UncleFappy

Member
Apr 22, 2025
245
679
I just really hope it's not "Hey, here's your father. I just killed him."
If a parent is gonna die from the Ethan shenanigans, I can see it being Andres who eats it. And that completes his "redemption". Despite the cheating, the raging at Emily, punching MC, he still gives his life to protect MC in the end. Or die helping MC's real dad, for MC's sake. That sort of thing.
 

mike12013

Active Member
Oct 3, 2024
609
1,069
If a parent is gonna die from the Ethan shenanigans, I can see it being Andres who eats it. And that completes his "redemption". Despite the cheating, the raging at Emily, punching MC, he still gives his life to protect MC in the end. Or die helping MC's real dad, for MC's sake. That sort of thing.
John or Andres are my predictions too. The new update actually kinda has me worried, Ep14s ending ends in a much more sinister way then 13, despite the content being effectively the same.

Ep13 - It still seemed like Ethan had it under control and was collected
Ep14 - He's lost his head and is irrational.

I need to get my mod updated and bury myself into some new VNs because the constant replaying isn't helping with the worry :LOL:
 

DIKHammer

Member
Dec 30, 2024
421
654
John or Andres are my predictions too. The new update actually kinda has me worried, Ep14s ending ends in a much more sinister way then 13, despite the content being effectively the same.

Ep13 - It still seemed like Ethan had it under control and was collected
Ep14 - He's lost his head and is irrational.

I need to get my mod updated and bury myself into some new VNs because the constant replaying isn't helping with the worry :LOL:

Yeah that's the problem I don't have anything else right now except AVN's I have already played or ones I am stockpiling to give another or even 3rd shot to because I couldn't get through them the 1st time
 

mike12013

Active Member
Oct 3, 2024
609
1,069
Yeah that's the problem I don't have anything else right now except AVN's I have already played or ones I am stockpiling to give another or even 3rd shot to because I couldn't get through them the 1st time
Yeah i've basically replayed every path in the last week or so. Can't wait to do it again in a. few months :LOL:

I've got a few downloaded that I need to find time for, and a few bookmarked to look at but they're relatively early in production, and I prefer to jump on when there's a decent chunk of content
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LSC82

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
15,923
21,386
John or Andres are my predictions too. The new update actually kinda has me worried, Ep14s ending ends in a much more sinister way then 13, despite the content being effectively the same.

Ep13 - It still seemed like Ethan had it under control and was collected
Ep14 - He's lost his head and is irrational.

I need to get my mod updated and bury myself into some new VNs because the constant replaying isn't helping with the worry :LOL:
Yeah that's why I think after the phone call he is going to get a gun and try to shoot the MC at one point and something is going to go wrong. As I got the feeling he wants to do it or be there when it happens even if it's just him putting a hit on him
 

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,787
5,578
John or Andres are my predictions too. The new update actually kinda has me worried, Ep14s ending ends in a much more sinister way then 13, despite the content being effectively the same.

Ep13 - It still seemed like Ethan had it under control and was collected
Ep14 - He's lost his head and is irrational.

I need to get my mod updated and bury myself into some new VNs because the constant replaying isn't helping with the worry :LOL:
If it does happen then I hope that it's Andres more than John. John still has Iris and Erynn to get to know. I think it would be pretty cruel of Nyx to kill off John, just as Erynn finds out who her father is after all this time.
I'm sure it's no coincidence that Nyx brought Andres back to Madison Springs seeking the MC's forgiveness. What better way than to sacrifice himself to save him, maybe take a bullet for him.
 

mike12013

Active Member
Oct 3, 2024
609
1,069
If it does happen then I hope that it's Andres more than John. John still has Iris and Erynn to get to know. I think it would be pretty cruel of Nyx to kill off John just as Erynn finds out who her father is after all this time.
I'm sure it's no coincidence that Nyx brought Andres back to Madison Springs seeking the MC's forgiveness. What better way than to sacrifice himself to save him, maybe take a bullet for him.
it depends how quick she wants the eventual Erynn scene to happen, cause it's not gonna happen anytime soon if her dad gets murdered, and at the rate episodes are progressing it'll be episode 50 before it happens
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,787
5,578
it depends how quick she wants the eventual Erynn scene to happen, cause it's not gonna happen anytime soon if her dad gets murdered, and at the rate episodes are progressing it'll be episode 50 before it happens
Nyx did say that she hopes to get the Ethan blackmail plot finished by episode 16, where I would imagine any possible death or deaths would happen.
Erynn is the reward for saving the day and slaying the monster. That much has been clear to me since the start. I would call John more her "father" than her "dad" anyone can be a father but it takes being in your childs life to be a dad. Not really his fault I know but still, the fact remains the same.
If John does die I'm sure after the initial upset she would be grateful for the little time she got to spend with him through the MC.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,734
5,754
If it does happen then I hope that it's Andres more than John. John still has Iris and Erynn to get to know. I think it would be pretty cruel of Nyx to kill off John, just as Erynn finds out who her father is after all this time.
I'm sure it's no coincidence that Nyx brought Andres back to Madison Springs seeking the MC's forgiveness. What better way than to sacrifice himself to save him, maybe take a bullet for him.
It would be extremely frustrating if the first thing Erynn got to do with her new father is go to his funeral.

Andres... i'd prefer if he lived, i would like for the MC to reconnect with him(independently from what Emily is gonna do), and having a bit of a choice on your favorite dad between Andres and Santiago.
But him taking a bullet does feel like a tremendous redemption arc.

Lastly, maybe Zach takes the bullet if he has positive points(so far his points have served 0 purpose) plus you didn't punch him? If you deck him someone we like gets shot.

it depends how quick she wants the eventual Erynn scene to happen, cause it's not gonna happen anytime soon if her dad gets murdered, and at the rate episodes are progressing it'll be episode 50 before it happens
It sure would slow any possible romance if we have to go to her dad's funeral, both for her and Iris.

Is this the time skip reason? Someone dies and everyone is sad and going through the motions for roughly a month?
 
Last edited:

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
15,923
21,386
Lastly, maybe Zach takes the bullet if he has positive points(so far his points have served 0 purpose) plus you didn't punch him? If you deck him someone we like gets shot.
would be nice tho Nyx did say you can't stop it so if he is one that does die don't think his point would matter much
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
15,923
21,386
After this update, I doubt that ethan kills anybody. His game is erryn and only erryn. John's only importance to him is that it gets him closer to Erryn. If melissa and John don't hurry up and tell her the truth that'll be a huge fuckup on their part
Honestly I kind of question if anyone is gonna die with Nyx finishing the blackmail plot up soon
 

Ozymandias037

Member
Sep 25, 2023
155
488
After this update, I doubt that ethan kills anybody. His game is erryn and only erryn. John's only importance to him is that it gets him closer to Erryn. If melissa and John don't hurry up and tell her the truth that'll be a huge fuckup on their part
Yeah, I've said this multiple times before but I just don't see Ethan as a killer. He's a sleazebag and a terrible person, but he's a manipulator, not a physical fighter. He sees himself as a mastermind and works behind the scenes; he's not going to dirty his hands by killing anyone. Even if he had it in him (which I don't believe he does) he'd have someone else do it for him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JeSinclair

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
15,923
21,386
Yeah, I've said this multiple times before but I just don't see Ethan as a killer. He's a sleazebag and a terrible person, but he's a manipulator, not a physical fighter. He sees himself as a mastermind and works behind the scenes; he's not going to dirty his hands by killing anyone. Even if he had it in him (which I don't believe he does) he'd have someone else do it for him.
idk I kind of see him as a heat of the moment type of killer not planned or anything especially if you look at the Fake Erynn scene and how Rachael ended up dead with the one of the outfits Erynn has been seen wearing before. Tho you could be right maybe one of his goons took care of her. But dumping her in a alley felt very sloppy to me. So im thinking he killed her.
 

robrize2169

Engaged Member
Oct 8, 2022
2,075
4,173
i hope it's Zach that dies. he overhears Ethan ranting at the mc about everything then taunts him about turning his friend Zach against him so easily cause Zach is a gullible idiot and then Zach gets in front of Ethan and gets shot and dies. and good riddance. before Ethan can turn the gun on mc, he jumps Ethan and gives him another beating leaving him unconscious before calling the cops. Ethan is charged with murdering Zach and later the cops find evidence that he murdered the blonde flight attendant too and he gets the death penalty..just my idea of how to end this annoying story arc.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,734
5,754
Yeah, I've said this multiple times before but I just don't see Ethan as a killer. He's a sleazebag and a terrible person, but he's a manipulator, not a physical fighter. He sees himself as a mastermind and works behind the scenes; he's not going to dirty his hands by killing anyone. Even if he had it in him (which I don't believe he does) he'd have someone else do it for him.
While you have a point, i still think he may have killed Rachel the stewardess... in a "smacked her too hard, didn't even know she was dead" type of incident.

idk I kind of see him as a heat of the moment type of killer not planned or anything especially if you look at the Fake Erynn scene and how Rachael ended up dead with the one of the outfits Erynn has been seen wearing before. Tho you could be right maybe one of his goons took care of her. But dumping her in a alley felt very sloppy to me. So im thinking he killed her.
My theory is that he may have snucked out of whatever club they were into that Alley, Ethan is a guy who has enough money and contacts that he doesn't wait in lines or use the front door of a club.
For example when we see him with Erynn they were in an alley while she was on one of her scorting jobs, they must've come out of the club rather fast, planning to go back in.

Rachel was feisty one, perhaps uncooperative when he started to do his Erynn roleplay and getting rough, so he smacks her, she hits her head in a bad angle, he leaves without even paying attention to her condition.

i hope it's Zach that dies. he overhears Ethan ranting at the mc about everything then taunts him about turning his friend Zach against him so easily cause Zach is a gullible idiot and then Zach gets in front of Ethan and gets shot and dies. and good riddance. before Ethan can turn the gun on mc, he jumps Ethan and gives him another beating leaving him unconscious before calling the cops. Ethan is charged with murdering Zach and later the cops find evidence that he murdered the blonde flight attendant too and he gets the death penalty..just my idea of how to end this annoying story arc.
Solid theory.
 

UncleFappy

Member
Apr 22, 2025
245
679
Yeah, I've said this multiple times before but I just don't see Ethan as a killer. He's a sleazebag and a terrible person, but he's a manipulator, not a physical fighter. He sees himself as a mastermind and works behind the scenes; he's not going to dirty his hands by killing anyone. Even if he had it in him (which I don't believe he does) he'd have someone else do it for him.
Ethan doesn't necessarily have to be the killer. It could be the goons he has with him. Or a hired thug to rough up John/MC/whoever, and they go too far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

DIKHammer

Member
Dec 30, 2024
421
654
idk I kind of see him as a heat of the moment type of killer not planned or anything especially if you look at the Fake Erynn scene and how Rachael ended up dead with the one of the outfits Erynn has been seen wearing before. Tho you could be right maybe one of his goons took care of her. But dumping her in a alley felt very sloppy to me. So im thinking he killed her.

THe mommy Brooke quote about Rachel getting left near a dumpster is quite odd however, I think Nyx is trolling there and it was Ethan
 
4.40 star(s) 306 Votes