MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,050
2,614
Half-sisters surely? And yes it's been heavily implied by Nyx that John is also the father of Erynn.
Which if true then Iris and Erynn would be the MC's step-sisters if John and Emily were to get married. Now that would be some Intertwined mess. :LOL:
Not if Melissa has something to say about that
 

Picallol

New Member
Nov 16, 2021
4
6
Anyone think Iris and Erynn are related? We still haven't found out who Erynn's real dad is and there's numerous mentions on how much Iris and Erynn look alike
Is this a commonly held belief?
If you look at the tattoos John has prior to the latest (maybe even one before) you can clearly see the tattoos line up.
The circle tattoo at his neck and the tip of the wings at his shoulders / arm.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

However, if you let Emily talk about her date with him it seems like Nyx went with something completely different for John, making it even more confusing. The circle tattoo at his neck are gone as well as the crosses

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

The change in tattoos is really confusing, almost as if the real dad is suddenly going to be someone else. Nyx going "fooled you guys!"

On a side node, if John is going to be Melissa's ex then having your MC say yes to her dating John is going to be an interesting development with her saying

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Justaphase

Active Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
776
2,075
If you look at the tattoos John has prior to the latest (maybe even one before) you can clearly see the tattoos line up.
The circle tattoo at his neck and the tip of the wings at his shoulders / arm.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

However, if you let Emily talk about her date with him it seems like Nyx went with something completely different for John, making it even more confusing. The circle tattoo at his neck are gone as well as the crosses

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

The change in tattoos is really confusing, almost as if the real dad is suddenly going to be someone else. Nyx going "fooled you guys!"

On a side node, if John is going to be Melissa's ex then having your MC say yes to her dating John is going to be an interesting development with her saying

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Maybe John's tattoos are really a big version of the stick on kids ones? Where you had to wet and peel them? That would explain the changing tattoos. :LOL:
And I think that Emily's only knowledge of Melissa's John is the brief descripion that she gave her years ago, of the guy with long blonde hair and tats who she said sounds like a viking.
 

Boogie

Active Member
Aug 7, 2017
902
1,460
The date between Emily and John didn't happen in first person perspective. It was a story told from one person to another which of course means the listener has to form their own visual image. I was also confused by the difference in tattoos but it could just be that we are seeing Melissa's visualization. At least I hope so, John being Erynn's father is a perfect fit for this story and would create further drama to spice things up.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,344
4,844
If you look at the tattoos John has prior to the latest (maybe even one before) you can clearly see the tattoos line up.
The circle tattoo at his neck and the tip of the wings at his shoulders / arm.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

However, if you let Emily talk about her date with him it seems like Nyx went with something completely different for John, making it even more confusing. The circle tattoo at his neck are gone as well as the crosses

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

The change in tattoos is really confusing, almost as if the real dad is suddenly going to be someone else. Nyx going "fooled you guys!"

On a side node, if John is going to be Melissa's ex then having your MC say yes to her dating John is going to be an interesting development with her saying

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Nyx is doing a slow, gradual remake of the game, changing the look of many things, one of those are John's Tatoos.
Personally, i don't think it makes a difference, it's just a mess of tats one on top of another, but Nyx wasn't happy with the original design for some reason...
The later updates already have updated assets, the change happens with no warning, the easiest way to spot the when you are seeing updated stuff is the MCs haircut, when he goes from shaved sides to spiky boyband look without any "he stopped for a haircut" scenes
PS: The hair has just changed again, but with a scene to justify it.

All this to say it's no use to do a deep analysis of John's tatoos currently, they change and are inconsistent, but some day they'll be consistent (hopefully).

And John will be the father of Erynn, too many hints to pull a "PSYCHED it's this other guy... who happens to fit the same exact description, and is also named John" now.

Is this a commonly held belief?
Very much so...
And every once in a while someone new comes into the thread thinking he just found something brand new that no one spotted before(no offence).

If you hang around long enough you'll see the next guy lol.
 
Last edited:

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
12,201
15,801
Half-sisters surely? And yes it's been heavily implied by Nyx that John is also the father of Erynn.
Which if true then Iris and Erynn would be the MC's step-sisters if John and Emily were to get married. Now that would be some Intertwined mess. :LOL:
Which will be funny because in one of the early Chapters the MC joked to Erynn what if he is her brother when talking about how she doesn't know her father. NGL first time I played the game and saw that scene I was like let it be true for the drama lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Justaphase

Kond

Member
Jul 8, 2018
400
1,413
I think it will take some time until the official revelation if John is Erynn's father or not happens, i think Nyx will do it only after the player has the chance to start dating Melissa, i dont think Nyx will lose the chance to use the drama that will come out from this, imagine, Emily dating John (or at least had the intention of dating him in the case of player's refusal), and then discovering that hes Melissa's Ex, Erynn's (and Iris) father and MC is dating Melissa, and let's not forget Mel and MC's mom have some history and MC saw them having some "fun", this can trigger strong reactions from John, Mel, Emily, Erynn and Iris since shes MC's ex and John's daughter...damn, what a drama.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,050
2,614
I think it will take some time until the official revelation if John is Erynn's father or not happens, i think Nyx will do it only after the player has the chance to start dating Melissa, i dont think Nyx will lose the chance to use the drama that will come out from this, imagine, Emily dating John (or at least had the intention of dating him in the case of player's refusal), and then discovering that hes Melissa's Ex, Erynn's (and Iris) father and MC is dating Melissa, and let's not forget Mel and MC's mom have some history and MC saw them having some "fun", this can trigger strong reactions from John, Mel, Emily, Erynn and Iris since shes MC's ex and John's daughter...damn, what a drama.
the reveal likely happens in 2 updates at the most, not only is there the dating emily storyline, but also John's involved in the blackmail storyline, he's involved in too much stuff for this secret not to come out sooner rather than later
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
67,360
33,995
Half-sisters surely? And yes it's been heavily implied by Nyx that John is also the father of Erynn.
Which if true then Iris and Erynn would be the MC's step-sisters if John and Emily were to get married. Now that would be some Intertwined mess. :LOL:
well emily's john hasn't met melissa yet and we don't know if emily has seen mel's john pics. nyx will ass "few" more "incest" scares on this by end.
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
67,360
33,995
weird thing: no errors after adding koga's mod (had scrappy's mod but 2nd last path i had forgotten to change mc's name) and no lexi presenting cars. so lookslike i have to replay 1st 3 paths to get error free saves (dang it but better than alternative aka start from scratch (HELL NO)).

i hope monroes house has thick walls and adriana for sure has 6th sense when it comes to her daughters, was bit surprised that she didn't pop-up when mc had sex with her daughters (maybe cooking kept her busy).

based on what zo and adriana were talking layla and lexi get babysister/boy and lakayen gets new cousin. that old pervert on beach is simply hilarious.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
4.40 star(s) 296 Votes