Yeah, if they got more personal it would be harder to keep him oblivious to her identity.Yeah, her role does mean more early game scenes, which made sense early in development. And if they actually talked much before getting together then either MC would work out who she is or Alexis would have to lie and come out looking even worse. I guess Alexis' early plot relies on them not really talking much!
I usually don't want to hook up with her immediately, but she's a fun character and it's just a shame that she almost vanishes on other routes. Other main girls like Layla or Erynn still play a big part in the game even if you're not on their route.
ASP is a weird one. I haven't played it so might be wrong, not really interested. But from descriptions it sounds like Alexis and Erynn almost have different personalities on it. Their solo route personalities don't feel like they'd mess with Layla's relationship like that, no matter how much Alexis fancies MC.
As it is she has the excuse that she only omitted(it doesn't fly with me, and she does straight up lie to Erynn, but it does with lots of players).
About ASP:
Erynn must be taking drugs on ASP
She's a whole different person from her normally soft and caring attitude, she decides to make something happen without asking if her friends if they want that... and goes forward with it, even though it might hurt their relationships and family.
Alexis... she does some dodgy shit on her main route too(even if she says she's sorry afterwards).
It's worst because there's no grey area with ASP, she's crushing on her sisters BF.
On the normal route there's some grey area between her, Erynn and MC, on ASP there's none, her sister is actually dating the guy, it's not "i think there's interest", and she's fully aware of that.
On the bright side she's doing a better job keeping it in her pants on ASP, she's lusting after him but hasn't tried jumping on him yet, she's actually trying to keep her distance... but close to failing.