LoveRedHairedGirl

Active Member
Dec 18, 2020
754
2,319
Worse. He rendered one image, slapped it on a track that was already composed by someone else, and called it progress.

I don't care if he swam in his music library for hours, or went out of his way and actually communicated to request access to the track, or did some little edits to the track itself; all of those are misplaced efforts in my eye.

With that being said though, at least Yasu's song feels more in depth than Miku's; that at least he can earn some petty credits.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I swear, if he post the idols I actually follow, I will cringe so much...
 

Bingoogus

Engaged Member
Sep 5, 2021
3,794
10,449
Teacher's pet Makoto's appreciation post. Can you remember all of these events?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And the very best for last!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Edit: Bless you, Makoto. Teaching all of us that all that you need to beat clinical depression is awareness of being stuck in an endless timeloop :ROFLMAO:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

DeSkel15

Engaged Member
Sep 29, 2019
2,591
8,769
Teacher's pet Makoto's appreciation post. Can you remember all of these events?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And the very best for last!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Bless you, Makoto. Teaching all of us that all that you need to beat clinical depression is awareness of being stuck in an endless timeloop :ROFLMAO:
One of my fav Makoto moments:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I still remember going "Dayum Makoto". She has some savage remarks throughout the game.

Also, because I'm a little pedantic, and I think it might be important later on:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Detective Dc345

Well-Known Member
May 27, 2020
1,406
10,343
Teacher's pet Makoto's appreciation post. Can you remember all of these events?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And the very best for last!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Edit: Bless you, Makoto. Teaching us that all that you need to beat clinical depression is awareness of being stuck in an endless timeloop :ROFLMAO:
Sorry, Sensei Moonflare. Makoto isnt naked in any of these corresponding events so they didnt stick in my head.
 

fdsasdf_p

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2021
1,102
4,661
Teacher's pet Makoto's appreciation post. Can you remember all of these events?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And the very best for last!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Edit: Bless you, Makoto. Teaching us that all that you need to beat clinical depression is awareness of being stuck in an endless timeloop :ROFLMAO:

I'm Not Here
To Sleep, Perchance to Dream
Humans With Hollow Bones
Bluejay
Happy Place
Wicked Witch of Kumon-mi
The Color White
Acute Love Triangle
Whisper of the World
A Beautiful Mind
Breakaway
Midnight Mom Mosh
Suffer the Same
Human Females
The Rest of Me
To Catch Me if I Fall
On the Count of Three
Hunger Games
Rubber Traits
Pros, Cons, and Countermeasures
Midnight Snack
T is For Time
Flowers and Forklifts
Heaven for Human Blood
To Sleep, Perchance to Dream
House of the Unholy
Permission Slip
Bingoogus Approved
Young Cardinals
May the Winter Come

16m11s. Thought I could do this in 10 min :ROFLMAO:
PS. It took a lot of time for Makoto to grow on me. I have this stupid glasses anti-fetish and plenty of times her hair feels like a hard shell helmet. But I now walk the path with everyone else.

Edit: oops forgot to mention fav Makoto moment
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:

TBone9

Member
Apr 6, 2023
172
365
whatever it is, if i stood before you with a magical glowing door and said if you went through the door you could live out your hottest sexual fantasy like it was 100% real but with absolutely no consequences whatsoever... can you confidently say you wouldn't walk through it?
My only worry would be not slamming into the door rushing to get through before you could open it all the way.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Bingoogus

daagagsdgd

Newbie
May 9, 2019
60
180
Makoto was pretty basic at the start (As most chrs were) it was until the later events where she starts to mature a lot that she grew on me.
IDK about what did it for you lot tho.
The same with me. At first she's kinda like the typical class rep falling for teacher you watched in anime so I flat out ignored her. And to be honest Akira in Ch.1 was a perfect imitation of teen creeper and molester (he grew more and more humane only afterwards) and his interactions with Makoto was not even funny.

It's only until Blue Jay that my comfortable ennui shattered to piece. My pupils were shaking when she said "But just now I understand what I wish to become. I want to be a blue jay." Sometimes it's just thing you were undeliberately ignored you found in a sudden become glittering than anything.

It's until Beach visit with Makoto in Ch.2 that made me finally realize how much had I taken for granted and how mistreated she was all along. And I should treat everyone better and stop having mindset of a porn game reviewer. It's a very interesting process I've encountered with since the game itself kept externalizing any event from readers, labeling us as "not here", we can't help but notice that for some reason this externally expressed feeling and pain enter into us.

But somehow everything turned out to be good, not with reset forcing her become normal, but the real comfort she met (again from Ami, never thought she faked it) that she's not alone while encountering sadness like passing of father. After all of that happened one of my favourite event - Young Cardinals. For me it's the place where her tragic life is summed up and revealed after all the tiresome hashing-over of parts. It's astronguishingly refreshing and delivering for a game filled up with uncertainties and insecurties. At that moment the blue jay has overcame a full circle and grew to a red bird.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

shmurfer

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2019
2,030
2,434
I don't get it. Like, is he just posting songs by using AI voices?
Nah they're pre-existing. A few updates later and there might be a Miku event using her lilfest song, and if Yasu has another big moment it'd be using this one (Personally, Yasu's new song sounds like it'd play with just her and Akira having a moment where they connect and can talk to a god directly or something, some big truth bomb being explained.)

They're just using voices Sel imagines the girl would use. (Maya, Uta, Ami, Niki and Yasu have similar songs in the game already, and now Niki and Yasu have multiple songs and they both use the same singer per character, for whatever good that insight is.)

He's probably got a bunch of songs picked out for most of the girls ( )

And it's totally a gimmie of a lilfest update day. Man wanted a day to 100% spryo 2 or something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LoveRedHairedGirl

SmallsMalone

Newbie
Sep 7, 2017
15
44
Hello again everyone, I really love coming through here and reading the theories from the regulars and I've grown to greatly respect the opinions and persepctives of some of the familiar faces. This drought has driven me to try to create my own glimpse into the void and I've been trying to do some research but I think you dedicated folks are the only ones that have the answers I'm looking for.

I think it's safe to say that a lot of us are here because these characters have burned their mark into our souls. Whether it's the unfiltered antics, Sel's unique writing flair or just the fact we've spent so damn many hours with them, they're here to stay and there's nothing we can do about it.

I caught up to the current patches late last year. My patience for soaking up lore and digging through the game for theories didn't last long so in short order their silent voices faded from my day to day, leaving behind an unsettling hollow within.

As time passed, that vacuous hole gathered within it the arrogance that I too, had a story to tell. That I could dust off an old setting in my fantasies and explore the intersection of intimacy, philosophy and agency on my own terms and in my own style. Sel did it at such a seemingly small budget, so why couldn't I? I dove deep into outlining and foundational work and lo and behold, something tangible, workable sits in my One Note, waiting for a path forward. However, as I researched the practical elements of stepping into the ring, something became abundantly clear.

Lessons in Love is a statistical anomaly. We're all familiar with the gameplay issues, the grinding, the reset puzzles and the ego trips. Beyond that lies the generic visuals, the stock animations, the boner-killing sex scenes and the unavoidable absurdity of the HAPPY events. This is something that should not exist. I love it for these things, as do many of us here but it's 2025 now and the rules seem to have changed.

If I follow this path will there be an audience at the other end? Am I taking inspiration from the wrong place? Does this corner of the internet still have any patience left for this aesthetic, or would I have to jump on the Daz Filatoon bandwagon to be taken seriously? Assuming my hubris is actually just premature confidence, can a linguistic style and depth of topic chasing the coattails of works like LiL and Subahibi carry a work such that it will find it's audience no matter the aesthetics?

I know I should be simply continuing the writing grind using placeholder visuals if I have to. However, I'd like to start planting the seeds for the visuals in this work soon so the persepctive from those uniquely dedicated to one of it's core inspirations is incredibly welcome.

Thanks to any who take the time to share their thoughts. Take care of yourselves and have a HAPPY "Fanfest"


P.S. - If anyone found that attempt at a Pareidolia Mall map useful or thinks it would be worth keeping around if I find a way to clean it up, I could see if I can cook something up.
 
Feb 17, 2024
459
526
They're just using voices Sel imagines the girl would use. (Maya, Uta, Ami, Niki and Yasu have similar songs in the game already, and now Niki and Yasu have multiple songs and they both use the same singer per character, for whatever good that insight is.)
I don't think the Maya one counts, it's just a song that fits the moment, like Ichiyarakka for Sana. Also, I think the two Niki songs are by two different singers? Unless the Uzuho and Shiho thing in the description of the videos is just a translation issue.

If I follow this path will there be an audience at the other end? Am I taking inspiration from the wrong place? Does this corner of the internet still have any patience left for this aesthetic, or would I have to jump on the Daz Filatoon bandwagon to be taken seriously? Assuming my hubris is actually just premature confidence, can a linguistic style and depth of topic chasing the coattails of works like LiL and Subahibi carry a work such that it will find it's audience no matter the aesthetics?
I'd say to check how the LiL-inspired ones work. Though they aren't exactly LiL-inspired, but it is what it is. I do love the ones I follow.
I'm sure however you choose to make the gameplay loop could still work even if you DAZ it up, but you better become good at composition, because it's one of the things Sel does best with scenes. You can of course compensate for it improving or excelling in the other ways you already mentioned, but that's your choice.
Also, depending on the story you want to tell, you're probably going to struggle attracting attention. Excluding the style, and again, depending on what's your story, it's gonna be hard to promote depending on how "deep" or how gratuitously erotic it is. Also, consistency would be key, Sel pretty much has followed a web serial style of release, with releases ALWAYS coming out on a schedule and changes to said schedule being announced with time to spare.

I think I lost the plot somewhere, but the attention span of a playerbase is something you will struggle with, style may not matter that much, consistency is key, and you'll have problems if your story, despite being interesting, is like .
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: SmallsMalone

FireCazador

Member
May 22, 2020
269
570
He's probably got a bunch of songs picked out for most of the girls ( )
Well, i didnt expect to find the original song from pedobear here. Also its only 14yo? I thought it would be older


Teacher's pet Makoto's appreciation post. Can you remember all of these events?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And the very best for last!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Edit: Bless you, Makoto. Teaching us that all that you need to beat clinical depression is awareness of being stuck in an endless timeloop :ROFLMAO:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:

SmallsMalone

Newbie
Sep 7, 2017
15
44
I'd say to check how the LiL-inspired ones work. Though they aren't exactly LiL-inspired, but it is what it is. I do love the ones I follow.

Heck yeah, thanks for the intel! Sel's use of composition is a big part of what makes me so stubborn about using a 3D snapshot style rather than a 2D sprite style. The presence and liveliness of the characters are truly standout features. I especially love how often the characters acknowledge each other or display unnecessary body language that contrasts with the rest of the scene.

I'm curious about what other works you have in mind when you talk about inspiration?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Antosha

Rincon

Newbie
Jul 29, 2023
76
184
I haven't checked the forum in a bit seeing as absolutely nothing is going on, how is everyone enjoying LiL Fan Fest crap, I mean content?
 

Moonflare

Well-Known Member
Aug 23, 2023
1,881
9,398
If I follow this path will there be an audience at the other end? Am I taking inspiration from the wrong place?

I know I should be simply continuing the writing grind using placeholder visuals if I have to. However, I'd like to start planting the seeds for the visuals in this work soon so the persepctive from those uniquely dedicated to one of it's core inspirations is incredibly welcome.

Thanks to any who take the time to share their thoughts.
We crap on Selebus as a programmer a lot, but that is more related to how high grade his storytelling abilities are compared to it. LiL is not that crappy tbh, it's above average from a technical standpoint at the very least. Actually, it's less his ability to program and more his choices of what to do with it that we have a problem with.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Anyway, I think we can all agree that it would be amazing to see something with Selebus' storytelling skills, Lost in you's much better user friendliness and "Eternum" level animations, don't get me wrong. But for your first project, if you want to write a good story, then write a good story. Also, finish your good story.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Feb 17, 2024
459
526
I haven't checked the forum in a bit seeing as absolutely nothing is going on, how is everyone enjoying LiL Fan Fest crap, I mean content?
As barebones as they were, I liked the "music videos" and the side story.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Not that really invested in the fanfest, tho, even if apparently there's wizard supremacy.

I'm curious about what other works you have in mind when you talk about inspiration?
LiL-inspired or in general for your own project? For the former check the first two posts of this thread (also adding Sorrow of Rebirth, liked that little game), and for the latter it would depend on what's your story, and I'm not that well-read so I wouldn't truly try to recommend you stuff for inspiration.
Being as blunt as possible (and quoting someone else), a "manchild grooms students and also his obsessive family member and also deals with surreal horror elements" story (or something in that vein) will always depend on how you choose to execute it. I suggest to touch grass in a literary way and look up stuff related to what themes you want to show and explore.
Also, forgot to mention this earlier but don't leave your music and song choices aside either.
 

SmallsMalone

Newbie
Sep 7, 2017
15
44
Being as blunt as possible (and quoting someone else), a "manchild grooms students and also his obsessive family member and also deals with surreal horror elements" story (or something in that vein) will always depend on how you choose to execute it. I suggest to touch grass in a literary way and look up stuff related to what themes you want to show and explore.
Also, forgot to mention this earlier but don't leave your music and song choices aside either.
Thanks again for the details. With that description, I realize I'm less inspired by the games trappings and more inspired by the methods it uses to motivate interest, the style of engagement it asks of the reader and it's raw exploration of the darker layers of connection and intimacy.

Without going too far into the weeds...

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

That being said, "the generic visuals, the stock animations, the boner-killing sex scenes and the unavoidable absurdity of the HAPPY events", these work because they point to something all of us (here) seem to know: this game is about its story. If I'm to read a book, sure, visuals help - but I'm not a kid, I'm here to draft meaning from the letters. Thus, if you have a good story to tell, compelling characters and an engaging plot - people will not care that much about everything else. That is, if you too distance your adult game from being an adult game, as Selebus did.

Without any sort of attack on "Lost in you" (in fact I'll play it again once it's finished to give it a fair shake), its visuals and overall programming are not that different from LiL (although LiL is still superior in every strictly technical aspect imo). So why does it not take off? Well, I personally did not dig the story. It's not bad, it's just not enough for me to ignore it being a game. This is the effect LiL has in me, it's like, rather than a game, it is a type of fruit that I have to peel to consume. The actual comsumption is the story, and the peeling is the stupid Selebus crap.

You can make a game that has less peeling involved (as "Lost in you" has), but at the end of the day, if the fruit itself is not that tasty, memorable or leaving you with wanting more - then it's just whatever. It will keep sitting on the shelf as I have to work to peel off the tastier one. Again, nothing against "Lost in you" - I just feel like it helps to explain LiL by comparing the two. Basically, why LiL is LiL, and "Lost in you" is an adult renpy game called "Lost in you". You see what I mean?
Thanks for the detailed input! Your perspective was one of the ones I was looking forward to the most and it certianly didn't disappoint. I'll make a point to take a look at Lost in You, compare and contrast is one of my favorite tools for understanding what makes something good anwyay.


You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
4.10 star(s) 328 Votes