As of v0.26
So, this game...
Well, it's great. Like, really great. Should I say more? Well, I might as well, now that I have slept on it.
Graphics:
They are good. Nothing obviously broken. I didn't really like the combat choreography, but that's just me.
There are animations for those who wonder and care (I don't). They are decent.
Characters:
The Main Character
He is a looser. And I mean a total looser. I really didn't like him at the start of the game, but he grows and grows a lot. Not always in a good way (he is going around messing with the minds of people) but he is not evil for the evilz sake. He has his good qualities (or at least you have enough control over him to nurture them) - he is loyal, brave, surprisingly caring and smart and his main problem was always that he is lazy. And the game makes it painfully obvious this is what the problem was.
As a whole he is a good character and is not as bad of a person... if you can look past the mind control part of the story. I know a lot of people won't be able to, but as far as MCs in adult games go - he is surprisingly nice. I liked him (you can bring the torches now).
But to like the character you must let him grow. At the start he is kind of the bog standard creep MC. And he gets pushed around a lot. But as he gets stronger he turns the tables, so don't despair.
The rest of the cast:
The cast is pretty big and most of them work well. You won't be meeting the same girl over and over - each one is different and a surprisingly well-rounded character. They are doing their own shit... until you mess with them and even after that they are not your puppets. I won't go in to detail for all, but I like most of them (like being defined as - they are well-written characters, I still wanna punch the royal envoy in the face).
Special note about your constant companion - at first I thought her annoying as hell, but as the story developed she grew on me. Half of the fun in the game is the constant banter between the two of you.
Another really good point for the game IMO is that it treats sexual orientation pretty decently. You can't just wave your hand and make a lesbian hungry for cock. Yes it's probably still quicker than realistic, but considering the very strict limitations in time the game gives you... yeah, it is really well approached topic.
Story.
Honestly... while engaging and well-written, the story is nothing stellar. Almost all "twists" are obvious. Some of them from a very early point in the game (If you don't know who the Lady in the Lake is - you are pretty blind
)
This is strangely not exactly a criticism of the story. It doesn't try to be more than it is and knowing where and when to stop is one of the hardest things about writing. I can't stress this enough.
Gameplay.
It's probably my main problem with the game. I get the idea, but I do have several problems with it, that I can't really ignore.
New Game Plus - I'm not certain it's a good idea in an adult game. I'm really not.Especially with such an otherwise simple system.
Training - while I like the idea of the different training sessions, I really don't like there is only one way to improve. There are no shortcuts, no alternative routes. Bravery training is the worst in that respect alongside Pathfinding.
Spell-learning - with the game having such a great secrets and investigation sub-systems in it, I would have really liked to see them involved in learning spells.
That said, none of those things is bad per se. It's my personal preference so... take it as you will.
Conclusion:
It's a very promising game with more than enough content and I'm not certain we have seen even half of it. Play it. You probably won't regret it.