I can only give my advice, and I'm only responsible for my rating, not the rating of the game. Lots of games are overrated, some are underrated, it is unfair, but well, what can I do ?
I have a personal scale, I don't rate the worst game, because I probably won't even download them and lose my time with them, so basicaly, it may seems unfair, but I'll only rate a game that looked attractive to me at first. 1 star if I don't plan to play it again, 2 stars if I may download it again after a few updates and fast forward into it to see if there's somethig interesting, 3 stars if I'll partially play the game, skipping some parts, and some characters that I dislike, 4 stars if several girls or route are appealing to me and 5 star if I plan to completely play it with all routes and characters.
As stated in my review, there are very problematic things in this one for me, the relation to the mother and sister to please patreon. It make the devs look greedy, lots of dev create a patreon even before the first release, they don't want to tell a good story, they want to earn money. This dev give the impression that for them, patreon is more important than the players and the story.
Then there's the forced sex scenes with the characters I dislike. I'm into petite girls, I like Pauline and Eula, but we are forced to Lily and Emily, in the first case it was changed, but there's still very intimate scene with her, in the later, it's a forced sex scene, the character is unaware it happened, but I am the player and the scene is shown to me and the dev could still give us the choice if it happened or not (or it happened, but it will only be told or shown after the player made decisions orienting to this character route, this way, players not interested in the character will never know it happened, as the MC). But in the end, I'm forced to characters that I find unattractive and that's a very bad point for something supposed to be arousing. And with two occurence, it will probably happen again, so I'm dropping it and probably won't come back to it, thus 1 star, sorry dev, nothing personal.