LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,728
8,143
637
I think Erynn makes an okay friend, if a little naïve and seems to have a really hard time telling people no. I also think she makes a terrible girlfriend for the same reasons. She falls for Ethan's shit time and time again and once she's finally realizes he's a classic douche, he's got something on her and is trapped. Of course, being the intelligent, mature person she is, she's gonna deal with it herself, and not involve anyone around her, like Melissa. Melissa knows what kind of damage a sex tape could do to Erynn, no matter the field she was trying to go into.

Alexis checking on MC after the confession was sweeter than almost anything Erynn has done story wise. Erynn showing up later to check on MC after he starts avoiding her (how much time passed?) is just her being too little, too late. Of course, we know from the letters she wrote that she did make a considerable effort to try to patch things up. It still doesn't scream romance to me at all, it's just a friend missing her other friend.

The only time I see what I'd consider romance with MC is the photoshoot, where it's a forced interaction (you make the choice as the player, but if you're interested in Erynn, you're not gonna leave her hanging here). All the other times are the MC taking a step (or the rare case early on where she makes a move and it's a huge mistake to accept it) and then getting frustrated sexually because she can't reciprocate.
She was a teen meeting new people on a new school, a teen we know turned a lot of heads and grabbed a lot of attention, it's unrealistic to expect that she would just turn everyone away.

Erynn stays behind to try and shut Ethan down, you can argue wether that was the right decision or not, but she was put on the spot and had to make this call in the heat of the moment... then she goes to see him the same day, right after he locked himself in his room and Emily tells her not to.
Even before the recent letter much was said of the effort she put into reconnecting with him, how much she thought about him and wanted him back in her life, on this part the MC is definitely to blame for ignoring her and making as hard as humanly possible to reconnect.

Neither girl thought of him sexually before that day(probably why there's so many scenes of Erynn thinking about how he grew up nicely), he was a little kid for them...

Erynn is slow to progress for 2 things:
1-She's scared to lose her friend, she worries that if they date and it doesn't work out it will lead to a cold and distant relationship, for her this is a real worry, she wants to remain close to him always, so this is something she must take into consideration, the risk vs reward(this was more a thing early on then now, but still a little bit).
2- Her bad experience surrounding sex, she had sex and it led to years of torment... she was left traumatized by the experience, so jumping into bed isn't something she just does.

Every small step of gaining comfort around the MC is character development/progress in her case.
 
Last edited:

Dessolos

Board Buff
Jul 25, 2017
19,832
27,975
936
I think Erynn makes an okay friend, if a little naïve and seems to have a really hard time telling people no. I also think she makes a terrible girlfriend for the same reasons. She falls for Ethan's shit time and time again and once she's finally realizes he's a classic douche, he's got something on her and is trapped. Of course, being the intelligent, mature person she is, she's gonna deal with it herself, and not involve anyone around her, like Melissa. Melissa knows what kind of damage a sex tape could do to Erynn, no matter the field she was trying to go into.

Alexis checking on MC after the confession was sweeter than almost anything Erynn has done story wise. Erynn showing up later to check on MC after he starts avoiding her (how much time passed?) is just her being too little, too late. Of course, we know from the letters she wrote that she did make a considerable effort to try to patch things up. It still doesn't scream romance to me at all, it's just a friend missing her other friend.

The only time I see what I'd consider romance with MC is the photoshoot, where it's a forced interaction (you make the choice as the player, but if you're interested in Erynn, you're not gonna leave her hanging here). All the other times are the MC taking a step (or the rare case early on where she makes a move and it's a huge mistake to accept it) and then getting frustrated sexually because she can't reciprocate.
id have to disagree even tho you do make some good points . I still think she would make a wonderful girlfriend if there was no Ethan stuff to deal with. There is some moments of her driving him to him to school , making him food , then just some great chemistry when they are being playful. All of that makes her feel like a good girlfriend to me and why I give her on my personal LI ranking Virtual girlfriend cause she gives me that girlfriend feeling. I give very few LI that ranking another would be Alexis.

I personally don't even blame her for falling for Ethan's trap because when the MC left. He faked changing into a better and nice person to manipulate her then he is the reason she lost all of her friends but Alexis ( tho she almost lost Alexis as a friend too). I would fall for that too most likely especially when she is young.

But I also don't full disagree with you cause the Ethan stuff does make her seem not like a good choice for a friend or girlfriend. But when you look past the Ethan stuff and when she can just be her self than that's when I see as just as good as a girlfriend as Alexis personally. But then it also comes down to what you value personally. Her lack of sexual progress isn't a big deal for at all as I prefer non sexual moments most of the time anyways as I find them more fun.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NadaMucho

jadepaladin

Engaged Member
Mar 9, 2020
3,497
7,279
646
id have to disagree even tho you do make some good points . I still think she would make a wonderful girlfriend if there was no Ethan stuff to deal with. There is some moments of her driving him to him to school , making him food , then just some great chemistry when they are being playful. All of that makes her feel like a good girlfriend to me and why I give her on my personal LI ranking Virtual girlfriend cause she gives me that girlfriend feeling. I give very few LI that ranking another would be Alexis.

I personally don't even blame her for falling for Ethan's trap because when the MC left. He faked changing into a better and nice person to manipulate her then he is the reason she lost all of her friends but Alexis ( tho she almost lost Alexis as a friend too). I would fall for that too most likely especially when she is young.

But I also don't full disagree with you cause the Ethan stuff does make her seem not like a good choice for a friend or girlfriend. But when you look past the Ethan stuff and when she can just be her self than that's when I see as just as good as a girlfriend as Alexis personally. But then it also comes down to what you value personally. Her lack of sexual progress isn't a big deal for at all as I prefer non sexual moments most of the time anyways as I find them more fun.
If there was no Ethan stuff to deal with it would be a completely different story. Back then, did she even see MC sexually? It's possible he would have been able to turn things into some kind of romance but given how he reacted to what happened, I don't think he possessed the necessary maturity. So now we have a MC that doesn't leave, but I don't see Erynn just accepting his confession. I see her being confused and then friend zoning him.

All the small things that happen with her (sitting in his lap while he plays witcher, etc) are things that can happen between friends, it doesn't mean much romantically. Hell, a lot of her content happens regardless if you are pursuing her or not, she's just a playful type of person it seems.

Erynn reminds me of Marissa from The OC. The poster pretty girl but always so surrounded by drama that she should never be anyone's first.
 

Dessolos

Board Buff
Jul 25, 2017
19,832
27,975
936
All the small things that happen with her (sitting in his lap while he plays witcher, etc) are things that can happen between friends, it doesn't mean much romantically. Hell, a lot of her content happens regardless if you are pursuing her or not, she's just a playful type of person it seems.
Yeah that's why I say it depends on how you look at it personally and what you value. I personally love those moments and is what makes her character so good for me. Yeah I don't count the Witcher thing as a romantic moment that her just being herself. I count the 1000 questions game ( not the first time) , driving him to school , making him food like she his is second mother those moments / scenes on the romance path or not as romantic moments with her , then of course all the the stuff that happens if you only on her path.

If there was no Ethan stuff to deal with it would be a completely different story. Back then, did she even see MC sexually? It's possible he would have been able to turn things into some kind of romance but given how he reacted to what happened, I don't think he possessed the necessary maturity. So now we have a MC that doesn't leave, but I don't see Erynn just accepting his confession. I see her being confused and then friend zoning him.
I was more refering to no Ethan when he returned but no in the past but no without Ethan I don't so either. Because he is the catalyst for her feeling for him if I recall correctly. Because the bad confessions got him to act out then he left. I recall a conversation or thought that Erynn didn't start to realize how much she liked the MC until he was gone.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,728
8,143
637
If there was no Ethan stuff to deal with it would be a completely different story. Back then, did she even see MC sexually? It's possible he would have been able to turn things into some kind of romance but given how he reacted to what happened, I don't think he possessed the necessary maturity. So now we have a MC that doesn't leave, but I don't see Erynn just accepting his confession. I see her being confused and then friend zoning him.

All the small things that happen with her (sitting in his lap while he plays witcher, etc) are things that can happen between friends, it doesn't mean much romantically. Hell, a lot of her content happens regardless if you are pursuing her or not, she's just a playful type of person it seems.

Erynn reminds me of Marissa from The OC. The poster pretty girl but always so surrounded by drama that she should never be anyone's first.
I don't think she did, he was a little brother to her, she loved playing with him but (as we recently found out)had no clue what her "tickling assaults" were doing to the boy.
How things procede from there i have no idea, how does she handle trying not to break his heart?
His attempt itself was a clumsy move born out of jealousy, because he thought he was losing her.

As adults she is attracted to him, many scenes indicate that, scenes where she catches herself staring and things like that(even her first appearance back in Ep3 has been changed to show her looking at him before she notices who he is).
But she truly is scared of ruining the friendship and driving him away, last time they were in this position they spent 5 years without seeing each other.

Some friends are touchy feely people, Erynn certainly so... with her love of tickling, waking him up, kisses on the cheek...
The Witcher scene however... it may have started innocent and friendly but went into another direction until COCKBLOCKULA showed up.

It does come down to wether you like to save the princess, see the relationship growing and developing... or simply stay problem free.
 

Kaskaze

Active Member
May 1, 2022
771
1,211
267
I don't think she did, he was a little brother to her, she loved playing with him but (as we recently found out)had no clue what her "tickling assaults" were doing to the boy.
How things procede from there i have no idea, how does she handle trying not to break his heart?
His attempt itself was a clumsy move born out of jealousy, because he thought he was losing her.

As adults she is attracted to him, many scenes indicate that, scenes where she catches herself staring and things like that(even her first appearance back in Ep3 has been changed to show her looking at him before she notices who he is).
But she truly is scared of ruining the friendship and driving him away, last time they were in this position they spent 5 years without seeing each other.

Some friends are touchy feely people, Erynn certainly so... with her love of tickling, waking him up, kisses on the cheek...
The Witcher scene however... it may have started innocent and friendly but went into another direction until COCKBLOCKULA showed up.

It does come down to wether you like to save the princess, see the relationship growing and developing... or simply stay problem free.
This remake will be very interesting and important in how Erynn is perceived. If we get to the point where the entire remake is completed, I am sure that many people will change their minds about Erynn
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,728
8,143
637
This remake will be very interesting and important in how Erynn is perceived. If we get to the point where the entire remake is completed, I am sure that many people will change their minds about Erynn
I agree.
I think how affected Erynn was by the MCs departure, how desperate she was to fix things... didn't land with everyone...
Maybe show her in pain earlier, in that flashback, show her crying with Melissa, beginning to write one of her letters...
We are told many times that she was in pain, but we didn't actually get to actually see it until recently...

And as you know, showing beats telling ;)
 
Last edited:

Warscared

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2021
1,969
12,977
624
I think Erynn makes an okay friend, if a little naïve and seems to have a really hard time telling people no. I also think she makes a terrible girlfriend for the same reasons. She falls for Ethan's shit time and time again and once she's finally realizes he's a classic douche, he's got something on her and is trapped. Of course, being the intelligent, mature person she is, she's gonna deal with it herself, and not involve anyone around her, like Melissa. Melissa knows what kind of damage a sex tape could do to Erynn, no matter the field she was trying to go into.

Alexis checking on MC after the confession was sweeter than almost anything Erynn has done story wise. Erynn showing up later to check on MC after he starts avoiding her (how much time passed?) is just her being too little, too late. Of course, we know from the letters she wrote that she did make a considerable effort to try to patch things up. It still doesn't scream romance to me at all, it's just a friend missing her other friend.

The only time I see what I'd consider romance with MC is the photoshoot, where it's a forced interaction (you make the choice as the player, but if you're interested in Erynn, you're not gonna leave her hanging here). All the other times are the MC taking a step (or the rare case early on where she makes a move and it's a huge mistake to accept it) and then getting frustrated sexually because she can't reciprocate.
everything you just said makes perfect sense but leaves out a very determining detail...
she is hot and a model while the best feature of the MC is that he has a very punchable face
she passes and guys get hard on´s the MC passes and... well i guess guys also get hard on´s!

Back then, did she even see MC sexually?
I hope not the MC was 12 and she wants to be a school teacher while already having a fairly successful modeling career...
she is passing on very strong predator vibes... and while this shit can pass for an attractive girl
when she reaches 40 or she gains 100 pounds whatever comes 1st...
some girls get preggers and just blow up the fat grenade
everyone will be saying "obviously! were you all blind to how she salivated around young pubescent boys?"

The Witcher scene however... it may have started innocent and friendly but went into another direction until COCKBLOCKULA showed up.
dude don't be that guy, Emily is too young to be a grandmother and also she wants 2 grandchildren
if her 2 "kids" hitch it up she halves the chances of being a grandmother when the appropriate time comes
One is a college girl currently being brainwashed with Woke shit that states that any manifestation of male libido is rape!
The other one is a highschooler that is so stupid that his only talent is running,
as we can clearly see how fast he runned away from her when things got hard!

We also have not debated EM´s abandonment issues...
her true love refused to be with her, he probably had better things to do... or people...to do!
her husband said "fuck it" and just left due to all the bullshit she made him went trough!
and her own kid when 3 older assholes bullied him a little dropped her like the little coward that he is!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: valbitterb

Dr.TSoni

Engaged Member
May 20, 2022
3,688
10,942
637
Iris has always been a mixed bag for me liked her in the flashback , then was not a fan of the short hair vs long. Then I kind of not a fan of how she acts when the MC is around the other girls or tries to tempt him to cheat ( like with the garage scene.) Tho I guess that depends if the MC is single or not on your save.
But except for Lexi, is Iris aware that MC is in a relationship?

You are entitled to your opinion and preference...just lets keep it civil and not descend into pointless waifu wars.
What do you mean no waifu wars, so what are we doing here? XD

Dude, she wants to be a teacher. A sex tape released would permanently kill that career for her, not to mention damage her reputation in general. Willingly or not, criminally or not. The world isn't fair about this shit.
She takes practically naked photos, that train has already left

I think Erynn makes an okay friend, if a little naïve and seems to have a really hard time telling people no. I also think she makes a terrible girlfriend for the same reasons. She falls for Ethan's shit time and time again and once she's finally realizes he's a classic douche, he's got something on her and is trapped. Of course, being the intelligent, mature person she is, she's gonna deal with it herself, and not involve anyone around her, like Melissa. Melissa knows what kind of damage a sex tape could do to Erynn, no matter the field she was trying to go into.

Alexis checking on MC after the confession was sweeter than almost anything Erynn has done story wise. Erynn showing up later to check on MC after he starts avoiding her (how much time passed?) is just her being too little, too late. Of course, we know from the letters she wrote that she did make a considerable effort to try to patch things up. It still doesn't scream romance to me at all, it's just a friend missing her other friend.

The only time I see what I'd consider romance with MC is the photoshoot, where it's a forced interaction (you make the choice as the player, but if you're interested in Erynn, you're not gonna leave her hanging here). All the other times are the MC taking a step (or the rare case early on where she makes a move and it's a huge mistake to accept it) and then getting frustrated sexually because she can't reciprocate.
I'm not 100% sure, but I agree.

I didn't, but their is a couple there.

This one has the most girls in it.

my-image (1).png
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
then she goes to see him the same day, right after he locked himself in his room and Emily tells her not to.
While it's always good and right to point out Emily's mess as a mother; Erynn simply says that Ethan made fun of him, there's never any mention that MC was making the confession to Erynn. There's no sign that Erynn even took it as a confession.
 
  • Heart
Reactions: NadaMucho

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,728
8,143
637
But except for Lexi, is Iris aware that MC is in a relationship?
If you play ASP she 100% knows about Layla.
Nyx loves this gray area, i show respect for my friend, but anyone outside of my immediate circle can get fucked.

On other paths it seems like Iris doesn't know shit.

While it's always good and right to point out Emily's mess as a mother; Erynn simply says that Ethan made fun of him, there's never any mention that MC was making the confession to Erynn. There's no sign that Erynn even took it as a confession.

Erynn knows it was a confession, and she still remembers.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
She was very "economical" with the details to Emily, that's true.

Btw, i don't think Emily did much wrong here, she couldn't have predicted this would escalate into 5 years of separation.
 
Last edited:

valbitterb

Engaged Member
Apr 11, 2022
2,049
6,589
636
CONVENOR:

LSC82, Dessolos, Heads of the Erynn clan,

Justaphase and Kazanovaromeo, heads of the Val clans,

Dr.TSoni and Jarulf, heads of the Layla clans, with their newest clan member Posbi95

Dessolos, also an underboss of the Lexi clans, with MiltonPowers, Ricthequick as his bosses, and a young soldier rising fast in the ranks DIKHammer,

NadaMucho, head of the Elena clan,

4rthurMorg4n, head of the Adriana clan,

and the heads of the Nikki, Cara, Iris, Gabi Intertwined waifu clans, thank you all for coming to this meeting today.

Now no one wants a war. It's bad for business ...

Well no one except the Kaskaze clan, maybe ...

KRZOgq-1648016481.gif

c75373ea-7e6d-4a06-900d-244584031787_text-1355600897.gif
 
Last edited:

Justaphase

Engaged Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
3,200
10,847
599
CONVENOR:

LSC82, Head of the Erynn clan,

Justaphase and Kazanovaromeo, heads of the Val clans,

Dr.TSoni and Jarulf, heads of the Layla clans,

Dessolos, one of the heads of the Lexi clans,

NadaMucho, head of the Elena clan,

and the heads of the Nikki, Cara, Iris, Gabi Intertwined waifu clans, thank you all for coming to this meeting today.

Now no one wants a war. It's bad for business ...

Well no one except the Kaskaze clan, maybe ...

View attachment 4917723

View attachment 4917725
It's all fun and games until someone wakes up with a horses head in their bed... :ROFLMAO:
 
4.40 star(s) 314 Votes