She didn't even know she was the one he was mad at, he cut off contact with his mother and everyone else too after he was sent away. So like I said, her friend is back and she's excited. She doesn't see it as 'ambushing' him. And the times he turns her down, outside the club, at the pool, etc, she is sad, but accepts it. You can not like her, but it's unfair to say that she's at fault for pretty much any of their relationship troubles, outside of an angry outburst if you're seeing Alexis, but she even accepts MC being with Alexis, she's just mad about the lying.
- Thread starter Maleficent
- Start date
LSC82
I am not looking to make this a thing so I’m just going to say this and be done. Everything you’ve listed happened. They are valid perceptions of actions/reactions, outside/in. What I am talking about is inside/out. “Erynn”, the character, if aware of the concept of introspection, can not possibly believe perfection is a life goal and be sane. Neither can someone strive to be both perfect and be a free spirit. Those two “states” are antithetical. I don’t want to mock anyone’s views but I’ll just suggest that one goes through the Erynn scenes empathically and see if all the reactions are consistent with a balanced and complete human being… I don't mean mature, or good or if you would do the same if it were you. I am saying would a single individual behave thusly.
EDIT:
Facepalm if you wish but I assume she wasn’t written as a 90s RomCom villainess, with a pink purse, throwing temper tantrums about the prom decorations… No one else was.
I am not looking to make this a thing so I’m just going to say this and be done. Everything you’ve listed happened. They are valid perceptions of actions/reactions, outside/in. What I am talking about is inside/out. “Erynn”, the character, if aware of the concept of introspection, can not possibly believe perfection is a life goal and be sane. Neither can someone strive to be both perfect and be a free spirit. Those two “states” are antithetical. I don’t want to mock anyone’s views but I’ll just suggest that one goes through the Erynn scenes empathically and see if all the reactions are consistent with a balanced and complete human being… I don't mean mature, or good or if you would do the same if it were you. I am saying would a single individual behave thusly.
EDIT:
Facepalm if you wish but I assume she wasn’t written as a 90s RomCom villainess, with a pink purse, throwing temper tantrums about the prom decorations… No one else was.
Last edited by a moderator:
She's not perfect... and she's very scared of how people will react once her veil of perfection is lifted.
Is she overthinking this(as we are ironically)? I think so, maybe some people will point fingers and laugh but her good friends will stand by her.
In the end i do buy her as a human being.
Also the person i was referencing and called "free spirit" was her mom, Erynn is very far from a free spirit, for example she thinks she must keep her perfect persona facade, which, yes, is pretty much the antithesis of being a free spirit.
Last edited:
It took a couple of months before he was sent a way. She must have knew that the mc was pissed at her.... I can understand she didn't understood why, but clearly she should have understood that something wrong happened between them. She probably speak to his mother....
But you are right, if she didn't understood that mc had something against her, that would explain why she was acting that way.
Well from Erynn's perspective:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Mar 3, 2020
- 1,962
- 4,187
he cut contact with Erynn before he was sent away, she tried to talk to him but he refused to listen
Imagine the small amount of drama this game would have if the MC actually talked to people instead of running away (exit pursued by drama)... He would have cleared up so many mysteries, been able to date the girl of his dreams, the whole Ethan thing wouldn't be happening, on and on. But then he wouldn't have met Nikki/Cara, Lakeyn, had a possible relationship with Layla, Lexi, or Elena... It's interesting how so much of the story comes down to just a couple of choices.
Well, it will be interesting to see how the drama is resolved. Especially when Ethan could have MC arrested for assault (even if he was defending someone there's no way to believe that Ethan won't lie to the police in order to get the MC into trouble).
- Mar 3, 2020
- 1,962
- 4,187
exactly thats why we should all thank Erynn for going to laugh at that video, shes the real M.V.P here
Erynn though that mc stop talking to her for 5 years because he was pissed at Ethan? I though she was delusional, but this is something else...
I said 'might', just showing it as the result of the last interaction she had with him, outside of him ignoring her. She never gives any indication of what she thinks his problem is. Tried to show that she didn't consider he might be upset at her.
Perhaps I worded it poorly, but you really seem hell bent on viewing her role in their relationship in a negative light, when nothing in the game supports this.
EDIT: And going back to the start of this discussion, when you said she wasn't shown as a good friend when they were kids, this is I think the only scene of young her we get outside of the multiple versions of the confession, and she's going to see MC, because she knows he is upset. That seems like a good friend to me.
Last edited:
I didn't express my self properly.
The point of that sentence was not saying she is a bad friend. It was saying that we dont have scene of her being a good friend in the past to make her more likable before meeting her the first time....
But I must say, I'm really annoy at the fact she act like nothing happened(5 years of ghosting), I don't know why, but that's clearly on me.
This game does an extreme amount of handholding concerning the plot, the foreshadowing is completely obvious. Kind of odd to see people viewing Erynn's relationship with MC harshly due to the way everything is so thoroughly spelled out.
She had no idea why MC ghosted her because the thought of her laughing at his declaration was the total opposite of how she felt. Is it really that surprising she hadn't even considered MC's perception of the situation when their view of how it played out was the complete opposite of each other? She was genuinely flattered and likely would've responded in a favorable way had Ethan not interfered.
As far as she's concerned MC just up and ghosted her for 5 years out of the blue without rhyme or reason. If anything she has every right in the world to treat MC like a sack of shit (but im not going to blame a young kid for not having an accurate perception of an event like that nor the maturity to resolve it). MC should be thankful she's even allowing him back into her life and honestly I don't even care that much for her.
Being a VN, attraction > everything else and unfortunately Alexis is #1 in that criteria.
Sidenote.. Am I the only one annoyed at how early this game cuts off relationship paths? Only 3 of the main girls (are the not step-sisters main girls? idk, 1 main girl if not) have any truly adult content. Until the other girls actually have their scenes fleshed out it just seems too early for cut-offs when half the main female cast is being BaDIK-Jill levels of staggered.
She had no idea why MC ghosted her because the thought of her laughing at his declaration was the total opposite of how she felt. Is it really that surprising she hadn't even considered MC's perception of the situation when their view of how it played out was the complete opposite of each other? She was genuinely flattered and likely would've responded in a favorable way had Ethan not interfered.
As far as she's concerned MC just up and ghosted her for 5 years out of the blue without rhyme or reason. If anything she has every right in the world to treat MC like a sack of shit (but im not going to blame a young kid for not having an accurate perception of an event like that nor the maturity to resolve it). MC should be thankful she's even allowing him back into her life and honestly I don't even care that much for her.
Being a VN, attraction > everything else and unfortunately Alexis is #1 in that criteria.
Sidenote.. Am I the only one annoyed at how early this game cuts off relationship paths? Only 3 of the main girls (are the not step-sisters main girls? idk, 1 main girl if not) have any truly adult content. Until the other girls actually have their scenes fleshed out it just seems too early for cut-offs when half the main female cast is being BaDIK-Jill levels of staggered.
Ok, if that's your read, it covers the available data. Thank you. It kinda makes her a bit off putting though, for me, anyway. Like she's a caricature of a future 50s house wife. My grandmother was like that. "what would the neighbors say!" *shudder*
Well... she is a girl that enjoys cooking for her "would be boyfriend", she's old school lol.Ok, if that's your read, it covers the available data. Thank you. It kinda makes her a bit off putting though, for me, anyway. Like she's a caricature of a future 50s house wife. My grandmother was like that. "what would the neighbors say!" *shudder*
On a more serious note i don't think any women would want her cooter being the topic of discussion all around a small town, while she could've handled the blackmail in million different ways, you are also underestimating how hurtful it is to her imo.
Well, let's be real, the tape would be played in a closed courtroom. Once. Years before this story starts. Right before the criminal mastermind that is Ethan went to "pound my ass" real prison for several years. Let's not pretend our June Cleaver handled that correctly, or sanely.
I wasn't being snippy. My god daughter is around this age. This Generation Z, or whatever these post Millennials are called are counseled as early as kindergarten about cyber bullying, illicit photography and all sorts of smart phone/internet related stuff constantly. How to report, what to do if it happens, what your rights are. I'm just saying, barring the need for drama in this story, Melissa would have addressed this long before a prom dress was purchased. Thats all I meant about being real.
Sorry dude, i tried playing nice with you, but i just can't anymore.
My own post said "she could've handled this in million different ways" yet you felt the need to respond sardonically with your obsession on what exactly would be the ONE-REALISTIC-WAY to handle this...
Like every person no matter how educated or not is gonna react in the same exact fashion.
Now seriously go bother someone else.
- Mar 3, 2020
- 1,962
- 4,187
i've been through a kind of similar situation as Erynn minus the sextape (not me personally) and i think Nyx has done a good job of portraying a scared lonely and somewhat naive young girl who has allowed herself through a few silly mistakes be isolated and taken advantage of by a scumbag
- Sep 22, 2019
- 200
- 385
Never underestimate human being's capacity to make really, really terrible decisions. Cults, scams, abusive relationships, patreons that haven't updated since 2019... the list is endless.
From the outside its easy to look at it and say "wow, that's really stupid", but thousands of otherwise rational people make the same mistakes every day.
From the outside its easy to look at it and say "wow, that's really stupid", but thousands of otherwise rational people make the same mistakes every day.
- Dec 4, 2017
- 3,923
- 10,217
Ethan don't even need to lie.
MC could have solved the whole situation whitout any force, all he needed to do was showing himself, problem solved, there never was a need to use force to stop Ethan...no matter how much he deserves it.
More so, he beat a person which was on the ground and not resisting...at this point no court will aknowlege this as selfdefense or the defense of others.
So it would be the MC, which would be charged for assault.
Ethan at best he would get a clap on his hand, as Erynn was the first one who slaps him and he reacts 'only' with a slap and stops there, he never was going to beat her up...