LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,692
8,039
637
We've had a lot more backstory and progression with Alexis than the majority of the ones you just mentioned, so I suppose you find their paths just as empty and unsatisfying... right?
Completely disagree with this statement...
Time on screen doesn't equal development, which Alexis had very little.
Not when your backstory can be summed up as "she's friends with Erynn and once kissed the MC".

Layla is a very happy, tension free route, a virgin who meets a guy and they start dating.
And still there's development in her getting more and more with him and deciding this guy is the one, gradual progression until she takes the big step.

The only tension with Alexis is external, if you are planning to jump ship to Erynn, Iris or Nikki.

"Sidechick" Gabi gets more actual development than her :p
A college girl finds a guy she's been sitting talking to for hours attractive, happens to be a guy her best friend sings praises about even whilst he's been absent. Is it that farfetched that she hooks up with him?

Also, you say at the beginning she wasn't happy about the stolen kiss, but by the end she seems elated because they ended up together, almost as if it's fate.
It's not, but this action and subsequent ones also made her a bit of shitty friend, something i think it is worth exploring more in depth.
Also i would love to try and put together "mile high club" within an hour with the "no dating history" super romantic chick, but for the life of me they don't go well together.

Sure, she likes it now as a fairytale story, no signs that she was thinking about it when she entered the plane.
 

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
737
1,346
306
Completely disagree with this statement...
Time on screen doesn't equal development, which Alexis had very little.
Not when your backstory can be summed up as "she's friends with Erynn and once kissed the MC".

Layla is a very happy, tension free route, a virgin who meets a guy and they start dating.
And still there's development in her getting more and more with him and deciding this guy is the one, gradual progression until she takes the big step.

The only tension with Alexis is external, if you are planning to jump ship to Erynn, Iris or Nikki.

"Sidechick" Gabi gets more actual development than her :p
You can disagree all you like, but it's an objective fact.
There is nothing known about Elena and Gabi's past and little to no progress beyond being a boy toy for the latter.
The only backstory for Layla is some guy wanted to date her, she refused and he never relented and started stalking her, but at least she has development.
We've just learned a small part of Val's backstory, but her progress is a slow burn.

It's funny how you mention Alexis' tension is all external, like that isn't the case with all LIs.
Erynn has the blackmail, Alexis, Iris, Mel
Layla has the stalker, Alexis, Elena, Val, Gabi, Tori
Elena has no time to date between cheerleading and babysitting, no need to mention Layla

In fact, I can't think of a relationship in this game where the problems are internal between MC and his partner. All the problems come from outside forces. We haven't even been properly introduced to the next whirlwind of tension, Mr Zane Donovan.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,692
8,039
637
You can disagree all you like, but it's an objective fact.
There is nothing known about Elena and Gabi's past and little to no progress beyond being a boy toy for the latter.
The only backstory for Layla is some guy wanted to date her, she refused and he never relented and started stalking her, but at least she has development.
We've just learned a small part of Val's backstory, but her progress is a slow burn.

It's funny how you mention Alexis' tension is all external, like that isn't the case with all LIs.
Erynn has the blackmail, Alexis, Iris, Mel
Layla has the stalker, Alexis, Elena, Val, Gabi, Tori
Elena has no time to date between cheerleading and babysitting, no need to mention Layla

In fact, I can't think of a relationship in this game where the problems are internal between MC and his partner. All the problems come from outside forces. We haven't even been properly introduced to the next whirlwind of tension, Mr Zane Donovan.
Elena doesn't have much of a backstory that is true, she's just poor and has a more "difficult life".
But she has a current story, she fell in love with the same guy as her BFF, this creates tension and story (yet to fully play out).
PS: A story i don't like btw, it feels forced to be handled in the worst way.

Gabi however was married, most likely to the MCs father, the marriage was bad and they are getting divorced, she's a woman on the rebound, entering a forbidden relationship with a student, majorly out of control with jealosy.
And it's gonna get worst, she still has no idea how bad it's gonna get.
That's proper backstory set up and development, she was out drinking and eager to fuck because of her bad marriage, she keeps doing the "wrong thing" because of the end of her marriage made her vulnerable...
Do you understand now how a good backstory can integrate with what is going on now and can add depth to a story?
Alexis having more than that is a "fact" you say? :p

This is not what i meant by "external".
The Erynn path has problems that are intrinsical to it.
Ethan, maybe Zane, John, getting over her trauma... these problems are intrinsical to every Erynn playthrough, they are always there.
And she has external problems... the other chicks.

Alexis only has the other chicks, for Alexis to have a problem you have to show interest in Erynn, Iris or Val... there's no problems self contained to her path.
 
Last edited:

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
737
1,346
306
But she has a current story, she fell in love with the same guy as her BFF, this creates tension and story (yet to fully play out).
Who does that remind me of? :unsure:

I could swear that's exactly the same thing happening on Alexis' path which you criticize as being shallow and empty...

Alexis having more than that is a "fact" you say?
Notice how I said she had more than the "majority"? Guess not.

I'm gonna drop it here because you keep editing posts while I rebut and I'm too busy watching Prison Break.
 
Last edited:

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,692
8,039
637
Who does that remind me of? :unsure:

I could swear that's exactly the same thing happening on Alexis' path which you criticize as being shallow and empty...
The edit that i dislike this storyline(who doesn't?) came too late...
But it's still more stuff than "i feel bad about what i did>let's start dating again".

Notice how I said she had more than the "majority"? Guess not.
You explicitly mentioned Elena and GABI as having less story than Alexis, that is also a fact ;)
Admitting you were wrong is not a sin :cool:
 

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
737
1,346
306
The edit that i dislike this storyline(who doesn't?) came too late...
But it's still more stuff than "i feel bad about what i did>let's start dating again".


You explicitly mentioned Elena and GABI as having less story than Alexis, that is also a fact ;)
Gabi does have less backstory, we know she's married, likely to Santi and that she was an Athlete. That's it...

Alexis we know is Erynn's best friend, they hung out occasionally as kids, they shared a first kiss and she was a volleyball player until she was injured.

You seem to take umbrage that we don't know who slept with her previously in the 5 years MC was away, so we never saw what made her who she is, when we know even less about Gabi.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,692
8,039
637
Gabi does have less backstory, we know she's married, likely to Santi and that she was an Athlete. That's it...

Alexis we know is Erynn's best friend, they hung out occasionally as kids, they shared a first kiss and she was a volleyball player until she was injured.

You seem to take umbrage that we don't know who slept with her previously in the 5 years MC was away, so we never saw what made her who she is, when we know even less about Gabi.
Not a great Prison Break episode i'm guessing...

Gabi has a famous best friend in Ximena(i also would love to see them interact more and learn how they met), but that's just fluff at the moment and haven't made much impact on the story.
Just like Alexis being a former volleyball player hasn't made much impact on the story, she plays volleyball once, great.
It's not a matter of simply listing stuff.

Gabi's failed marriage shapes her current headspace and actions, that is pretty clear, the end of the marriage left her in a vulnerable state, ready for the MC to pick up the scraps.
And it's gonna get even more important when Santiago-Gabi gets revealed.

I take umbrage on the fact that Alexis last 5 years are a blank slate, and that nothing we learn about her gives further significance to her actions.
Other than the stolen kiss she didn't even like at first i guess.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Justaphase

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
737
1,346
306
Not a great Prison Break episode i'm guessing...
Season 5, kinda hit and miss...

All the things that pique your interest in Gabi's story can be compared to things that happen on Alexis' path.
Gabi has a famous friend? Alexis' dad says hi!
Gabi is in a taboo relationship with a student? Alexis is fucking her best friends crush!

You still keep dancing around the fact that not only does Alexis have more backstory, more current progress and probably more future progress centred around Ethan/Erynn and her now having to deal with the fallout of her boyfriend being suspended by her mother. The only "external issues" seem like it's not just girls anymore...
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LSC82

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,692
8,039
637
Season 5, kinda hit and miss...

All the things that pique your interest in Gabi's story can be compared to things that happen on Alexis' path.
Gabi has a famous friend? Alexis' dad says hi!
Gabi is in a taboo relationship with a student? Alexis is fucking her best friends crush!

You still keep dancing around the fact that not only does Alexis have more backstory, more current progress and probably more future progress centred around Ethan/Erynn and her now having to deal with the fallout of her boyfriend being suspended by her mother. The only "external issues" seem like it's not just girls anymore...
You have serious comprehension problems my friend...

I just said the Ximena friendship has been irrelevant(can't blame edits this time), just like Alexis dad being famous hasn't affected anything, justifies the big house and expensive cars i guess...
Alexis dating the guy Erynn loves makes the scenario where Erynn is still in love and pining for her friends BF more interesting, not relevant for a solo Alexis run.
And personal opinion, it's making Erynn more interesting, not Alexis, Erynn is the one who has to act completely different because of her feelings, Alexis just acts normally.
Even good scenes for the rivalry, like the beach scene, had no consequences long term, she resets to default(might be worth taking a look at that on the new script).

If Alexis gets more depth in the future that's great, anything we can learn more and help SHAPE THE STORY, awesome.
What was her relationship to Ethan? Does the Erynn and MC closeness bother(the poster should be an opportunity) her? What does she think of Zane? Anything...
Cause right now...
I have been waiting for these things, but Nyx is either delaying it forever or has no plans for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Justaphase

byaaahh

Active Member
Feb 3, 2018
737
1,346
306
You have serious comprehension problems my friend...

I just said the Ximena friendship has been irrelevant(can't blame edits this time), just like Alexis dad being famous hasn't affected anything, justifies the big house and expensive cars i guess...
I never said it was impactful, only that it piqued your interest. We have no idea if or how Gabi's relationship with Ximena will be explored, will you be as judgemental to that path if we don't discover how they met? I'm guessing you are a Gabi fan as you seem to look past the fact we don't really know what makes her tick, but you dislike the Alexis path because we don't know what she's been up to for the last 5 years...

Alexis dating the guy Erynn loves makes the scenario where Erynn is still in love and pining for her friends BF more interesting, not relevant for a solo Alexis run.
Well since there are two solo runs for Alexis, it makes it 50% relevant.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,692
8,039
637
I never said it was impactful, only that it piqued your interest. We have no idea if or how Gabi's relationship with Ximena will be explored, will you be as judgemental to that path if we don't discover how they met? I'm guessing you are a Gabi fan as you seem to look past the fact we don't really know what makes her tick, but you dislike the Alexis path because we don't know what she's been up to for the last 5 years...
What part of "it's just fluff", "Irrelevant", "Has no impact" sounded like it peaked my interest?
But if you are gonna use "volleyball" as a point for Alexis backstory, i think Ximena is worth mentioning.

I do like Gabi and i look forward to learning more of Ximena and Gabi together(even the MC asked how they met, but Gabi dodged the question), if nothing comes and that's the last we see of them together i will be disappointed, if we get some wild interactions, i will be happy.
Right now Ximena is fluff, but can gain relevance in the future if it gets more development.
Pretty simple isn't it?

I know what is making Gabi tick and i've explained it numerous times by now... last time, don't ask me again.
Gabi is going through a tough divorce, she found solace and cock on a young boy during a night of drinking, nothing very deep here.
This boy happened to be a student from her school(we can guess there's more to come, but that's all she knows at this point) which makes the relationship forbidden.
In her vulnerable state(her failed marriage impacting current events) she keeps going back to him.
Her vulnerability impacts her better judgement, she keeps making mistakes and is becoming increasingly attached and jealous of this boy.
The backstory shapes current events.
If you still aren't getting how her backstory enhances and explains current events, just ignore this section, please...

I dislike the Alexis path because i think Alexis lacks depth as a character and the path is low on conflict and tension.
Adding extra depth and conflict would be a good thing for me, it would make more entertaining.
A tumultous backstory could be a way to do that, it's not the only way, but a possible way to add that.

With this perceived lack of depth and this big blank space of 5 years just infront of me, you bet i wanna fill that with as much shit as possible :p
Of course that doesn't sit well with people like you who enjoy having a "problem free route".



Well since there are two solo runs for Alexis, it makes it 50% relevant.
Fair enough lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
3,536
4,347
378
The only LIs who have backstory are Erynn, Iris, Nikki (we see her ex) and Valeria's was recently explored. There's nothing for Alexis, Elena or Cara. Layla could go either way as we know she has a stalker.

I don't think we really need "The Silmarillion" of every LIs past.
Elena has a backstory, she spends most of her time either hanging with Layla or taking care of her brothers. Her reason for not having a love life and explained pretty well methinks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Elduriel

DIKHammer

Well-Known Member
Dec 30, 2024
1,033
1,809
221
I doubt that Nyx would have it so that Alexis and Nathan slept together. Even if it was before the MC the anti-NTR crowd would go ballistic, well not that Nyx would care she likes winding people up honestly. I just don't think that it would fit this game or the Lexi path very well.
He most likely saw her on one of her trips to see Lakeyn, just like the MC did.
at most he slept with Lakeyn maybe


I wonder if Dani's hit-and-run incident will be Intertwined with any of the storylines.

Is Ethan or any of his family members involved? Is Madison Spring Old Perv involved? Is anyone the MC knows involved?

Pure Speculation: Did Santi cover up for Marauders' MVP Gatling?

Nyx (through Darryl) seems to be hinting at some kind of cover up for someone influential and powerful.


View attachment 5091988

View attachment 5091992
Andres probably, piece of shit
 
  • Wow
Reactions: valbitterb

Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
7,717
16,795
803
I doubt that Nyx would have it so that Alexis and Nathan slept together. Even if it was before the MC the anti-NTR crowd would go ballistic, well not that Nyx would care she likes winding people up honestly. I just don't think that it would fit this game or the Lexi path very well.
He most likely saw her on one of her trips to see Lakeyn, just like the MC did.
while Slexi wasn't a virgin (supposedly, no way she would give it up in a toilet :ROFLMAO: ... and she again supposedly never sucked a dick if I remember right from internal monologue), so I doubt she slept around much, so she would remember if she fucked Nathan. But I'm kinda curious if her previous partner(s) will be brought in to the story, could lead to soo much additional intertwining.
 

Justaphase

Engaged Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
3,189
10,791
599
But I'm kinda curious if her previous partner(s) will be brought in to the story, could lead to soo much additional intertwining.
I doubt it at the point in the story. I do think that Nyx should have fleshed out Lexi's character a bit more. It's easy to get on to her path as she literally throws herself at you twice, well three times if you've accepted once.
In a way Tori get's alot of hate for her quite pushy interactions with the MC. Inviting him to go and fuck in some alley, but that's not much different to Lexi really. :ROFLMAO:
 

Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
7,717
16,795
803
I doubt it at the point in the story. I do think that Nyx should have fleshed out Lexi's character a bit more. It's easy to get on to her path as she literally throws herself at you twice, well three times if you've accepted once.
In a way Tori get's alot of hate for her quite pushy interactions with the MC. Inviting him to go and fuck in some alley, but that's not much different to Lexi really. :ROFLMAO:
yeah Slexi was the easy LI, sort of, besides the Erynn drama. And I don't particularly want that kinda new branch anyway, not that it would bother me in itself, just would be more shit on our plate that will never get resolved (see Lucas, who was never heard of again but could still come back)
 

Dr.TSoni

Engaged Member
May 20, 2022
3,625
10,784
637
I doubt it at the point in the story. I do think that Nyx should have fleshed out Lexi's character a bit more. It's easy to get on to her path as she literally throws herself at you twice, well three times if you've accepted once.
In a way Tori get's alot of hate for her quite pushy interactions with the MC. Inviting him to go and fuck in some alley, but that's not much different to Lexi really. :ROFLMAO:
I think Lexi gains affection with the softer approach and the fact that you can easily reject her offers, whereas with Tori you almost have to dive into Layla's path to avoid her XD
 
4.40 star(s) 314 Votes