You got to wonder what the review system is here for, when so many of the five star reviews for this game practically are just "Great renders, story has potential."
You are not supposed to give 5 stars to a game for that. Five stars basically means the game is already near perfection.
It does everything right. That's what you give the highest rating for.
Not good renders and a story you think is promising.
This game had issues from the start and ever since it became a sandbox it turned to boring, tedious crap, but of course that's only my opinion and it's cool if you like it more than I do, but don't give a five star rating to a game just for the renders.
If the renders were the only thing important in a game, we wouldn't need games at all, we could just run slideshows with daz3d models.
Who are you to gatekeep what the review system is for? If someone genuinely enjoyed the game, if it entertained a particular fetish, or if they just had a good time playing it, then that's their business. As it stands, the 5 star review system is not so in-depth and is very basic. You're free to leave a review with whatever criteria you want and I'm sure it will be a very informative and helpful read (no sarcasm is intended, I see that you've been here for awhile), but as someone who left a 5 star review, I stand by my words. I found the game fun and I found the story fairly engaging, at least as far as a porn game goes. To be fair, I came upon to the game when there was already a fair amount of content made for it and didn't have to deal with what seems to be a large amount of inactivity and miscommunication from the developer, so I didn't go into it with any bitter feelings. Plus there's a very significant futa-on-male aspect of the game that I really enjoyed.
So yeah, just goes to show you there's always another perspective and not everyone who might disagree with you about the game is just looking at the pretty pictures and throwing out misleading 5 star reviews every which way.
EDIT: Just figured out what the new content was for the most recent update, starting to feel some of that bitterness now. Really, really weak.