qwertyu12359:
Im not gonna alter my review or my rating. At that time thats what I thought about your beta. Maybe you can invent a time machine? Do you alter Amazon or Steam reviews once the seller makes changes due to previous feedback?
If I receive the updated product for free, of course I make changes to my previous feedback. I already did to almost all my reviews in F95. A review is only contingent to the time you test the product; if the product is altered, the review should be altered (you know, common effort between the dev' and the player). Your review is still displaying as the title now is 2.0.1, which alters the average rating and will prevent people from trying; while I think they should, if slave management is what they are looking for.
What about
p44p? Zero messages but 5 star review?
What about
Vrahel? Not gonna
trash him? He did criticize you you know?
What about
Buddawg? Not gonna trash him?
You must be registered to see the links
.
I didn't trash you. I addressed your points; I criticized your criticism. And you aren't really addressing my point, you're trying to avoid them all by attacking my personal credibility instead, whilst you should either be agreeing or be giving proper counter arguments.
Whats your problem with my review? I was mostly trashing 1.7.5, not your beta. Isnt that what you want? Okay to trash crushboss and all the guys before you. Just dont trash Mr. Hypocrite.
Why persist on "trashing"? You get a game for free and without any paywall.
Some of your points of criticism are more than fair (look, the combat system. I put it in the roadmap immediately after reading your review). However there's "criticism" (examination) which can pinpoint things that suck, and there's "trashing" which blatantly exaggerate on issues and make fallacious reasoning, as a way to evacuate frustration. You're free to evacuate frustration, but bad reviews are harmful to the motivation (especially when done on a beta...).
Your mod is no longer so shitty
Oww
See? You can be so nice when you want...
and will be less shitty thanks to all the feedback from people who are not asskissers. You should thank people like me instead of bitching about it.
You would have had the same result in game if you posted a nice message in the topic saying "thank you! I like this, and that, and this (for exemple merging the 1.7.3 and the 1.7.5 pictures; still waiting for your acknowledgement that this was needed
). The game will become less shitty in spite of your two star review, not thanks to it.
It may look like you have lots of people kissing your ass. But only two actually believe in you enough to actually tip your Patreon account.
Why do you care so much about an anon like me (whose name is freaking "Qwertyu"
). Will you stop the personal attacks and focus on the game or the
counter arguments I've
made? It's like you genuinely want to hurt me personally and it's your main goal, more than having a great game unfold before your eyes.
-----> My final question is, since you said you "mainly trashed 1.7.5". Do you think v1.7.5 deserves 2 stars? If you do, fine, it means you've spoke your mind honestly. (I personally think it's a master piece and would give it 4 to 5 stars).
However, if you think it deserves 3 or 4 stars, do you think a (mostly visual) update of 1.7.5, which fix tiny little things, and adds 0 flaws (based on your review) overhaul deserves 2 stars?
My opinion—and I've made my case for it in the two previous messages addressed to you—is that your bad rating was an exaggeration. If now, emotions aside, you still think 2 stars is a fair reflection of the game quality, then it's fine by me. If you (independently of me as a person or a developer) come to the conclusion that maybe your previous rating doesn't reflect the quality of the overhaul game, again, feel free to change it accordingly to your own standards.
