Yeah, I agree with your last statement... Unless Nyx shifts a bunch of the narrative I don't see the milfs being love interests.
Yeah, Elena is someone else you get relationship points with... And quite a few have asked for her to be a love interest. Soo... Just saying there's some really sensitive people who wouldn't be happy with that
If Erynn and Ethan dated, went to prom together, and continued to date but never had sex I will roll my eyes out of my god damned face. That implies years of Erynn blue balling Ethan which seems unlikely. Also even if she barely dated Ethan it doesn't preclude the possibility of her fucking someone else.
And yeah, I absolutely agree with you that the women should be able to have relationships besides the MC (Zach and Elena would make a cute love/hate passionate couple) but, once again, there are people who would freak the fuck out about it. Even though this isn't a harem game, etc...
Oh Nyx will screw us over at some point but I don't think THAT will be the way it happens...
I don't like to go after LI who are already in relationships (which makes some games a bit problematic or straight up unplayable for me). But that's just me... Some people may love that idea.
I just don't believe Erynn's waving her hand at the suggestion that she and Ethan had any type of relationship. She was friends with him since she was 15, she went to prom with him, and he shows up at her apartment. No way they weren't an item. I wouldn't be surprised to find out they were prom king and queen...