Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
8,334
19,244
854
I find it curious that Erynn and Val get labelled as "too problematic" for things that happened sometimes years ago by accident or they were victims of...
And yet often the same people are completely ok with Alexis, who lied and deceived both the guy she loves and her best friend, demons created by her own conscious decisions... she's the mature option right?

"I was just afraid i would lose you if i told the truth", you guys bought this bullshit excuse? After she comes up short on telling the truth not once, but 4 times?
She just feels so bad about lying and backstabbing her friend :ROFLMAO:, she keeps instigating more and feeling SO SAD after...

She's in my pour gasoline and light the match tier:devilish:
I like Slexi coz she has lots of content, and to be fair it's not bad content either most of the time, but not my favorite LI either. But she ain't exactly light on fire category :ROFLMAO: I'll reserve that for Tori
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Maviarab

DIKHammer

Well-Known Member
Dec 30, 2024
1,262
2,466
331
I like Slexi coz she has lots of content, and to be fair it's not bad content either most of the time, but not my favorite LI either. But she ain't exactly light on fire category :ROFLMAO: I'll reserve that for Tori
I have a solution for Tori - sick her on Ethan and watch for a while before getting rid of Ethan
 

Justaphase

Engaged Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
3,523
12,347
650
For Val I can't say because I've never been interested in her, but Erynn my problem is that the relationship has suffered too much distrust. Remaining friends seems possible to me but in a relationship unconsciously there would always be problems.

Let's be honest, for five years Erynn had been nagging her to death about the MC and Lexi had a classic Emily moment.
The difference is Emily didn't know that John was Melissa's John and Erynn's rather.
Lexi was aware of who the MC was pretty quickly on the plane, but still fucked him. Knowing how much that would hurt Erynn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr.TSoni and LSC82

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,982
8,874
688
I like Slexi coz she has lots of content, and to be fair it's not bad content either most of the time, but not my favorite LI either. But she ain't exactly light on fire category :ROFLMAO: I'll reserve that for Tori
So the "The rewards came quickly so i chose to forget her bullshit tier"? :ROFLMAO:
Let's be honest, for five years Erynn had been nagging her to death about the MC and Lexi had a classic Emily moment.
She had 4 classic Emily moments, and unlike Emily she knew what she was doing.
 
Last edited:

Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
8,334
19,244
854
So the "The rewards came quickly so i chose to forget her bullshit tier"? :ROFLMAO:
I'd say the strategy worked out for Nyx, had to have something to pull the horny crowd in with instant gratification. Yeah she had her bullshit with that whole thing, but MC is a fucking idiot too quite often. Don't follow the popularity votes, but I'd be surprised if she was at the bottom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Dr.TSoni

Forum Fanatic
May 20, 2022
4,138
12,382
688
The difference is Emily didn't know that John was Melissa's John and Erynn's rather.
Lexi was aware of who the MC was pretty quickly on the plane, but still fucked him. Knowing how much that would hurt Erynn.
It's true, but it's such a humanly selfish moment. And personally I struggle to separate this problem of hers from her origin due to being born as a side girl
So the "The rewards came quickly so i chose to forget her bullshit tier"? :ROFLMAO:
Obvious
tenor.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LSC82 and DIKHammer

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,982
8,874
688
I'd say the strategy worked out for Nyx, had to have something to pull the horny crowd in with instant gratification. Yeah she had her bullshit with that whole thing, but MC is a fucking idiot too quite often. Don't follow the popularity votes, but I'd be surprised if she was at the bottom.
I just like that you said the quiet part loud my friend :ROFLMAO: , it's complete bullshit... but there's a lot of sex...

I have no problems with it, just people saying how "mature" she is, while often pointing the finger at others, that irks me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Elduriel

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
3,889
4,803
429
I find it curious that Erynn and Val get labelled as "too problematic" for things that happened sometimes years ago by accident or they were victims of...
And yet often the same people are completely ok with Alexis, who lied and deceived both the guy she loves and her best friend, demons created by her own conscious decisions... she's the mature option right?

"I was just afraid i would lose you if i told the truth", you guys bought this bullshit excuse? After she comes up short on telling the truth not once, but 4 times?
She just feels so bad about lying and backstabbing her friend :ROFLMAO:, she keeps instigating more and feeling SO SAD after...

She's in my pour gasoline and light the match tier:devilish:
Not to mention if you don't want to be her girlfriend, she stays the fuck away from you. At least everybody else has the decorum to still be your friend regardless of who you're fucking ( except Tori, cuz that's just a sign of bad taste).
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,982
8,874
688
Not to mention if you don't want to be her girlfriend, she stays the fuck away from you. At least everybody else has the decorum to still be your friend regardless of who you're fucking ( except Tori, cuz that's just a sign of bad taste).
She's constantly in Layla's scenes looking dejected.

Let me just come out and say it, Layla, the poster girl for "immaturity", handled being passed over with much more grace and poise.
 

Dessolos

Post Pro
Jul 25, 2017
21,116
30,431
987
I just like that you said the quiet part loud my friend :ROFLMAO: , it's complete bullshit... but there's a lot of sex...

I have no problems with it, just people saying how "mature" she is, while often pointing the finger at others, that irks me.
yeah kind of why she takes a bit to warm up to and get better if you can get past her negatives initially. My first playthrough I wanted nothing to do with her and wanted to break up with her and stay loyal to Erynn after I found out about the lies. But well they both found out before I had the chance.

It was only on my 2nd or 3rd playthrough where I gave her path a real chance I started to like her cause once I got past the initial bad there was nothing but good and kind of felt like real girlfriend material to me after that point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maccabbee and LSC82

jadepaladin

Engaged Member
Mar 9, 2020
3,502
7,303
672
Who calls Alexis mature? Is that a thing?

Don't get me wrong, I like her. I just wouldn't describe her as mature. I'm not sure anyone in this VN is mature. Elena probably comes closest due to her family life. Melissa, maybe. Emily's trying, I guess but the secrets don't make friends.

Erynn? Hell no.
Val? Eh. Kind of I guess.
Nikki? Probably more mature than any of the Madison Springs crew
Cara? Nope sorry.
Layla? hahahaha.

I could keep naming people but no one really jumps out at me as being mature.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maccabbee
4.40 star(s) 317 Votes