VN Ren'Py Innocent Witches [v0.12.1 A Fix1] [Sad Crab]

[Deleted member 522652]

Well, we have been having an hour conversation about a minigame, using QTE vs Logic... one requires using your memory, but is more steps. The other is simpler but more trial and error.

What would you guys prefer? More steps, but very logical? Or less steps, but a bit of trial and error?

The writing is being updated by a proper editor, the game will improve over time, don't be mistaken.

+1 for skills in mini games: I liked the Daphne mini game because it was on character, and catching the snitch task was also good in theory, but it was just too fast (and still easy to beat). Other games have you find the right sequence of touching a girl's body to spur her arousal, which I usually like ('cos that's how it works in real life, too) Like MC does a medical exam, how can he get her wet, without her complaining he went too fast.

The Hermi puzzle was not for me: totally off character for the prude to agree to this

 

[yesz]

Is the only way to get the prefect addresses in the beginning?
somehow i made it past that point without getting the ravenclaw prefect's address and now i cant contact her

 

[POEPOPSTOEL]

Had some fun with the cg rip.
Maybe ill do some more in the future.

 

[yamadakun]

Had some fun with the cg rip.
Maybe ill do some more in the future.
View attachment 468312

yes, please do more!

 

[SamHaim]

Had some fun with the cg rip.
Maybe ill do some more in the future.
View attachment 468312

Maybe they should be hiring you.

 

[Splatter_1]

I think I might really hate this damn game. I must be partially retarded because I am stuck on the swimsuit quest, puzzle. WHY WHY have SO many things to do just to advance the story... I can fix a Computer, cars, and appliances but trying to follow this game is making me want to pull out my frikking hair. And the "video" on how to do it was recorded in fucking fast forward so I can't even read what to do... Pissed off...

 

[SamHaim]

I think I might really hate this damn game. I must be partially retarded because I am stuck on the swimsuit quest, puzzle. WHY WHY have SO many things to do just to advance the story... I can fix a Computer, cars, and appliances but trying to follow this game is making me want to pull out my frikking hair. And the "video" on how to do it was recorded in fucking fast forward so I can't even read what to do... Pissed off...

Dev says there's a skip option. I also rage quit at this point.

I frickin love the artwork and the potential of this game but it's like any criticism of the rambling dialogue that leads to obscure quests just falls on deaf ears.

 

[ꜱᴛᴀɢᴡᴏᴏᴅ]

Personally, I'm not sure how people have trouble with it. The House Elves gather all the clothes on a certain day for laundry which resets the progress. Just swap out the swimsuits with your modified versions before laundry day. I didn't find myself having to pay attention to anything else. Maybe I got lucky?

 

[Splatter_1]

Modified versions? What modified versions... I give hat the "underwear" then I collect them from him nothing changes... I missed something somewhere..... and where is the skip option

 

[jackofshadows]

I found that swimsuit quest just extremely tiresome, nothing more. But I had pissed during bedroom puzzle in exchange. Why the only fucking sequence matter and not the result itself by any approach? I guess that way was hard/impossible to implement but in any case, that's just retarded.

 

[ꜱᴛᴀɢᴡᴏᴏᴅ]

Modified versions? What modified versions... I give hat the "underwear" then I collect them from him nothing changes... I missed something somewhere..... and where is the skip option

The modified swimsuits. You have to give the collected swimsuits to the hat to modify them. How are people missing this stuff? lol
I do agree it can be tiresome like Jack says. Even knowing what you're doing it can become a chore to go to each dorm and repeat the same tasks. Even on a perfect doing it right the first time run you're repeating a task 4 times.

 

[ꜱᴛᴀɢᴡᴏᴏᴅ]

Hey JoeBanks
When you get around to reworking the old content, please add more rewarding content to the swimsuit quest in the form of us actually being able to spy on the girls or something. We get some dialogue from them while in the pool but we only get to look at Hogwarts. Seeing the results of our hard work in action would make the work less tiresome.
It also doesn't make sense for the replaced swimsuits to revert if we don't do them all in the timeframe. Why/how are the elves replacing the modified swimsuits with the originals if the player replaces half of them or something before laundry day? Figuring out what you need to do is a puzzle in itself without the added time constraint.

 

[JoeBanks]

Hey JoeBanks
When you get around to reworking the old content, please add more rewarding content to the swimsuit quest in the form of us actually being able to spy on the girls or something. We get some dialogue from them while in the pool but we only get to look at Hogwarts. Seeing the results of our hard work in action would make the work less tiresome.
It also doesn't make sense for the replaced swimsuits to revert if we don't do them all in the timeframe. Why/how are the elves replacing the modified swimsuits with the originals if the player replaces half of them or something before laundry day? Figuring out what you need to do is a puzzle in itself without the added time constraint.

That's one of my biggest personal gripes, there's like no reward for 4 chapters. It's a heavy reworking, chapter 4 is all me (due to editing costs). Also, in the end, I want to make it so you pick one girl and play through, not doing all 4 girls for everything.

 

[ꜱᴛᴀɢᴡᴏᴏᴅ]

That's one of my biggest personal gripes, there's like no reward for 4 chapters. It's a heavy reworking, chapter 4 is all me (due to editing costs). Also, in the end, I want to make it so you pick one girl and play through, not doing all 4 girls for everything.

I do hope I will still be able to pursue all girls at once though. I'm a greedy bastard harem kind of guy.
It bummed me out a little when I basically had to choose my best girl. Daphne is incredible in this game, but Luna has always been a favourite of mine, and Hermoine is just Hermoine and something about her just really makes me want to put her in her place. It hurt me to have to choose just one. I know replayability is a factor when it comes to multiple routes, but there's a lot of content here that isn't specific to the girls so it would feel like a real grind having to play through it all again for each girl.

 

[JoeBanks]

I found that swimsuit quest just extremely tiresome, nothing more. But I had pissed during bedroom puzzle in exchange. Why the only fucking sequence matter and not the result itself by any approach? I guess that way was hard/impossible to implement but in any case, that's just retarded.

If you don't make the entire sequence based on open and closing, it just becomes random and non-sensical.

 

[raihuhoha]

Well, we have been having an hour conversation about a minigame, using QTE vs Logic... one requires using your memory, but is more steps. The other is simpler but more trial and error.

What would you guys prefer? More steps, but very logical? Or less steps, but a bit of trial and error?

Memory. Remember in Super Mario 3 where you got to play that memory game? That would be kind of awesome to have again. Sure, might be a pain in the ass to think of a reward with it, but it can be done, no?

 

[Woeml]

This game is very hard and long, very few cutsences and minigame. They even have not uploaded new walkingthrough. I've played this game since last year, until now i'm still waiting something surprise, but it makes me disappointed

 

[omsues1307]

I think I might really hate this damn game. I must be partially retarded because I am stuck on the swimsuit quest, puzzle. WHY WHY have SO many things to do just to advance the story... I can fix a Computer, cars, and appliances but trying to follow this game is making me want to pull out my frikking hair. And the "video" on how to do it was recorded in fucking fast forward so I can't even read what to do... Pissed off...

I will help you just send a message

 

[JoeBanks]

This game is very hard and long, very few cutsences and minigame. They even have not uploaded new walkingthrough. I've played this game since last year, until now i'm still waiting something surprise, but it makes me disappointed

We only update the walkthrough for the F release to the public. Otherwise, we have our discord for patreons for questions on patreon releases.

 

[Katyxxx]

Stop Whining !!! Good game !!! but I have such an idea... Here at Hogwarts, the paintings are alive ? it would be cool when the Girl changes clothes behind a Screen in Dumbledore's office , response of two paintings which hang there )) Women and Men on this matter ))))