Without any player interaction he is "too good". A God sent body coupled with extraordinary intelligence, educated, bilingual, charming, sexually skilled and athletically competitive. This is probably how every girl imagines her "first" and every mother-in-law imagines her son-in-law. Don't get me wrong, he fits into this game like no other, but that's not standard or regular by any means irl.
considering his background being bi lingual is nothing! his mothers name is Vicari which yes its latin but Italian Latin not Spanish Latin so he should be able to speak 3 languages as an advantage!
he also probably had secondary languages at school! since he is already fluent in Spanish he should have taken french or German ... so if he picked Spanish ... yeah not so smart indeed! just lazy!
As for being smart... for such a smart guy he does get caught up in shitty situations all the time!
a smart dude would be able to read the situation and have either put E-Manual in his place with overwhelming strength or should have stayed out and played in the background!
instead what does he do? he humiliates the dude in front of his peers making an enemy out of a possible future Ally or of someone who was neutral! if he was smart he would make fun of him on 1 vs 1 but when you do it publicly and in front off their peers you gave the dude no chance except retaliate!
Yes it shows courage, but imagine he had done it to someone on a wheelchair? or someone smaller then him? if he is trully that smart that is a sort of bullying flexing his brains like that!
As for body the dude is coming out of his teenager years, except for massive zip issues who could have ruined his face he is at his peek beauty! if he keeps working and being athletic he will hit his peek at 22 years of age! actually we can say with objectivity that Zach as a tighter body then the MC!
as for educated it does not fit his profile! Andre is nor particularly polite and he had no mother to teach him etiquette! i think that what you mean is charm... which is what people blame in Andre!
As for being sexually skilled... well he as been practicing since he was 14 or perhaps 16 with iris so yes compared with the rest who are like 80% virgins, so he is not gifted he is experienced and that is more thanks to iris then an innate quality! he also seems to have experienced with different women who might have helped him to know whats specific to particular women and what is a rule of thumb applicable to almost all women!
so yes he fits into the game but most of it does not come out of his work or skills but granted by luck of his gens his family culture his good luck in finding a good girlfriend with a cool father like Biker John or the specific state of life in which he finds himself!
had the MC been born to poor parents? his 3 parents are all well off to say the least, and he is an only child! if he was for instance Elena brother being so poor? being poor and having to share resources ... he probably would be an high school drop out to help the family!
if he had nowhere to run and had to endure the idiot harassment how open minded and smart would he be instead of a social shut in the result of being constantly bullied ?
if he had stayed with Emily (Em being a cook...) what amazing body would you think he would have? he would probably be overweight (since being bullied over being Erynn "younger" brother means he did not have the self reliance to try out for sports to begin with!)
if he had stayed with a jaded Andre instead of someone who took it in the chin and kept on living would he had learned how be charming and talking to girls?
he is quite regular for the conditions that he was granted, if anything we can say he is quite lazy he should have gotten more with the advantages he has add! being charming and sexually skilled he should have had more girlfriends! he did not had to go hungry to bed or find part time jobs to supplement his family earnings he should be far far better academically and athletically!
he is good at making friends... how come he only left 2 people who remember him on his hometown? he should have had far more and far better friends!
so yes he is standard for his advantages or even bellow par, what kind of idiot has sex with a total stranger risking std´s? he did not even had a fucking condom... smart? the dudes an idiot! always being caught out of left field getting punched and hurt and played like a fiddle for every idiot that wants to use him!
if he had been born poor in an overcrowded family with little living space with no chances to study and work out and he was the MC as we see him then yes, that would make him stand out, actually if he had had to endure bullying and social shame for his family economic position he would be a true hero!