Hello.
no, I was talking about the game called Straight its the only one I consider a legit well thought gay sex game with a sensible story not just fetishes thrown in to please the crowd and I know there are games in which mc is top but none of great quality in which the character he's with is a main character and not just a side story with a one night stand there's maybe 5 games of that caliber and I was saying its ironic the best of gay games IMO is the one called straight and yet the mc never even has sex in the game now tell me how is that game doing better than all these and yet none of the other authors are taking notes on how to write a good story for the game there all falling into the same category you must not be looking at the list there literally all the same
From the way you wrote your sentences, I understood you were talking about the genre and not the game itself, though it's difficult to have a clear idea of what you say when it's a wall of text.
I wouldn't say it's the best gay game. It's been a while since I played it and I always found it very repetitive. It may have changed since then and I never reached the ending each time, that's why I never commented on the game thread yet.
For the rest, I have the impression it's a question of taste. You seem very peculiar on the content inside a game. The best gay game I ever played is Young Marcus - Expanded from randiel (I'm not even sure I'll found a better one in the future).
Good continuation.