I agree, animations are of course a nice to have, but not really essential here. At all, if it would slow down the development process of the game. For me, good pictures/renders and of course the story are much more important. That's where this game stands out from the crowd for me.
- Thread starter monroe
- Start date
Thanks for the thoughts about adding animations.
I need to talk to my patrons about it first but will post a reply soon.
I need to talk to my patrons about it first but will post a reply soon.
- Jan 13, 2020
- 1,309
- 2,592
yeah i get it why animations are an important thought (and in some games the animations are awesome, but would the game be not that good without them? dont think so), but i have to say, most of the games around here get kinda lost in animations and sex after a while... most of the games starting promising, and when you reach about the half than there are sex-scene after sex-scene and nothing more... the story of hillside is very promising, the charactres are very good written, the relationships are building up very good... keep the focus on that and dont get distracted with animations for fap-material... there is a good way to build up an "erotic" mood without them
- May 9, 2019
- 4,872
- 16,026
DISCLAIMER: I really like this novel and I wish for it the best.
I'd said it so many times that I can just copy my posts, but I will say it again. Animations are totally overrated.
Almost everything you can do with animations, you can do as good with a few good static renders. The cost of animations in resources (be it money or time) is higher than the benefit.
This is particularly true for repetitive movements as, for example, sex scenes. In the end, sex scenes are just repetitive movements everybody have seen before. Now if we were talking about something complex, as a dance, that you wanted to showcase, now that would be harder to do with such a few renders, as essentially a dance is about movement. But that is really only true if you want to highlight the dance. Just for dancing as part of the story, static but well done renders is enough.
I know that ultimately this depends on your patreons which are the ones you should be hearing the most. But I dare to say that the reason people are drawn to this novel is mainly the story (i know it is kind of presumptuous to assume I know what people like.. take this if anything as my assumption and/or a statistical claim about what i've read in the forum than a certainty over all the population). The visual quality, while nice, is second to that. And without any doubt animations will reduce the speed of development.
I'd said it so many times that I can just copy my posts, but I will say it again. Animations are totally overrated.
Almost everything you can do with animations, you can do as good with a few good static renders. The cost of animations in resources (be it money or time) is higher than the benefit.
This is particularly true for repetitive movements as, for example, sex scenes. In the end, sex scenes are just repetitive movements everybody have seen before. Now if we were talking about something complex, as a dance, that you wanted to showcase, now that would be harder to do with such a few renders, as essentially a dance is about movement. But that is really only true if you want to highlight the dance. Just for dancing as part of the story, static but well done renders is enough.
I know that ultimately this depends on your patreons which are the ones you should be hearing the most. But I dare to say that the reason people are drawn to this novel is mainly the story (i know it is kind of presumptuous to assume I know what people like.. take this if anything as my assumption and/or a statistical claim about what i've read in the forum than a certainty over all the population). The visual quality, while nice, is second to that. And without any doubt animations will reduce the speed of development.
Last edited:
- Sep 12, 2018
- 8,958
- 36,973
But...but....what about those poor lost "noi animations-no good" trolls?
think of them please...just do think...of them...those....sad...lost...souls...without animations....doomed
kidding aside, i'd put this as a sticky note alongside trending games banner or so.
only if more devs would think that way.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 8,416
- 18,758
Agree'd. While I am doing animations...I can churn them out without having to take 2 weeks to be able to do a 10s clip (though many of mine won't be sex animations but general ones). I admit, if that's someones issue (due to their GPU), just don't bother. If it's a simple loop, I'd personally prefer not to see it and just keep static and maybe do two or three more renders from different angles and slightly change the pose. Far more effective.
Bad animations are far worse than not having them at all and thinking about your scene composition instead.
- May 9, 2019
- 4,872
- 16,026
I am going to be a little extreme by saying this but unless people are going by Oceanlab's quality and approach, which is extremely hard and costly to do, well done but static images are the way to go. In his case it's just that the end result is so good that you could, arguably, look the other way if you want. But he has animations as bottlenecks that result is slow updates.
Last edited:
- Jul 12, 2020
- 8,416
- 18,758
For sure (and just wait heh)...the problem is in the time rendering, not even so much the time setting up the sequence. Could set up his opening sequence in a couple of hours (from SG). However, even at 2 mins a render and let's say you're doing a 10s clip at 30fps...
That's...10 hours....25 hours if your GPU can only do them at 5 mins a render....you get the picture heh. However, anyone trying to do animation stills that can't churn out a still (animated images don't need the same quality) in less than a few mins..using IRay....really needs to give it up and forget it (unless have a dedicated machine just for those). Far better render engines out there for churning out those 300, 500, 1000 stills for an animation (as actually animating in Daz is a fecking nightmare). As we say, better stick to just doing a few extra still images.
Anyway...going OT....apologies.
- Sep 5, 2019
- 6,505
- 7,709
Well if adding a good smooth animation added an extra week, I would be happy for it, then again I am not a stupid kid who can't just fucking wait.
What kind of scrub dev doesn't add animations.
What kind of scrub dev doesn't add animations.
- Nov 30, 2020
- 238
- 583
One who's more interested in getting a update out earlier for his Patreon's.
There are a few very good games on this site with great stories that haven't got any animations, and not having them hasn't spoiled the game at all, well not for me they haven't.
But I suppose if you want animations one could always pop over to Pornhub and watch some there.
- May 9, 2019
- 4,872
- 16,026
Yes.. I am sure most people prefer to wait an extra week for the same repetitive moment that is a sex scene that anybody that is not 7 years old has seen before and understands and that it last... 30 seconds? Seems like a really good trade off... assuming 2 months of current development for a 30 minutes update... so an eighth of additional time developing for something that lasted one sixtyth of current update... that is not that you didn't have before, it is now simply animated (assuming is done perfectly).
Second, I am not an expert, but from what I've heard, you cannot compare animations in Ripples that is made in Honey Select to animations made in Daz or Blender.
I did mention that some things do need to be animated. A dance, a fight.. maybe. Sex is absolutely not one of them, being obvious and repetitive. And I did mentioned Ocean's animation are justified given the quality and approach. Most are not.
But anyway, we are discussing tastes... so no need to force an agreement, simply saying that I am extremely confident most would agree with me that the trade off is not worth it in most cases.
Last edited:
- Sep 5, 2019
- 6,505
- 7,709
HA, the animations in ripple be it HS/PH are still better than a lot of the daz games on this site.
As for the same thing you have seen before in animations, come on how many games on here have the same thing, horny young guy off to Uni to fuck a bunch of sluts, horny young guy with dead/gone/bad dad trying to show his mum she is still hot so he can fuck her, horny old guy seducing his daughter, 99% of the games on this site have incest, hell Suzy is a cunt to you, who no doubt will come around to the MC, that sunda sundrea whatever the weeb shit is, is in 99% of the games on this site.
But whatever this is starting to go around in circles and I ain't in the mood.
As for the same thing you have seen before in animations, come on how many games on here have the same thing, horny young guy off to Uni to fuck a bunch of sluts, horny young guy with dead/gone/bad dad trying to show his mum she is still hot so he can fuck her, horny old guy seducing his daughter, 99% of the games on this site have incest, hell Suzy is a cunt to you, who no doubt will come around to the MC, that sunda sundrea whatever the weeb shit is, is in 99% of the games on this site.
But whatever this is starting to go around in circles and I ain't in the mood.
- Nov 30, 2020
- 238
- 583
Well one bonus for you, is that HillsideVN did mention earlier in this thread that he wanted to add music and animations later on, so you may get your wish after all, somewhere down the line.
- Jul 14, 2017
- 412
- 886
- May 9, 2019
- 4,872
- 16,026
Hahaha give it time... unless you are expecting a development of the novel á la Jesus/Anakin.add pregnancy
- Aug 14, 2018
- 3,022
- 31,016
