions anything that she has been told to see what the story is on the other side of the coin.
- Apr 8, 2024
- 2,343
- 4,023
... yes you can. You can hate the impact he's had on your life. You can hate what he did to your mother. You can hate a lot.
Not saying that's what she meant, as I don't remember it, but just saying it's definitely possible.
- Jul 26, 2023
- 9,409
- 18,160
To hate someone, that person must have at least a face. Otherwise, it smells like Harry Osborne-style schizophrenia.