Last time I played this game, I got held up at an inscrutable puzzle dealing with trying to get different clothes from different houses on different days. I stopped playing after looking up the answers and I couldn't even follow the walk through for the puzzle.
I liked the concept, but witch trainer did every part of it better, at least when I last played this. The game had too much work for too little pay off.
I was hoping it would get better with time, but from the comments it may not have yet.