Ready to play dirty? Command your Lust Goddess now. Play Now!
x

Moonflare

Engaged Member
Aug 23, 2023
2,349
13,623
599
Noticed something I never really thought about on my latest playthrough
long rant of me theorizing about two lines in the early main event: "O World (In Our Final Moments)" (the grave one):

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
"What have they done to your body" is an interesting part of that quote insofar as the simulation is concerned.

That being said, some recent revelations (through the FanFest) reinforce the idea of the wish. Specifically with Maya being the one wishing (as it seems more or less clear that that's also what she was doing to reset the world each time).

The one thing that currently complicates that idea is Ami. Alt Ami has stated that Maya was not a part of the original resets/and or the original timeline (having difficulty even considering her a real person). Thus, making Ami the one that would have wished (if one of the girls). In fact, Ami has put forward the idea that she's the original "Maya" (in the sense of being the one with the role that Maya acquired later), and recently even called herself the "girl with the worst luck" (which is what Maya used to call herself).

Mind you, the Ami stuff is highly confusing at the moment (no actual revelation there yet). However, the one canon ending of the game that we have happens through Ami's death, with Akira actually growing older (and the world moving beyond the resets). Selebus confirms this (to some extent) on his commentary to "Times new roman", thus this could potentially make Ami the one making the wish, if through her death the loops suddenly stop (for at least ten years).
 

Squalicorax

Newbie
Jun 1, 2023
76
238
125
"What have they done to your body" is an interesting part of that quote insofar as the simulation is concerned.

That being said, some recent revelations (through the FanFest) reinforce the idea of the wish. Specifically with Maya being the one wishing (as it seems more or less clear that that's also what she was doing to reset the world each time).

The one thing that currently complicates that idea is Ami. Alt Ami has stated that Maya was not a part of the original resets/and or the original timeline (having difficulty even considering her a real person). Thus, making Ami the one that would have wished (if one of the girls). In fact, Ami has put forward the idea that she's the original "Maya" (in the sense of being the one with the role that Maya acquired later), and recently even called herself the "girl with the worst luck" (which is what Maya used to call herself).

Mind you, the Ami stuff is highly confusing at the moment (no actual revelation there yet). However, the one canon ending of the game that we have happens through Ami's death, with Akira actually growing older (and the world moving beyond the resets). Selebus confirms this (to some extent) on his commentary to "Times new roman", thus this could potentially make Ami the one making the wish, if through her death the loops suddenly stop (for at least ten years).
Ooh, all of that sounds interesting. I'm not sure I understand the "Alt Ami" bit (I also saw someone refer to an "Alt Sekai") is that about fanfest stuff or does it have to do with the alternate timelimes from that one recent update?

The Ami stuff is peaks my interest in particular because my theory for the reason she goes berserk when other people talk about the loops is because she knows she's the key (or at least one of the keys) to ending the loops. Can you explain the "Canon Ending" thing you mentioned? Is that from an update through 46-49, fanfest stuff, or something older I've forgotten about?
 
  • Like
Reactions: crustlord12

shmurfer

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2019
3,125
4,850
387
Ooh, all of that sounds interesting. I'm not sure I understand the "Alt Ami" bit (I also saw someone refer to an "Alt Sekai") is that about fanfest stuff or does it have to do with the alternate timelimes from that one recent update?

The Ami stuff is peaks my interest in particular because my theory for the reason she goes berserk when other people talk about the loops is because she knows she's the key (or at least one of the keys) to ending the loops. Can you explain the "Canon Ending" thing you mentioned? Is that from an update through 46-49, fanfest stuff, or something older I've forgotten about?
I'm a little busy to doublecheck if Alt Ami is the Ami that stabbed Nodoka, but when I referenced Alt Sekai I was talking about the Sekai in that world. She's a bit too "I only exist for Ami's happiness" for me to say she's the real Sekai that's so deep Akira had trauma over losing her (Don't stab that girl now the others won't like you :( ha ha ha)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Squalicorax

TheGoodPastor

Member
Feb 8, 2024
378
1,387
172
Ooh, all of that sounds interesting. I'm not sure I understand the "Alt Ami" bit (I also saw someone refer to an "Alt Sekai") is that about fanfest stuff or does it have to do with the alternate timelimes from that one recent update?

The Ami stuff is peaks my interest in particular because my theory for the reason she goes berserk when other people talk about the loops is because she knows she's the key (or at least one of the keys) to ending the loops. Can you explain the "Canon Ending" thing you mentioned? Is that from an update through 46-49, fanfest stuff, or something older I've forgotten about?
One of the fanfest extras was a commentary on the reset event 'Times New Roman' (the one where Sensei is locked inside his house to protect him from the outside world) and Sel basically explains that the event is another timeline where the loops stopped at 'End of the World' (the scene prior where Maya and Ayane find Ami dead in the hall) and Sensei's (almost) completely isolated himself from the rest of the world to avoid being hurt and hurting others.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Squalicorax

Newbie
Jun 1, 2023
76
238
125
I'm a little busy to doublecheck if Alt Ami is the Ami that stabbed Nodoka, but when I referenced Alt Sekai I was talking about the Sekai in that world. She's a bit too "I only exist for Ami's happiness" for me to say she's the real Sekai that's so deep Akira had trauma over losing her (Don't stab that girl now the others won't like you :( ha ha ha)
Ah, thanks for the clarity. I do wonder about what you're saying about Sekai though. I think Akira's trauma over her has more to do with their complex abusive relationship than anything to do with how deep she was, and Alt Sekai felt in line with what I would expect out of Ghost Sekai.

One of the fanfest extras was a commentary on the reset event 'Times New Roman' (the one where Sensei is locked inside his house to protect him from the outside world) and Sel basically explains that the event is another timeline where the loops stopped at 'End of the World' (the scene prior where Maya and Ayane find Ami dead in the hall) and Sensei's (almost) completely isolated himself from the rest of the world to avoid being hurt and hurting others.
Fuck now I have to actually read the Fanfest stuff because that's my favorite reset by far. I was contemplating skipping it but now I know that this is a thing I'm locked in, unfortunately.
Edit: WAIT A FUCKING MINUTE. I just remembered I have an old post on this thread where I speculated all the weirdness of that reset was us actually getting glimpses of other timelines and people gave the canned "it's all in Akira's head" excuse (iirc, sorry if I'm slandering you, whoever you were) and I FUCKING KNEW IT. Get owned the lot of you. First I was right about Ami then I was right about that reset I cannot stop winning oorah.
 
Last edited:

fasoaga

Member
Jul 24, 2017
301
1,136
286
I'm a little busy to doublecheck if Alt Ami is the Ami that stabbed Nodoka, but when I referenced Alt Sekai I was talking about the Sekai in that world. She's a bit too "I only exist for Ami's happiness" for me to say she's the real Sekai that's so deep Akira had trauma over losing her (Don't stab that girl now the others won't like you :( ha ha ha)
I agree on Alt Sekai. I am too lazy to find it but aramaug has a post about how Ami rapes Maya is very similar to how Sekai rapes Tsuneyo. Using similar words etc which totally convinces me Sekai can control Ami just like she controls Kaori.

But there is something scary about it.

We know when Sekai takes control of Kaori by the eyes.
We don't know When she takes control of Ami because they have the SAME EYES.
 

TheGoodPastor

Member
Feb 8, 2024
378
1,387
172
Fuck now I have to actually read the Fanfest stuff because that's my favorite reset by far. I was contemplating skipping it but now I know that this is a thing I'm locked in, unfortunately.
Yeah, mine too. Lacklustre though fanfest was it's still worth grabbing for the two commentaries in my opinion. Personally I enjoyed Forever Young too lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Squalicorax

shmurfer

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2019
3,125
4,850
387
Ah, thanks for the clarity. I do wonder about what you're saying about Sekai though. I think Akira's trauma over her has more to do with their complex abusive relationship than anything to do with how deep she was, and Alt Sekai felt in line with what I would expect out of Ghost Sekai.
It's more that her reaction to Ami stabbing Nodoka makes that Sekai seem too stupid to be real.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

They even lampshade that fact with the first part of "God of Light" being written and performed like a sitcom complete with canned laughter

To me that's what Ami thinks the ideal Sekai would be, in a setting where she could wish for her ideal Sekai.

Yeah, mine too. Lacklustre though fanfest was it's still worth grabbing for the two commentaries in my opinion. Personally I enjoyed Forever Young too lol
This is one of the best things to have come out of fanfest

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Squalicorax

Newbie
Jun 1, 2023
76
238
125
It's more that her reaction to Ami stabbing Nodoka makes that Sekai seem too stupid to be real.
Maybe, but I honestly think living, main timeline Sekai was also kind of reckless in a dumb way. I get the sense she thought she could get away with anything considering the whole Akira situation and the fact she was publicly writing about it*. I could totally see this being an alternate timeline where Ami wished for an idealized world with Sekai though, so I'm not gonna totally discount this either.

(*Also ties into my more out there theory that maybe she could actually get away with so much stupid, obvious stuff for a reason, I think she probably has ties to the Tsukiokas and the Yasu religion that used to exist mentioned by Touka. Specifically because of the Tsukioka sakura tree that I suspect is both very relevant (and maybe tied to the whole wishing well business? Interestingly there's also a surprisngly early bit hinting at the wishing well immediately after the part I was talking about with Akira's suicide, considering the whole context of that event it feels super relevant) and also tied into Sekai and her Sakura association, but all of that is besides the point that I think Sekai actually was just that dumb, or at least reckless)
 

Moonflare

Engaged Member
Aug 23, 2023
2,349
13,623
599
Edit: WAIT A FUCKING MINUTE. I just remembered I have an old post on this thread where I speculated all the weirdness of that reset was us actually getting glimpses of other timelines and people gave the canned "it's all in Akira's head" excuse (iirc, sorry if I'm slandering you, whoever you were) and I FUCKING KNEW IT. Get owned the lot of you. First I was right about Ami then I was right about that reset I cannot stop winning oorah.
I went back to the conversation and that wasn't exactly what you said (plus you mostly talked about "Paper city", not "Times new roman"). Granted, you said a lot of stuff. Nor did DeSkel say that it was all in Akira's head either. Regardless, Selebus' explanation goes more in the way of "it's all in Akira's head" than "it's all happening in a different timeline" (although it is a mix of the two).

If you watch the commentary to "Il cervo", it becomes very clear (to a divisive degree) that a bunch of stuff is just Selebus throwing whatever metaphors he wants at a single moment and not caring to say they're metaphors. I mean, "Il cervo" never happened, and I've yet to find a single person that got out of that event with this conclusion. To me is just a mix of bad writing and an experiment, leaning more towards bad writing imo.

"Times new roman" is less divisive because, since it's a reset, we already expect that Akira is tripping. But parts of Ami throughout the house is in his head, porn videos of people he knows is in his head, what's inside the drawers (including living things) is in his head. Most of "Times new roman" isn't happening at all. The part that is are small things: the picture of Niki, Sana visiting him, Yasu talking to him on the phone, him becoming deranged and blaming himself because of Ami's death - those are all real.

So, really, in this ending, Akira went insane and locked himself inside the house for a decade. It also tells us that most of the shit he sees isn't real. There is no supernatural or hidden meaning to most (and possibly any) of it, he just has mental problems and projects his traumas into visual imagery. Obviously that is the case for this one event, we can at most speculate for the rest.
 

Squalicorax

Newbie
Jun 1, 2023
76
238
125
plus you mostly talked about "Paper city", not "Times new roman"
Fair, though for clarity with 'that reset' I mean more all the events tied to it, not just Time New Roman, including paper city and whatever the Ayane fake reset event is called.

It also tells us that most of the shit he sees isn't real. There is no supernatural or hidden meaning to most (and possibly any) of it, he just has mental problems and projects his traumas into visual imagery.
I haven't read the fanfest commentaries yet obviously, so maybe I'll change my tune, but for now I'll say I disagree with this pretty vehemently. Hallucinations and mental problems are explicitly tied to the supernatural throughout the entire game. Ghost Sekai, who is most obviously a product of Akira projecting "his traumas into visual imagery" is shown to be able to operate independently of him and have material effects on the world, most notably of course lifting up one of the Angel dolls in front of Yasu. Yasu can't see her, but she sees the doll floating. I think if things were normal in Kumon-Mi you could say this, but I think the supernatural elements of Kumon-Mi literally manifest from people's trauma, from the timeloop to the angels and gods, all of it. Yeah, Akira hallucinates, and probably would without any supernatural influence but he also exists in a supernatural situation that preys on his trauma and mental illness. The supernatural isn't causing people's hallucinations, I think it's the opposite, people's hallucinations are causing the supernatural because the lines between perception and reality are being blurred and reality is to a degree subjective in Kumon-Mi. I also think saying they have no meaning is throwing the baby out with the bathwater way too early, especially considering a lot of them do have clear and obvious meanings, though I will admit a lot seems like random bullshit I can't decipher. There's also stuff that I'm pretty sure is symbolism but I haven't persoanlly figured out (the squid stuff) (in my reading, of course, not trying to state that all as objective fact)
 

fdsasdf_p

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2021
1,241
5,868
637
What are you guys’ thoughts on Ami Prime referring to herself as “another regular teenager with the worst luck in the world”?
1747182914724.png
This of course is a throwback to Maya Prime, and subtly insinuating how Ami Prime fares in the reset business (self-proclaimed). However, this choice of words rings a different bell. How is Ami Prime able to say something so accurately mirroring Maya Prime’s catchphrase? During our journey, we've seen a few moments in which Maya Prime said that about herself, but it was done when the elephant in the room was about resets and/or her forbidden love for Sensei, and mostly when the two were alone (if you are willing to overlook what happened by the end of Stray Cat that is. This is the only moment I remembered though). Assuming Maya Prime never talked about being the girl with the worst luck in the world around her friends during inapplicable moments 24/7 before our journey began, how would Ami Prime know Maya Prime's iconic line?

This little doubt would easily go to a dead end if this is a mere coincidence, an "independent invention" situation, a case in where Ami Prime “simply knows shit" either because she at some point somehow was a trans-dimensional spectator or because Selly wasn’t being very meticulous in wording, or if my prior assumption is wrong and Maya Prime was in fact a blabber mouth. But, if none of the above is true and Ami Prime did learn this catchphrase via "normal means", this could potentially imply that Ami Prime learned that directly from Maya Prime (another way around also works too), then expanding to ideas like Ami Prime once operated at the same time as Maya Prime, maybe together like sisters in arms, or maybe against each other like rivals, tackling the same apocalypse and the same forbidden love affairs. Whatever the case is, a secret past where Maya Prime and Ami Prime doing more than just acknowledging each other's existence has always felt tangible, and the feeling gets stronger each time Ami Prime cites something supposedly only Maya Prime, Sensei, and us viewers fully understand.
 

SlidingSubject

Well-Known Member
Feb 17, 2024
1,054
1,139
249
Ghost Sekai, who is most obviously a product of Akira projecting "his traumas into visual imagery" is shown to be able to operate independently of him and have material effects on the world, most notably of course lifting up one of the Angel dolls in front of Yasu.
All this real or not real discussion reminds me of Umineko. The fact that it happened to Yasu of all people doesn't help.
If you wanna go into that rabbit hole, are the flashbacks of the past real? Or just something to give depth to the members of the class?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
people's hallucinations are causing the supernatural because the lines between perception and reality are being blurred and reality is to a degree subjective in Kumon-Mi
At some point you have to ask yourself, why is reality subjective? Is it just a prop, taken for granted and left as is, or is it a part of the setting, one which will come into play at some point?

if none of the above is true and Ami Prime did learn this catchphrase via "normal means", this could potentially imply that Ami Prime learned that directly from Maya Prime (another way around also works too), then expanding to ideas like Ami Prime once operated at the same time as Maya Prime
I'd go with this, but mostly that Maya didn't want to talk about the resets with Ami because she broke down under the weight of remembrance and that got the world reset (e.g. Bluejay, it WAS one, even if it was just a light case of the world moving backwards instead of forwards). But, maybe enough time passed, or maybe it was because Maya was the one talking, when she got infodumped by Makoto and Ayane, she didn't break (at least immediately). She managed to remember everything, or maybe just enough to pretend in front of a confused Maya and an even more confused Sensei.
 

LoveWhiteHairedGirl

Active Member
Dec 18, 2020
953
3,147
366
What are you guys’ thoughts on Ami Prime referring to herself as “another regular teenager with the worst luck in the world”?
View attachment 4836958
This of course is a throwback to Maya Prime, and subtly insinuating how Ami Prime fares in the reset business (self-proclaimed). However, this choice of words rings a different bell. How is Ami Prime able to say something so accurately mirroring Maya Prime’s catchphrase? During our journey, we've seen a few moments in which Maya Prime said that about herself, but it was done when the elephant in the room was about resets and/or her forbidden love for Sensei, and mostly when the two were alone (if you are willing to overlook what happened by the end of Stray Cat that is. This is the only moment I remembered though). Assuming Maya Prime never talked about being the girl with the worst luck in the world around her friends during inapplicable moments 24/7 before our journey began, how would Ami Prime know Maya Prime's iconic line?

This little doubt would easily go to a dead end if this is a mere coincidence, an "independent invention" situation, a case in where Ami Prime “simply knows shit" either because she at some point somehow was a trans-dimensional spectator or because Selly wasn’t being very meticulous in wording, or if my prior assumption is wrong and Maya Prime was in fact a blabber mouth. But, if none of the above is true and Ami Prime did learn this catchphrase via "normal means", this could potentially imply that Ami Prime learned that directly from Maya Prime (another way around also works too), then expanding to ideas like Ami Prime once operated at the same time as Maya Prime, maybe together like sisters in arms, or maybe against each other like rivals, tackling the same apocalypse and the same forbidden love affairs. Whatever the case is, a secret past where Maya Prime and Ami Prime doing more than just acknowledging each other's existence has always felt tangible, and the feeling gets stronger each time Ami Prime cites something supposedly only Maya Prime, Sensei, and us viewers fully understand.
What if Ami Prime started using this phrase? Then Maya Prime took the phrase, since she is a nerd and found it too cool to not use it.
 

shmurfer

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2019
3,125
4,850
387
What are you guys’ thoughts on Ami Prime referring to herself as “another regular teenager with the worst luck in the world”?
I don't have any hard ideas, but there's been a bunch of times both have been shown to be equivalent to each other. Copying each other's outfit, copying each other, appearing in events in each other's place.


There's also an instance of Ami creating a Maya for Sensei to make him love Ami more, but she doesn't do that and instead gets attacked by Ami.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

DeSkel15

Engaged Member
Sep 29, 2019
2,644
9,340
637
What are you guys’ thoughts on Ami Prime referring to herself as “another regular teenager with the worst luck in the world”?
View attachment 4836958
This of course is a throwback to Maya Prime, and subtly insinuating how Ami Prime fares in the reset business (self-proclaimed). However, this choice of words rings a different bell. How is Ami Prime able to say something so accurately mirroring Maya Prime’s catchphrase? During our journey, we've seen a few moments in which Maya Prime said that about herself, but it was done when the elephant in the room was about resets and/or her forbidden love for Sensei, and mostly when the two were alone (if you are willing to overlook what happened by the end of Stray Cat that is. This is the only moment I remembered though). Assuming Maya Prime never talked about being the girl with the worst luck in the world around her friends during inapplicable moments 24/7 before our journey began, how would Ami Prime know Maya Prime's iconic line?

This little doubt would easily go to a dead end if this is a mere coincidence, an "independent invention" situation, a case in where Ami Prime “simply knows shit" either because she at some point somehow was a trans-dimensional spectator or because Selly wasn’t being very meticulous in wording, or if my prior assumption is wrong and Maya Prime was in fact a blabber mouth. But, if none of the above is true and Ami Prime did learn this catchphrase via "normal means", this could potentially imply that Ami Prime learned that directly from Maya Prime (another way around also works too), then expanding to ideas like Ami Prime once operated at the same time as Maya Prime, maybe together like sisters in arms, or maybe against each other like rivals, tackling the same apocalypse and the same forbidden love affairs. Whatever the case is, a secret past where Maya Prime and Ami Prime doing more than just acknowledging each other's existence has always felt tangible, and the feeling gets stronger each time Ami Prime cites something supposedly only Maya Prime, Sensei, and us viewers fully understand.
Ami Prime has potentially known many Maya Primes:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
And she's likely known them intimately:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Along with the other girls, probably, based off an Alt Maya Prime:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

So, Ami Prime might know Maya and Maya Prime better than anyone, including Maya Prime herself.

Ami Prime also thinks that Maya was more or less pretending to be her:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Which still hasn't been explained, but could suggest that Maya Prime was copying Ami (or at least someone was). Hard to say what's really going on there.

Edit: I also feel compelled to note that Sekai could just be whispering things to say in Ami's ear:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:

shmurfer

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2019
3,125
4,850
387
And because I keep being brought back to the scene, I'm just gonna post this quick.

Earlier in the year I posted about a image that was never talked about that was hidden inside a random beach event with Io, Uta and Yasu. I didn't have the setup I have now to check all of the game code. Besides one use in Lifejacket which was used alongside lots of other "Why does it have to hurt so much" which probably references the obvious "please stop playing this game, it's only going to get worse" text.

It's spammed a bunch in the event where Maya is invisible and on the bed, alongside the text where the green scarf girl told him she loved him and got fingered on christmas (Which I believe a dev commentary confirmed that to be Maya) and the "I love you so much" scribbled over message.

It implies the hidden message is also from Maya's perspective. Whether that leads to something important, I don't know yet.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:
4.10 star(s) 338 Votes