I also don't like it because 90% of choices are meaningless. I don't want a kinetic VN, but the look here and look there shit is so outdated at this point.
1)Look Emily, I grabbed you and tossed you in the pool, can I still get a bike? +2
2)Sorry I looked at your boobs after throwing you in the pool Emily, can I still get a bike? -2
3)Sorry I lied about Zach, Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
4)Sorry I won't invite you to the beach in the future Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
*Around this time is the "look closer" reward for being a good kid, enjoy watching some boobs I guess, 6 points needed which is basically doing everything perfect with her up to this point*
5)Sorry I didn't hug you Emily after our fight, can I still get a bike? 0
6)Sorry I didn't correct you for thinking you are a bad mother Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
7)Sorry I didn't say I love you Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
8)Sorry for not checking up on you after your phone call with Andres, Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
9)Sorry for not picking you up in your own vehicle that you loaned me and instead making you take the bus Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
*Small window where if you botched Erynn and Alexis, it blows up on you and instead of taking responsibility, you can blame Emily, since she sent Erynn up after all, it's -4 if you do*
10) Sorry I didn't tell you the truth about Layla's prank phone call Emily, can I still get a bike? 0
*Bike time=13 points*
Almost every interaction with Emily is worth 2, and you need 13, so you need to do 7 of these. There's around 10 actions, (11 if you count the negative only Alexis/Erynn botch) and you have to do #1 to have a chance to lose points in #2.
All of this could be avoided by just having the bike decision based on how the MC handles her after the Mel/Emily reveal happens and they make up. If he goes in forgiving and respectful, set a flag. If he goes in still ticked off and doesn't do anything but make peace, set it to false.
Whether or not you threw Emily in the pool, talked about inviting her to the beach, stared at her tits when they popped out, etc shouldn't have an impact on her decision to buy you a bike.
TLDR: point systems suck.