Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
15,958
21,439
I feel like a prick I only read erryns letter and respond on her path or my messy path.

I forget which path but one of them I pick tori, on that same path I wont even help layla with her Spanish assignment
not reading the Erynn letter and replying back for me is almost as bad as not helping her in the Alley it's kind of hard not to do.
 
  • Heart
Reactions: LSC82

valbitterb

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2022
1,130
3,633
If a parent is gonna die from the Ethan shenanigans, I can see it being Andres who eats it. And that completes his "redemption". Despite the cheating, the raging at Emily, punching MC, he still gives his life to protect MC in the end. Or die helping MC's real dad, for MC's sake. That sort of thing.
John or Andres are my predictions too. The new update actually kinda has me worried, Ep14s ending ends in a much more sinister way then 13, despite the content being effectively the same.
If it does happen then I hope that it's Andres more than John.
Andres... i'd prefer if he lived, i would like for the MC to reconnect with him(independently from what Emily is gonna do), and having a bit of a choice on your favorite dad between Andres and Santiago.
But him taking a bullet does feel like a tremendous redemption arc.
I liked the Andres scene. Complete opposite to Zach. Tail tucked between his legs, understood he fucked up and hugely. And he wants to make amends however he can, even if MC and Emily won't accept it. He got the hug when he left.
Andres got a hug from me on my Erynn save

HOW SOME ANDRES SYMPATHIZERS HOPE IT ENDS FOR HIM AND THE MC ...

View attachment Andres Positive.mp4

















HOW OTHER ANDRES SYMPATHIZERS HOPE IT ENDS FOR HIM AND THE MC ...

View attachment Andres Negative.mp4
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,842
3,551
I did it in one save, but even the game seems to tell you that it's a bad idea
Yeah, even MC's running buddy is basically like wtf.

Didnt he throw the letter away? Unless Erryn really likes going through garbage, Im not seeing how she'll know about that letter. Besides there's already the john timebomb that's going to explode on MC through little to no fault of his own
 

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,787
5,580
Didnt he throw the letter away? Unless Erryn really likes going through garbage, Im not seeing how she'll know about that letter.
Do you really think that Nyx wouldn't find a way for Erynn to see that the MC finally got one of her letters and threw it away? She absolutely will if you chose to do that.
Even on a path where she's mad at the MC because of kissing her while seeing Lexi I still read it and will do a response letter. Hopefully it will be a way for them to at least become friends again. Even if we don't get the same opportunity to help her.
 

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,787
5,580
he didn't say he never got them, just that he never read them/threw them away coz he was angry at her
But still the fact that he now had the opportunity to read one but instead threw it away is sure to sting. Causing an already pissed off Erynn to double down or a friendly Erynn to become less so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

UncleFappy

Member
Apr 22, 2025
246
683
It just struck me. Lots of "finally the Ethan drama is going to end, and we can go do nice slice of life stuff" sentiment.

...

The Lucas drama is still ongoing. Thats totally who stole Layla's hoodie. Probably smelling it at home like a creep.

Ethan 2.0 is incoming, my guys. :geek:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: valbitterb

Dr.TSoni

Engaged Member
May 20, 2022
2,091
6,654
It just struck me. Lots of "finally the Ethan drama is going to end, and we can go do nice slice of life stuff" sentiment.

...

The Lucas drama is still ongoing. Thats totally who stole Layla's hoodie. Probably smelling it at home like a creep.

Ethan 2.0 is incoming, my guys. :geek:
I'll be honest, he seems like a better enemy than Ethan.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,842
3,551
Do you really think that Nyx wouldn't find a way for Erynn to see that the MC finally got one of her letters and threw it away? She absolutely will if you chose to do that.
Even on a path where she's mad at the MC because of kissing her while seeing Lexi I still read it and will do a response letter. Hopefully it will be a way for them to at least become friends again. Even if we don't get the same opportunity to help her.
there are other minefields in the game without the manufactured bullshit of a letter from years ago breaking erryn's heart
 

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,787
5,580
It just struck me. Lots of "finally the Ethan drama is going to end, and we can go do nice slice of life stuff" sentiment.

...

The Lucas drama is still ongoing. Thats totally who stole Layla's hoodie. Probably smelling it at home like a creep.

Ethan 2.0 is incoming, my guys. :geek:
It's all good Lucas never leaves the park, he lives there like a homeless person. :ROFLMAO: Though I do have a feeling that he may actually be who kicked/pushed over the MC's bike at school. We are blaming Zach as he's the obvious choice when in fact it was Lucas, especially after seeing the MC with Layla in the morning.
 
4.40 star(s) 306 Votes