Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
8,266
18,926
854
I have to disagree with you here. MC has spoken to Zach a few times and given him hints. Zach just doesn't get it. There was the conversation at Heaven's when they were there with Elena and Layla, the scolding when Zach behaved badly towards Elena in the cafeteria, the conversation by the pool, the conversation on the stairs at school, and so on and so forth. Zach, however, is someone who doesn't understand anything at all. His entire behavior is, at best, preschool-level. It was never mentioned in the game, but I'm pretty sure the reason Zach had to change schools at the time was because he was expelled for inappropriate behavior towards girls.
Zach is written to be a fucking idiot, there's nothing to be analyzed there. The MC too is written as an idiot just in a different way.
 
Jan 2, 2022
55
125
208
WTF?

Zach is a pretty bad friend to MC

Zach wants him to spy on girls like they're 12

MC gives very minimal advice because Zach doesn't listen to anyone who isn't trying to poison him



Says the Zoey avatar
I’m not saying Zach is a saint, and I’m not justifying his actions in any way. What I mean is that, at least when it comes to MC, Zach has always shown genuine friendship. For example he immediately recognized MC when he arrived at the school, let him sleep at his place, and is always available for him.

MC, on the other hand, has been a bad friend. For instance, when Miguel draws a penis on Zach’s face, a good friend would have stopped it or at least told Zach as soon as possible. Instead MC just watched as Zach made a fool of himself in front of Gabi (she even laughed).
 

miltonlucifer

Member
Dec 31, 2019
151
295
178
I’m not saying Zach is a saint, and I’m not justifying his actions in any way. What I mean is that, at least when it comes to MC, Zach has always shown genuine friendship. For example he immediately recognized MC when he arrived at the school, let him sleep at his place, and is always available for him.

MC, on the other hand, has been a bad friend. For instance, when Miguel draws a penis on Zach’s face, a good friend would have stopped it or at least told Zach as soon as possible. Instead MC just watched as Zach made a fool of himself in front of Gabi (she even laughed).
but he's not a friend though. when you meet him at the beginning of the game, you have the choice to "not recognize him"
which means they were in the same class or the same age a few years back , and they had a vague cordial relationship without being particularly friends , and the zach , seeing a familiar face that he hasn't seen in while decides to hang with MC (probably because he's ostracized because he's an idiot and a dick . and no one wants to hangout with him, he's the burden of the classroom most likely, there's always one)

which frankly is perfectly realistic behaviour and interaction . sometimes you hang with people in HS just because you were with them one class prior and knew vaguely their face , and not because you were friends .


also explains why in uni or superior classes, generally people coming from the same high school hangout together and you have clans based on which high school you come from.

I'd say zach was a vague acquaintance of MC , nothing more.
 
Last edited:

Kaskaze

Active Member
May 1, 2022
976
1,623
328
I’m not saying Zach is a saint, and I’m not justifying his actions in any way. What I mean is that, at least when it comes to MC, Zach has always shown genuine friendship. For example he immediately recognized MC when he arrived at the school, let him sleep at his place, and is always available for him.

MC, on the other hand, has been a bad friend. For instance, when Miguel draws a penis on Zach’s face, a good friend would have stopped it or at least told Zach as soon as possible. Instead MC just watched as Zach made a fool of himself in front of Gabi (she even laughed).
Is this really bad behavior though? My buddy would 100% call it out and drag me over to a bigger group so everyone could see that I’ve got a dick drawn on my face. :LOL: Zach is an idiot, plain and simple
 
Jan 2, 2022
55
125
208
That was harmless fun between teenagers.
The problem with those kinds of jokes is that once they’re accepted, they gradually start going further and further, always being justified as "harmless fun" It’s funny at first, but not so much when the joke is turned back on you or taken even further.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffive

DIKHammer

Well-Known Member
Dec 30, 2024
1,247
2,402
331
I’m not saying Zach is a saint, and I’m not justifying his actions in any way. What I mean is that, at least when it comes to MC, Zach has always shown genuine friendship. For example he immediately recognized MC when he arrived at the school, let him sleep at his place, and is always available for him.

MC, on the other hand, has been a bad friend. For instance, when Miguel draws a penis on Zach’s face, a good friend would have stopped it or at least told Zach as soon as possible. Instead MC just watched as Zach made a fool of himself in front of Gabi (she even laughed).
Bro you fall asleep at a party its all bets off friend or not, Zach is lucky he didn't;'t get teabagged or arabian goggles

MC has tried to warn Zach but it fails just like your comprehension
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TheDaringGoat
Jan 2, 2022
55
125
208
Bro you fall asleep at a party its all bets off friend or not, Zach is lucky he didn't;'t get teabagged or arabian goggles

MC has tried to warn Zach but it fails just like your comprehension
Saying “all bets are off” is just an excuse. Being a friend means stepping in or at least telling him afterward. Doing nothing is still a choice.
 
Jan 2, 2022
55
125
208
Is this really bad behavior though? My buddy would 100% call it out and drag me over to a bigger group so everyone could see that I’ve got a dick drawn on my face. :LOL: Zach is an idiot, plain and simple
Just because you would laugh about it doesn’t make it okay for everyone. Respect isn’t defined by the loudest guy in the room.
 

DIKHammer

Well-Known Member
Dec 30, 2024
1,247
2,402
331
Saying “all bets are off” is just an excuse. Being a friend means stepping in or at least telling him afterward. Doing nothing is still a choice.
Just because I'm someone's friend and again Zach is more like an acquaintance then someone I would count as a friend, doesn't mean I'm not stopping this and laughing.
 

acmb2017

Newbie
Apr 7, 2023
73
88
192
How the Fuck is anyone defending Zach?
Me as a free thinking individual say it would absolutely not be my responsibility to teach this " friend" how to be a normal human.
When I was late teens early 20s bet your ass that dude would be on my fuck right off list, even more now that I am grown.
I swear I am glad ill die before seeing what happens when these snowflakes run the world
 

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
10,464
25,850
988
I have to disagree with you here. MC has spoken to Zach a few times and given him hints. Zach just doesn't get it.
Sure, and after those few times where MC made a token effort, he starts instead to shit on the guy in his own thoughts and badmouth him together with the girls instead of maybe, i don't know, try to explain in some detail why Zach's behavior is wrong, rather than simply tell him what amounts to "don't do that [because i tell you]" or as you put it, give him hints. Since i'm saying that MC isn't acting like a good friend with Zach and you are disagreeing on this matter with me, then let me ask you this -- what exactly in MC's behavior towards Zach that we can see throughout the game makes you believe the MC is Zach's good friend...?

That was harmless fun between teenagers.
And yet you can bet if it was MC who ended up with dick on his face and Zach was laughing at him instead of telling them, people here would be bringing this up as strong evidence of how much of a dick Zach was towards the MC. :sneaky:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ozymandias037

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
10,464
25,850
988
but he's not a friend though. when you meet him at the beginning of the game, you have the choice to "not recognize him"
That's a "who are you" sort of joke. MC instantly corrects himself afterwards and reveals that he does in fact recognize Zach. IIRC he also tells the girls when they ask, that him and Zach go way back. At no point he's seriously acting like he isn't close with the guy, not even in his internal monologues. And he sure gets pissed at Zach for "being a bad friend" and rambles about it repeatedly after Zach turns on him. Hardly a reaction of distant acquaintance.
 

Elduriel

Resist the Kaiju!
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
8,266
18,926
854
Sure, and after those few times where MC made a token effort, he starts instead to shit on the guy in his own thoughts and badmouth him together with the girls instead of maybe, i don't know, try to explain in some detail why Zach's behavior is wrong, rather than simply tell him what amounts to "don't do that [because i tell you]" or as you put it, give him hints. Since i'm saying that MC isn't acting like a good friend with Zach and you are disagreeing on this matter with me, then let me ask you this -- what exactly in MC's behavior towards Zach that we can see throughout the game makes you believe the MC is Zach's good friend...?
I mean, why would he need to explain decent fucking human behavior to the guy? Well, I suppose he is a fucking idiot. So yeah, good point :rolleyes: Seriously, he is just written there as a bad plot device, nothing more, why would anyone argue about him. It!s not like Nyx is a genius author that will surprise us at any point, all of her "cliffhangers" thus far have been fucking obvious.
 

Tremonia

Justice for Finnabair!
Donor
Jun 14, 2020
3,589
11,941
698
what exactly in MC's behavior towards Zach that we can see throughout the game makes you believe the MC is Zach's good friend...?
I don't think MC consider himself as a good friend of Zach. Zach is just a friend, not more. MC has made an effort to tolerate Zach's idiocy. Normal people would have made it clear to Zach early on that he's as dumb as a pack of cucumbers and should piss off. It's not MC's job to teach an 18-year-old social skills. At that age, Zach should know better and pick up on the more than obvious hints from those around him.
 

miltonlucifer

Member
Dec 31, 2019
151
295
178
That's a "who are you" sort of joke. MC instantly corrects himself afterwards and reveals that he does in fact recognize Zach. IIRC he also tells the girls when they ask, that him and Zach go way back. At no point he's seriously acting like he isn't close with the guy, not even in his internal monologues. And he sure gets pissed at Zach for "being a bad friend" and rambles about it repeatedly after Zach turns on him. Hardly a reaction of distant acquaintance.
Ah Well, I haven't played the game in half a year, and played a lot of other VNs inbetween, they tend to blend together at some point.

but the vibe I got from Zach, is the same as Derek in BaDik, except Derek was actually a great guy below the goofy surface.
 

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
10,464
25,850
988
I don't think MC consider himself as a good friend of Zach. Zach is just a friend, not more. MC has made an effort to tolerate Zach's idiocy. Normal people would have made it clear to Zach early on that he's as dumb as a pack of cucumbers and should piss off. It's not MC's job to teach an 18-year-old social skills. At that age, Zach should know better and pick up on the more than obvious hints from those around him.
OK, so if MC himself doesn't consider himself a good friend of Zach, why are people here acting like simply stating as much, that MC isn't acting like a good friend of Zach, like some sort of crime against humanity that must be disagreed with and debated at lenght?
 
4.40 star(s) 317 Votes