Neriel

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2018
1,018
1,054
Thank you.

Why may i ask ?
You want to keep your Order as low as possible because the Kingdom will give you more money since you are "struggling". If you have high Order, the Kingdom thinks you have everything under control so they give you less money. Well at least early you want to keep your Order low. The further you get into the game, the more and more you want to increase your Order because you should have increased your general income by then and Riots can lead to a Game Over if Order is too low. + fights are harder the lower the Order is. So late game, you want your fights to be easier.
 

otoboke

Member
Nov 6, 2019
391
751
Why this game attracts so many of those weird guys with "screenshots" made on phone from laptop display? :PogChamp:
 

Shimk

Member
Aug 21, 2019
185
139
You want to keep your Order as low as possible because the Kingdom will give you more money since you are "struggling". If you have high Order, the Kingdom thinks you have everything under control so they give you less money. Well at least early you want to keep your Order low. The further you get into the game, the more and more you want to increase your Order because you should have increased your general income by then and Riots can lead to a Game Over if Order is too low. + fights are harder the lower the Order is. So late game, you want your fights to be easier.
the game is about balance... so, i don't agree.


For who says that you can't fight at day one, i disagree to that too.
You can't rush to the boss at day one, but you can fight some enemies, to gain exp and order, unlocking the right edicts.
 

Supreme_Evil

⸸ БѢСЪ ⸸
Uploader
Oct 16, 2020
2,314
30,969
Quick guide for those weird guys:
Click on the game tab, press Alt+PrintScreen, go to the comment section in this thread (write your reply), press Ctrl+V and click on the post reply button.
 
  • Like
Reactions: otoboke

Nazzar

Newbie
Jun 4, 2022
47
81
I'll almost feel guilty if i don't address at least some points in a 2-page debate for my benefit, so here goes:
Neriel said:
You really went with Gold and Edicts as an Example? Isn't that the perfect example of "This is a Porn Game, I just don't want to deal with managing the Prison"?
It isn't. There is a difference between the crowds that look for saves and gallery - those are the ones who don't want to deal with gameplay, just look at the smut - and those that ask to cheat and edit. The latter clearly intends to play the game and not just watch pretty pictures, but cant deal with the egregiously antagonistic approach the game takes towards players.

Neriel said:
Again are parts of the Game tedious or annoying? Sure. Is some information without reason hidden? Sure.
Lets not sugarcoat it here: its not "some" information that's hidden. you're heavily downplaying it. The "tutorial" npc cover mostly basic stuff, nothing of substance. The useful things they are vague about and in 2 instances they outright lie to you.

Just some examples of vital information hidden: enemy stats, combat act order, actual numerical values for health, overblow protection breakpoints, basic damage estimates - like how the hell do i know the difference between slam and blunt attack's effectiveness?? Does cleave use different damage formula from slash? Does skewer have either higher or lower base chance to hit than thrust? Player is given nothing to make an informed decision about pretty much anything.

To say nothing of the extremely vague descriptions of edicts who express effects in arrows up or down, as opposed to anything you can clearly calculate or plan out. Just one example is "staff efficiency" - 0 explanation - its just there as a statistic. Riot chance arrow up/down? Well bully for me, that still does jack in helping me plan or calculate my odds. It resembles nothing close to how a proper risk management mechanic should be.

And do they say enemies level up for each riot that happens? I had to look at the code to learn that one. Thats just 1 example; most of the actually important stuff is only accessible if you scour the game files with a fine-tooth comb. All of this is on purpose. They even go the extra mile to design the game so that even if you simply defend yourself long enough, you will *still* turn out a massive whore. As i said before, they take the time to make fun of the player, saying that they are expected to repeatedly fail and game over, which goes way beyond an average metric of player antagonism.

And they know it. That is why their steam description of the game is so defensive: "the game is fairly unfair", my ass.

Your argument is kind of like saying "Malenia boss from Elden Ring is not really hard because you can just choose to not fight and instead wait until you're OP"
I'm gonna borrow the Elden Ring simile here to make a point. I'm not critiquing KP's difficulty. I'm saying that the game is hard for all the wrong reasons, hence why i said "poor design choices". Its hardships are tied to purposefully vague, timewasting and convoluted gameplay. Withholding information, forcing you to stumble blind, 1 failure at a time. And even if you fail, it does nothing to teach you what could've been done better. It just says "take whatever titles you got and try again".

KP is not difficult in the traditional sense of the word. Elden ring and Sekiro are difficult. I've finished Sekiro's mortal journey boss rush gauntlet. I know "difficult".
The fights are insane, their special moves come from every which way, can 1/2-shot you easily, have an excessively aggressive AI, demand split-second reaction time and a posture break mechanic that makes it unfavorable to the player to stall for time and turtle.

The great difference here and there is that no matter how stacked the odds, everything is dependent entirely on the player. All the game mechanics are laid bare and nothing is hidden. Its up to you to negotiate the difficulty through your own skill, reflexes and judgement. That i why there are videos of some maniacs who kill the last boss in FromSoftware games at level 1, with 0 equipment or upgrades. Because insanely difficult as it, success is still reliant solely on the player. THAT is what you can call "fairly unfair".
Can KP be finished without edicts and accessories? No. It intentionally denies player agency in what goes on inside the game.

Neriel said:
The far majority never asks about anything. They download it, play it and move on.
Untrue. How many games posted in 07.2019 can boast 1284 pages? I'll tell you - not nearly close to that many. My speculation is that people are interested and *want* to play this, but they end up cutting their losses when they realize that learning the game will require them to live in its .js files for a couple of days first, break down and ask for cheats and edits or just quit instead. Like this person:
...Nah, ima call it quits. If my only recourse is changing the core gameplay, using NG+'d save, outright cheating or spending 5-10x the amount of time the game warrants, locked behind artificially-induced endless drudgery and counter-intuitive learning process, its better I cut my losses.
Or like me: I didnt feel gratification after finishing my plays. I felt like i spent far too much researching, learning and playing this, than I should've. For what it is, the artificially inflated learning curve required to play the game, siphoned far more time than is remotely reasonable.
Which, again, seems to support my initial argument.

Moving on to the thug thing:
Neriel said:
I just pointed out, that you can avoid fighting Thugs on the First Floor as long as you want.
And how is a new player supposed to know that?? Ok, you have that one npc that squats in the yard that warns about thugs. Big whoop - that does nothing to tell you how to avoid them. A metric for good game design is the ability to finish it successfully on your first attempt, with no prior knowledge, if you pay attention, manage your risks and make use of the various mechanics, tools and information made available to you.
How the hell is a player just starting the game supposed to know which packs have the gameover thugs in them? And not just walk straight out of the first 2 corridors of the game into a fight he cant possibly hope to win. More to the point - the sprites of the enemies have nothing to do with the actual enemies inside the fight. You can approach that goblin sprite and see 0 goblins. You can approach that prisoner sprite and eat 2 thugs.

Yet another example of a design choice that is purposefully vague and antagonistic towards the player. No experimentation or breathing room for failure allowed - take your rape scene and either try again, crippled with passives, which sets you up to fail later, but not before realizing that you are an inescapable downward spiral, several hours in.(word for word what the devs' cat actually tells you)
Or start over.

Neriel said:
Question, you do actually understand that I meant his point is "wrong" in combination of cheating... right?
I have absolutely no idea what this sentence meant.
Making a conclusion of something, while not playing it to it's full potential?
I made no absolute statements. I described my experience in an entirely neutral summary. And with regards to "playing to full potential" at the risk of sounding conceited, I'm fairly certain finishing 2 prisoner challenge runs puts me in the upper percentile of people playing this, meaning i *do* have an inkling of what i am talking about, so you shouldnt dismiss my views so entirely.

So you're implying as if OP stated the game isn't "balanced" just because of their one point of "bar fight was hard at start" while completely ignoring rest of the points contributing to it?
I never fought the bar enemies in any of my games. Dont know why this became a narrative as i never once mentioned the bar.
More importantly, the game - in a very rare show of courtesy - actually *tells you* not to fight the bar when you first enter, so I wouldn't actually have grounds to say anything in the first place. The 2 thugs were located in the rooms above, using a basic prisoner sprite, because , well, fuck me.

you want to tell me, that it is mathematically impossible to win against Thugs early?
The "mathematical impossibility" i addressed was winning the fight that included two thugs+prisoner as its 2/3 wave. Again, not the bar. I was all of 5-6 level at the time with 0 accessories, and as stated in my summary, it was the absence of +10 accessories that made it hard.


I can fight in the Bar 1st Day and not lose. So even then, funnily enough, they are actually wrong with that statment.
You can beat the bar fight 1st day on Prisoner and no accessories?

Ok, I said how and why your magical, threading the razor's edge 19-29-39-49 Prisoner herobook, no losses, no halberd, armor or stat upgrades, all in one shot strains believability, and then i dropped it, but this one i will call you out on - you are full of it.
And im not talking about trying it until it eventually works out, no.
To fit with what you just implied, plus the espoused narrative from the herobook conversation, where you can calculate down to a hair's breadth all things RNG that may, could or will happen, you'll need to work beating the bar into an actual play you intend to finish. No re-tries, obv.
Your words: Prisoner. Day1. No accessories. Go for it, champ.
 
Last edited:

vrtrtr

Member
May 8, 2017
378
617
After adding the preg images, crotch tattoo (iirc) is now a sign that she isn't knocked up atm. Belly starts showing from 2nd trimester as expected. so its a simple hint until that point to show that she's pregnant (I think)
interesting. do you know of a way to turn it off (outside of turning off the whole pregnancy module)?
 

ronadan

Member
Jul 2, 2017
167
360
the game is about balance... so, i don't agree.
it's a viable and easy-to-follow strategy for a new player. that said, if you have a better strategy for that stage of the game, I'm sure poisonbug would appreciate hearing it

if you want to criticize, fine. but at least offer an alternative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eugene67

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,318
3,814
You wrote exactly my feelings for this game, better than I probably could, everything was spot-on.
Especially the part about hidden information. I feel like just about everything is hidden: enemy stats during battle(all stats, including numeric health), damage preview, turn order, vague edicts with up and down arrows, vague skill descriptions...
This game is full of guessing. Nothing is certain because almost everything is hidden.
Who's gonna act first in battle? Guess.
Who's gonna act next? Guess.
How much damage you can do? Guess.
How much health enemies have? Guess.
How much effects buff and debuff skills have? Guess.
How much crit chance I or enemies have? Guess.
Edicts with up and down arrows, how much of an effect they have? Guess.
Current riot chances of each level? Guess.
Why did I just unlocked a passive that has negative effects? Guess.
There's also hidden mechanics only found by looking at the game's files, when I found this for the first time I said a few insults loudly to devs. I still find this unbelievable. They expect me to play this game lots of times while hiding gameplay mechanics from me. I'm glad I didn't buy it. I've probably spent 1/3 of my gameplay time digging through it's files to discover hidden mechanics and change values of some questionable design choices. Fuck that shit, seriously.
 
Last edited:

Neriel

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2018
1,018
1,054
You can beat the bar fight 1st day on Prisoner and no accessories?

Ok, I said how and why your magical, threading the razor's edge 19-29-39-49 Prisoner herobook, no losses, no halberd, armor or stat upgrades, all in one shot strains believability, and then i dropped it, but this one i will call you out on - you are full of it.
And im not talking about trying it until it eventually works out, no.
To fit with what you just implied, plus the espoused narrative from the herobook conversation, where you can calculate down to a hair's breadth all things RNG that may, could or will happen, you'll need to work beating the bar into an actual play you intend to finish. No re-tries, obv.
Your words: Prisoner. Day1. No accessories. Go for it, champ.
I am not gonna address all the other stuff, since I don't want this to drag on. I was talking in context of a NG+ run you did and the challenge run. Not a fresh save. But since I am in a good mood, here I did it even on a fresh save, first try. Now to be fair 2 of the Thugs I could not beat down quick enough before they masturbated themselves to death. I could retry until I get it but maybe you now understand why I said, that I could do it since in NG+ you have a lot of more titles and therefor are stronger.

Screenshot (44).png

So here again, now with NG+. And this time I beat them without anybody masturbating themselves to death. Screenshot (45).png

So please go ahead how full I am. Just because you can't do it, doesn't mean it is impossible.

Lets not sugarcoat it here: its not "some" information that's hidden. Just some examples of vital information hidden: enemy stats, combat act order, actual numerical values for health, overblow protection breakpoints, basic damage estimates
That is why I said viewpoint. All those things are for me just one thing in terms of, that the game doesn't give you Statistical Data. Sure if you look at it one by one, in mounts up. But for me this is one issue. Not 10 as an example. But I can repeat myself and seems like people ignore always certain parts of what I say, so whatever not gonna continue it. (also... enemy stats... really? I can understand a lot of things but if you mean, that you need to know exact values of all their Core Stats, then we are starting to talk about hand holding)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Assassin3
Aug 11, 2020
349
961
You wrote exactly my feelings for this game, better than I probably could, everything was spot-on.
Especially the part about hidden information. I feel like just about everything is hidden: enemy stats during battle(all stats, including numeric health), damage preview, turn order, vague edicts with up and down arrows, vague skill descriptions...
This game is full of guessing. Nothing is certain because almost everything is hidden.
Who's gonna act first in battle? Guess.
Who's gonna act next? Guess.
How much damage you can do? Guess.
How much health enemies have? Guess.
How much effects buff and debuff skills have? Guess.
How much crit chance I or enemies have? Guess.
Edicts with up and down arrows, how much of an effect they have? Guess.
Current riot chances of each level? Guess.
Why did I just unlocked a passive that has negative effects? Guess.
There's also hidden mechanics only found by looking at the game's files, when I found this for the first time I said a few insults loudly to devs. I still find this unbelievable. They expect me to play this game lots of times while hiding gameplay mechanics from me. I'm glad I didn't buy it. I've probably spent 1/3 of my gameplay time digging through it's files to discover hidden mechanics and change values of some questionable design choices. Fuck that shit, seriously.
The beautiful part here is that everything makes sense and is logical, but you need to fail first before realizing this. Most game mechanics are explained by the guards in the break room and the prisoners in the mess hall and courtyard. Core stats are explained really well when you look at the edicts that improve the growth rate. However, I agree that this is done very poorly because the information is spread over 4 or 5 edicts. All the other things that you mention are vague by design. You get an estimate what the effects of a certain edict will be, but never the exact numbers.

The only real issues for new players are the decreasing subsidies when your order is high (again, this is logical if you think about it) and not specializing in a certain stat (also logical, since you'd be mediocre at everything). And of course also the fact that autosave is on by default when you play on normal difficulty. That's the only thing I find truly annoying about this game, but you can make manual backups of your saves throughout the game.
 
Aug 11, 2020
349
961
I am not gonna address all the other stuff, since I don't want this to drag on. I was talking in context of a NG+ run you did and the challenge run. Not a fresh save. But since I am in a good mood, here I did it even on a fresh save, first try. Now to be fair 2 of the Thugs I could not beat down quick enough before they masturbated themselves to death. I could retry until I get it but maybe you now understand why I said, that I could do it since in NG+ you have a lot of more titles and therefor are stronger.

View attachment 1874448

So here again, now with NG+. And this time I beat them without anybody masturbating themselves to death. View attachment 1874458

So please go ahead how full I am. Just because you can't do it, doesn't mean it is impossible.
Which edicts did you buy for those two runs?
 

Neriel

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2018
1,018
1,054
Which edicts did you buy for those two runs?
Mind Training 1 and Healing Thoughts. If you don't buy the +10 Acc. Items, which makes sence in a Aspring Hero Challenge Run, you need to have staying power. So being able to replenish Energy is a must. Now ofc I would still not fight in the Bar. It only takes a bad roll with a red Thug to ruin your day.
 

Purple_Heart

Engaged Member
Oct 15, 2021
2,318
3,814
The beautiful part here is that everything makes sense and is logical, but you need to fail first before realizing this. Most game mechanics are explained by the guards in the break room and the prisoners in the mess hall and courtyard. Core stats are explained really well when you look at the edicts that improve the growth rate.

The only real issues for new players are the decreasing subsidies when your order is high (again, this is logical if you think about it) and not specializing in a certain stat (also logical, since you'd be mediocre at everything). And of course also the fact that autosave is on by default when you play on normal difficulty. That's the only thing I find truly annoying about this game, but you can make manual backups of your saves throughout the game.
You're assuming I'm new to the game, I didn't the complete the game AND I didn't read a few poorly written "explainations" that can be found by talking to npc's. That's lots of assumptions.

There's no excuse for the lack of information. If it is all by design, it is a bad design that deserves all the negativity it gets.
If I was making a turn based strategy game, the first thing I do would be creating an easy to read ui that has lots of information, especially turn order.
If I was making a game with lots of management options like this game has(edicts) I'd make sure they have exact descriptions of what they do in order to NOT leave the player playing the guessing game.

None of this is excusable, play any other turn based strategy game and see how they work. Go ahead and play xcom 2 for example. See how that game explains everything perfectly and has no bs hidden mechanics. Perfectly clear base management, perfectly clear combat. Nothing is hidden. If you lose it's your fault. If you lose in karryn's prison it's either because you didn't know what happened due to lack of information(example: stacked negative passives without knowing why) or game decided it is time for you to lose by spawning a rare powerful enemy. You rarely lose because it is your fault, which isn't fun at all.
 

Nazzar

Newbie
Jun 4, 2022
47
81
Where to start...Ok for the most obvious, images can in no way show items equipped or game difficulty. For all i know, you slapped some accessories then removed them after the fight, and I have no way to know how many tries it took you. Or played secretary. But thats neither here nor there.

Moving on, I cant help notice you are missing 1100 starting gold. You wouldnt happen to have used them for edicts that will help with this *specific* fight would you...?

There is a reason i said
To fit with what you just implied, plus the espoused narrative from the herobook conversation, where you can calculate down to a hair's breadth all things RNG that may, could or will happen, you'll need to work beating the bar into an actual play you intend to finish
Because no one in their right mind, intending to play normally would start the game buying items and skills specifically directed for the entirely inconsequential and optional event of fighting in the bar. No, the smart thing anyone would do is shore up their financial situation with -expense and +income edicts.
And that's *not* what you did, is it?
The point was simulating an actual run, like mine, whose success - by all accounts - you severely hampered by opting for day 1 combat purchases. Its not a playthrough you ever intended to finish, which invalidates the whole premise of the experiment.

Just because you can't do it, doesn't mean it is impossible
...you are just wanking to the sound of your keystrokes with this one. And again, you are completely missing the idea. Barfight can be done day 1. Just not even close to reliably enough, so that one would risk actually doing it in a run, you'd intend to finish.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RedAISkye
Aug 11, 2020
349
961
Mind Training 1 and Healing Thoughts. If you don't buy the +10 Acc. Items, which makes sence in a Aspring Hero Challenge Run, you need to have staying power. So being able to replenish Energy is a must. Now ofc I would still not fight in the Bar. It only takes a bad roll with a red Thug to ruin your day.
A sensible strategy and probably the only strategy that's close to being viable on day 1.

But I'm going to call bullshit too because you have 1 corruption. You only get corruption from buying accessories (which you can't because you don't have edict points left), from fighting the guards near the office (the chances of you having a nice rounded 900 gold in both screenshots after that fight are one in a billion) and certain edicts (which you can't buy because you have no points left). Maybe I'm missing something here, but I'm pretty sure those are all the sources of corruption in the game.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Assassin3

Neriel

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2018
1,018
1,054
Where to start...Ok for the most obvious, images can in no way show items equipped or game difficulty. For all i know, you slapped some accessories then removed them after the fight, *or* how many tries it took you. But thats neither here nor there.
Oh yeah, because the very obvious Corruption 1 doesn't clearly show, that I didn't buy a single Acc. Item. Or the -9 in Control doesn't show, that it is Prisoner Mode with the insane - in income I have. Now with the tries... look I really don't care. It is clear, that you will question everything anyway, even if evidence slaps you in the face and since I cannot prove that it was first try, think what you want.

Moving on, I cant help notice you are missing 1100 starting gold. You wouldnt happen to have used them for edicts that will help with this *specific* fight would you...?
My first day I always go for Edicts that improve my fighting ability. Normally that would be 2 Acc. Items with +10 Agi and +10 Dex to make fights easier. So same Story here. Just that I go for Mind Training 1 and Healing Thoughts. I don't worry too much about money, since the main income will happen anyways at the start from low Order and farming money on the First Floor, not because of Edicts.

There is a reason i said
Because no one in their right mind, intending to play normally would start the game buying items and skills specifically directed for the entirely inconsequential and optional event of fighting in the bar. No, the smart thing anyone would do is shore up their financial situation with -expense and +income edicts.
And that's *not* what you did, is it?
The point was simulating an actual run, like mine, whose success - by all accounts - you severely hampered by opting for day 1 combat purchases. Its not a playthrough you ever intended to finish, which invalidates the whole premise of the experiment.


...you are just wanking to the sound of your keystrokes now.
Well maybe then you are doing something wrong? Or maybe, just maybe, there are more ways to play the game. Crazy thought. It is actually kinda funny, that somebody like you, comes at me like this. If you would have been here a few months people would have said to you, the things you are doing are impossible on Prisoner Mode since you need x Titles. You are actually good enough to beat Prisoner Mode without the help of NG+ but at the same time, somehow are very limited in your viewpoint. I never start with fixing my Income right away. I focus on making fights as easy as possible, to make farming on the First Floor easy. So yes, I was simulating how I would start a run like that. Ok I would not fight in the Bar, since it is still a risk that you don't have to take but that would be hard to do in an argument, that is about beating the Bar Day 1.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Assassin3
4.60 star(s) 442 Votes