Bmagada

Active Member
Dec 18, 2021
587
1,863
292
If you're on this path she spends massive amounts of time flirting with you. Its not like she doesn't want to do pervy stuff with the MC, she just has hang ups about it. She likes you and trusts you. A mature person doesn't assign the blame of their trauma on every person that follows in their life.

Besides, if the writer decides she's fine with it, she's fine with it. By that measure why is is okay if him and his blonde bestie fuck around? She's been assaulted over and over by this point. She has very real hang ups about it. She still gets very handsy with the MC. Not every female is going to react the same to everything. Especially if the dev doesn't write her that way. Maybe don't expect everyone to feel the way you feel about a situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

adanu

Member
Mar 28, 2020
373
478
163
Interesting that you saw things that way; FWIW I saw them differently.

He asked the mothers not to tell Erynn he returned because he did not want Erynn to know... ...he didn't want to see, confront, or have anything to do with her. It appeared to me that MC still was angry with Erynn over the flower incident; as the player, we know he misread that but the MC didn't realize this yet. To me, his resentment due to Erynn's "hurtful act" was alive and well.

I recognize this defies logic since the MC is Mel's next-door neighbor and landscaper. It's inevitable the MC will meet Erynn again. But at this point in the game the MC still isn't making very sound choices when his emotions are involved.

LSC82: Yeah ;)
I don't buy this. If this were the case, we would have had the MC's inner thoughts upon seeing Erynn be blatant about this.
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
3,975
8,859
688
"I know what you're really trying to do, Lexi. But don't worry, ask nicely and you can have a piece of this beefcake, too." :whistle:
Perfect line for an unrepentant Manwhore :p

I feel like Im the only one that finds the val date creepy which is another check mark in the mc is an asshole camp
It has elements of him pushing his luck for sure. He can get away with it because she already likes him so much, he also has that pretty privilege. There's one scene where Val even says "You're lucky I like you." when he is clearly pushing his luck, I just wish that we could reply with "I like you too." Is that really too much to ask for?
There are alot of other elements though to the date. I like how comforting we can be as the MC after those two idiots show up. There are some really tender moments.
He was at his worst for much of the beach date... sometimes creepy, sometimes annoying.
But some good moments managed to save it.

After she strips down, i think he is right to push his luck a bit, this is clearly a girl in the mood to play.
It doesn't feel like he pushed her beyond her limits, pretty privilege or not.

If you're on this path she spends massive amounts of time flirting with you. Its not like she doesn't want to do pervy stuff with the MC, she just has hang ups about it. She likes you and trusts you. A mature person doesn't assign the blame of their trauma on every person that follows in their life.

Besides, if the writer decides she's fine with it, she's fine with it. By that measure why is is okay if him and his blonde bestie fuck around? She's been assaulted over and over by this point. She has very real hang ups about it. She still gets very handsy with the MC. Not every female is going to react the same to everything. Especially if the dev doesn't write her that way. Maybe don't expect everyone to feel the way you feel about a situation.
Valeria originally didn't like anyone touching or grabbing her, but clearly that doesn't apply to the MC anymore, he's free to touch (within limits, not talking about fingering without asking her first :ROFLMAO: ).

Erynn has been in the driver's seat for much of the hotter parts of their dates, she suggests showering together and washing each other, she invites him into her bathroom later... Erynn is gradually expanding her limits, getting more comfortable with these things.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
3,881
4,782
429
Lol yea it's just weird how he's fine on most dates but with Val he turns into a raging horndog but for the most part I agree with the views here for the most part.
He was at his worst for much of the beach date... sometimes creepy, sometimes annoying.
But some good moments managed to save it.

After she strips down, i think he is right to push his luck a bit, this is clearly a girl in the mood to play.
It doesn't feel like he pushed her beyond her limits, pretty privilege or not.
Other than when ole girl got her clothes stolen and was somewhat scared but he convinced her to take a sexy pic. That felt like a zach move
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
3,881
4,782
429
if yall had to choose one sister threesome to happen which would it be the Lexi/mckayla, Cara/Muscle mommy, Emily/melissa, Erryn/ iris
 
Last edited:

NadaMucho

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2023
1,330
2,628
400
if yall had to choose one sister threesome to happen which would it be the Lexi/mckayla, Cara/Muscle mommy, Emily/melissa, Erryn/ iris
Yes I'm a habitual line stepper but Elena and Layla are LIKE sisters so I'm pulling for a mutual happy ending to finish the hot tub party. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jarulf

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
10,488
25,943
988
Lol yea it's just weird how he's fine on most dates but with Val he turns into a raging horndog but for the most part I agree with the views here for the most part.
He's kinda a horndog on most dates tbh. Bulk of his activities on these outings is drooling (either internally or overtly) over how the girls turn him on and trying to grope them or feel them up in some way or another. :whistle:
 

HeyZen_

Newbie
Sep 23, 2025
87
67
79
Reading the topics I see criticism of the protagonist, what do you think of him? For me he's neutral, not one of my favorites, but not one of the worst either.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
3,881
4,782
429
Reading the topics I see criticism of the protagonist, what do you think of him? For me, he's neutral, not one of my favorites, but not one of the worst either.
Horny pretty boy who wants to do good and has a thing for the girl next door? He's kinda whiny, but other than that, he's a bit of a cliché, but he fits in this world and he allows the love interests of this world to shine. So he fits into the story well.
 

Kaskaze

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2022
1,012
1,696
348
Reading the topics I see criticism of the protagonist, what do you think of him? For me he's neutral, not one of my favorites, but not one of the worst either.
For me, the MC is neutral, and that fits the world he’s in. In my opinion, there’s nothing that makes me want to defend him, but also nothing that gives me a reason to hate him. All of his current actions are explained or justified (some better, some worse).
The only thing that really bothers me in the whole game is the MC’s behavior before taking Layla’s virginity and being on Elena’s route at the same time. That’s the one moment where I was seriously disappointed in the MC and had a really bad opinion of him. Because that choice was supposed to break Layla’s heart, but not in such a brutal way. He could have rejected Layla, but not like that
 

Dessolos

Post Pro
Jul 25, 2017
21,108
30,417
987
Reading the topics I see criticism of the protagonist, what do you think of him? For me he's neutral, not one of my favorites, but not one of the worst either.
only thing I dislike about him is his tattoo's. For me he is one of the better MC's and I tend to forget or not care for most MC's out there. Then again a fuckboy MC isn't my main path and he is a pretty decent guy on those solo paths.
 
4.40 star(s) 317 Votes