So to see what Selebus thought about Wizard-s*x I searched for his comments on the discord server. These are his comments
" I will never stop being creeped out by the people who think it’s okay to bang the high school girls but not the wizards (edited)
Treating fictional characters like real people is fucking weird to begin with but you’ve gotta be a real sketch to think just one of those things is okay if you’re going to apply real life characteristics and rights to the girls "
Sooo.... it seems like he doesn't see a difference between the lolis wizards and the class which is retarded. I think there will be explicit wizard stuff but behind an unofficial "fan" patch or something.
If I could try to interpret this stance on the situation, my initial reaction to this is that Sel can't avoid the reading that someone fine with sex with the rest of the class but upset by sex with the wizards is actively moralizing fictional sex depictions based on their real-world morality. In other words, by projecting some of your real world morality into the fictional world and avoiding sex with wizards, Sel extrapolates that when you enjoy engaging with the classroom you are ALSO makings decisions based on your real world morality.
With just this to go on, it seems like Sel only finds your morality consistent if you either:
A: Find grooming and sex with students repulsive and don't want to see it even in ficiton.
B: Don't apply real world morality to fictional characters and are fine with seeing anything.
I see where it's coming from, but I think it's a pretty reductive take. To use myself as an example, this position would find my stance on gore as simlarly hypocritical. I don't like watching extra gory horror films not because I find it morally reprehensible to depict necessarily, it just makes me personally uncomfortable to see past a certain point. Some bloody and realistic depictions are fine while others are too gratuitous and just overwhelm me. It's not that I "morally and intellectually can't watch the terrible thing happen" I just start having physical reactions to certain visuals that I'd rather avoid, given the choice.