v1900

Well-Known Member
Apr 21, 2020
1,076
2,619
So this is how a friend does it... He tells you... This how i would do it... But Alexis... nope
Yeah, I'll give the reason to you about that. It is always nice to get the courtesy. Still, it does not give Erynn any standing to forbid their relation, in my opinion.
 

Bnshy

Newbie
Nov 20, 2021
84
118
Yes, and that also makes her worst in my book, her time has passed her by and should step aside. How so, she butts in between Lexi and the MC as if either of them had any obligation to her. It could be argued that Lexi has an obligation out of loyalty to her friend but that is just petty and egotistical on Erynn's side. Also, the MC needs some self-respect. How many men in real life actually keep the friendship with the girl that rejected them, very few and I won't comment on them. :KEK:
Alexis definitely knows more about Erynn's feelings after the MC left, than us readers..
That's why she hid the truth....
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrD812

Bnshy

Newbie
Nov 20, 2021
84
118
Exactly, especially when MC was like 13 years old? And Erynn being couple years older, at that age it would be weird, atleast in my opinion.
Exactly, especially when MC was like 13 years old? And Erynn being couple years older, at that age it would be weird, atleast in my opinion.
I don't think she was rejecting him, I believe she just needed time to think about how she truly feels.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrD812

v1900

Well-Known Member
Apr 21, 2020
1,076
2,619
Alexis definitely knows more about Erynn's feelings after the MC left, than us readers..
That's why she hid the truth....
She sure does. But I kind of get that you did not get the point I was making. I might have worded it the wrong way.

I have already said that the argument can be made regarding Lexi's fuck up. "It could be argued that Lexi has an obligation out of loyalty to her friend". But my main point is not that, my main point is that Erynn has no standing to impede them. She has no say in how they live their lives. Best she could hope for was the curtesy of being informed, too bad she didn't get it.

It's related to what the user I responded to was saying, she lost the romantic aspect but that does not mean she lost her friend. I concurred with him but differing on the losing the friendship and added that because she lost the romantic aspect with the MC, she no longer has the right to dictate the MC's romantic life. Just that.
 

Bnshy

Newbie
Nov 20, 2021
84
118
She sure does. But I kind of get that you did not get the point I was making. I might have worded it the wrong way.

I have already said that the argument can be made regarding Lexi's fuck up. "It could be argued that Lexi has an obligation out of loyalty to her friend". But my main point is not that, my main point is that Erynn has no standing to impede them. She has no say in how they live their lives. Best she could hope for was the curtesy of being informed, too bad she didn't get it.

It's related to what the user I responded to was saying, she lost the romantic aspect but that does not mean she lost her friend. I concurred with him but differing on the losing the friendship and added that because she lost the romantic aspect with the MC, she no longer has the right to dictate the MC's romantic life. Just that.
Yup, as a friend Alexis sucks...
She definitely should've said something...
To both the MC and Erynn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrD812 and v1900

nyrek

Active Member
Apr 19, 2021
974
14,241
The "reserved" concept is valid when you first call dibs man. Once you struck out that shit is free border. :KEK:
Similarly, the bros before hoes concept applies to an ass you have already tapped. So Erynn should have had to already fucked the MC. She struck out and is now just having mental wanks.
well, look at it however you want
be it just calling dibs on one end or marrying the chick at the other end
but women don't have that
 
  • Like
Reactions: v1900

anonnyscouse

Active Member
Jul 25, 2020
706
2,050
Alexis certainly knew how Erynn felt, however Alexis felt the same and has done from the start. She's the one who went after MC after the flower incident and kissed him not Erynn. After hearing MC's story she realised that once MC saw Erynn again her chance would be gone, so she took her only chance to make a move. Yes, she could have been honest with MC regarding who she was, but again that could have cost her what she thought was her only chance.
 

Bnshy

Newbie
Nov 20, 2021
84
118
Alexis certainly knew how Erynn felt, however Alexis felt the same and has done from the start. She's the one who went after MC after the flower incident and kissed him not Erynn. After hearing MC's story she realised that once MC saw Erynn again her chance would be gone, so she took her only chance to make a move. Yes, she could have been honest with MC regarding who she was, but again that could have cost her what she thought was her only chance.
I don't think Alexis ever liked the MC in the past..
They knew of each other, that's it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrD812

CrioniC.Syn

Member
Aug 30, 2021
126
208
Then why did she go after him after the Erynn flower incident? She then not only told MC that she wished someone would do something that romantic for her but she then kisses him, does every girl do that with boys they only know of?
It feels like people are playing a different game than me or just can't read. Everyone saying different shit instead of actually mentioning what is in the game.
She didn't kiss him. He stole a kiss from her.
She didn't go after him to comfort him. She was going home and accidentally saw mc sitting against the garage door.

On the other topic. Erynn isn't angry at Alexis for dating mc, she's angry Alexis didn't tell her that mc has been back for several days.
 

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,495
2,207
Yeah, Erynn rejected being MC's girlfriend at the time. That doesn't mean she dislikes him or didn't have feelings for him. Rejecting being his girlfriend doesn't equate to rejecting him entirely.
Please indulge us, show us "Erynn rejected being MC's girlfriend"..... just for the record.
 

anonnyscouse

Active Member
Jul 25, 2020
706
2,050
Please indulge us, show us "Erynn rejected being MC's girlfriend"..... just for the record.
Do we have to go over the same ground again? It's obvious from what we know now that Erynn didn't reject MC. However that IS how the MC saw it from his memory of what happened. Obviously when discussing the situation it is seen through MC's eyes, and whether he was right or wrong at the time he decided to fuck Alexis on the plane (if he does on the playthrough you're playing at this point), Alexis also knows that MC sees it as Erynn rejecting him because he's just told her the story.

Alexis knows the truth at this point (MC doesn't) so she had the choice of telling MC (and potentially not have a chance with him because he's obviously still hung up on Erynn) or not telling him and taking potentially her only chance to get him.
 

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,495
2,207
Do we have to go over the same ground again? It's obvious from what we know now that Erynn didn't reject MC. However that IS how the MC saw it from his memory of what happened. Obviously when discussing the situation it is seen through MC's eyes, and whether he was right or wrong at the time he decided to fuck Alexis on the plane (if he does on the playthrough you're playing at this point), Alexis also knows that MC sees it as Erynn rejecting him because he's just told her the story.

Alexis knows the truth at this point (MC doesn't) so she had the choice of telling MC (and potentially not have a chance with him because he's obviously still hung up on Erynn) or not telling him and taking potentially her only chance to get him.
Show us the screenshot "However that IS how the MC saw it from his memory of what happened ".
I can provide screenshots of "How He Remembered it'.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
4.40 star(s) 293 Votes