I would agree with you if this game had a "Completed" tag among the others. We somewhere in the middle of the story at the current moment, maybe even we're not reached the middle. Then going the title of the game itself... second hint. Absolutely sweet, carefree/drama free, sugar coated playthroughs and endings are the worst you get get and expect from such a game and from the whole genre, imo.
Just to remember: Iris (MC's ex), Lexi that was addicted to our MC from the moment he leaved the city, Erynn that got her best friend back and realized how much she love him, Nikki & Cara - each wears a brave face while dying inside if you pick one of them. Layla still have an unresolved situation with Lucas, then - Elena, of course. Melissa have a hots for MC too. If you're not role playing a jerk and/or a "bad boy" then most or all girls "wants" you. Layla's and Erynn's pure paths feels as the most safe ones at the moment, but don't fool yourself.