I kinda and kinda don't agree with that take on Chloe. She's had it rough, yes, and then the question is: do you think those earlier events explain her state later in life so you can connect with her? We're not even talking about whether those events justify her behavior which is another discussion. It's definitely not justified for instance how all her potential was thrown away. Blue is blue and not strawberry blonde because she in part rebelled against herself quite drastically. Compare her with punk Rachel who kept her long blonde hair and was able to blend in with her peers more easily to keep up appearances. Her story is a well-told tragedy one can connect with, not a supercool (well, a bad idea is awesome until it's not), righteous rebellion against whatever because people around her have done the best they could for her - some would argue Max didn't and that's one of her huge shortcomings, so Chloe found out what her best friend really was like: a girl with her own issues and a social ineptitude in certain situations. Everything from when she started going downhill to just driving off after the destruction of her hometown and people like her mom and even David undoubtedly wondering if she died is wrong, tragic, melodramatic, melancholic. The fact is, she reacted to her situation in the worst way possible. One of the things that attracts me to Chloe is how much she keeps it real; her sincerity and emotional genuineness are things I can't appreciate enough. Which leads me back to Warren's situation. It's really weird for me that people cut their favorite character this much slack - while Cloe is my own favorite character indeed, but not a tiny bit of charity can be extended to characters like Warren. This is not about slandering Chloe, it's about slandering Warren while acknowledging Chloe isn't a great character because she's (totally not) perfect (*) but because she's genuine and worth sympathizing with.
(*) In her own words: "Glass looks way prettier when it's broken. Wonder what else that's true for?"
And another one to demonstrate how broken everything is in LIS: "Maybe the lies we tell each other are less horrible than the truths we keep hidden?"
I'm also on Team Rachel, but her being alive would mean the junkyard scene was staged, Nathan was even more insane and less aware of reality or easily made to believe lies than previously thought and the autopsy results would have demonstrated that. What a great twist that would be in the LIS3 we're probably never getting. And that fact rustles my jimmies (they're already so rustled they're in orbit going to the moon) to this day.
I don't know why I even bother at this point, but still hiding the biggest spoilers.