CREATE YOUR AI CUM SLUT ON CANDY.AI TRY FOR FREE
x

PTGames

Developer of Lunar's Chosen
Donor
Respected User
Game Developer
Sep 17, 2018
2,314
3,862
Right stupid of me to get invested in a game's story and characters.
You didn't though. Because the games stories and characters are that Amy and Claire are best friends, who have a sexual history and are highly competitive. They often make bets and have sexual consequences as the forfeit. On top of that, despite losing and often having to be subservient to Claire in some way, Amy never tries to get out of it because she is far to proud to admit defeat and possibly even enjoys it a little bit.

So, whatever version of events and characters you got invested in, isn't the same as what's being told and portrayed in the story and game.

It's absolutely fine to dislike content. It's even fine to come in and actively tell me you dislike content, I actually encourage that. Constructive feedback is incredibly useful in a creative project like this. What isn't fine is coming in kicking off, ranting nonsensically and insulting the work saying a character is ruined just because the story doesn't fit the narrative you've created. That's both just pointless and insulting.
 

PapaPhat

Engaged Member
Mar 31, 2022
3,337
5,622
OK, I could do with some advice if anyone can help me, I am super massively pissed off after being forced to watch helplessly see my image of my sweet Amy being ruined by some narcissistic man-hating piece of shit cunt treat her like a dog and put a stupid fucking cucky chastity cage on her, should I go with my instincts and rage quit before I am forced to watch Katie and or worse Amber be completely ruined too.
Look, Havik... I have tried to help you with this title, I really have. There are some things I do not like about the game too, like the fully body covering latex suits. Those are a hard turn off for me. However, I do not let those few things that I don't like hinder my overall enjoyment of the game. This game is a ton of fun yet cannot be taken too seriously as there are elements that are really way out "in left field!"

If you cannot handle Claire and Amy's bets then you are in for several more shocks in this story! One bet Amy loses results in her being locked in a full body cage nude at the club and used as both cocktail table and conversation piece while allowing all comers to write whatever they want on her body in exchange for a donation to charity!

Amy is fully aware that Claire will humiliate her if she loses the bet and Amy STILL makes the bet! The only one to blame is Amy who had something devious planned for Claire if Amy had won the bet. This is a dynamic of their friendship. So, if you cannot deal with it then, please, STFU and GTFO NOW!!! I have tried to be a friend and explain this game to you but you still want to take a shit in the middle of my nice, generally peaceful forum visit. One more outburst like this and you will be on my ignore list so I do not have to read any more of your toxic comments. That means no more Phat to help you out with ANYTHING because all of your comments will be hidden.

Adventure ever on, Phat:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

Master of Puppets

Conversation Conqueror
Oct 5, 2017
7,548
10,058
That reminds me, we have seen Amy lose a few bets, I can't remember if any of the scenes have her winning the bet and Claire losing. Has that happened and I forgot about it? If not, it is about time for it I'd say.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaPhat

Bob69

Uploading the World
Uploader
Donor
Compressor
Mar 2, 2019
13,888
149,218
That reminds me, we have seen Amy lose a few bets, I can't remember if any of the scenes have her winning the bet and Claire losing. Has that happened and I forgot about it? If not, it is about time for it I'd say.
Was the buff/bimbo Claire scene in the Gym a bet with Amy or MC? I only really remember that one, that Claire lost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaPhat

PapaPhat

Engaged Member
Mar 31, 2022
3,337
5,622
Was the buff/bimbo Claire scene in the Gym a bet with Amy or MC? I only really remember that one, that Claire lost.
Pretty sure Amy won in the gym but I may be wrong... IDK now... That was a fun scene any way you slice it. That much I DO remember;)

Adventure ever on my friends, Phat:devilish:(y)
 

OttO45

Member
Aug 24, 2022
105
52
Hi.

Have a problem with Katie as it says I will take more porn from Amy.
I've checked at the pool via the phone but only get back, just like at the photo studio it's the same under friends.

Have I accidentally got some weird bug or something?

I have a picture of what it says right next to Katie on the computer if that would help screenshot0001.png
 

PTGames

Developer of Lunar's Chosen
Donor
Respected User
Game Developer
Sep 17, 2018
2,314
3,862
Hi.

Have a problem with Katie as it says I will take more porn from Amy.
I've checked at the pool via the phone but only get back, just like at the photo studio it's the same under friends.

Have I accidentally got some weird bug or something?

I have a picture of what it says right next to Katie on the computer if that would help View attachment 2343448
Double check you've uploaded Amy's previous shoot.

OK I don't get it.
It doesn't make sense, don't worry. I'm just blaming random things on Icarus :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Havik79

Havik79

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 5, 2019
6,764
8,014
The Red Room is another game, Siri is the main character. We did a crossover event where she visited the photostudio.
Ah I see, is that another one with Futa/trap on male.
Oh I think I found it, futa on female no wonder I didn't know about it.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: PapaPhat

TheLeanGreenBean

New Member
Jan 20, 2023
3
4
I would just like to say, I think you are making a truly beautiful game. You've totally hit the nail on the head with your goal in making a porn game that has an actual plot! Out of all the porn games I've played, I think Lunar's Chosen has become my favorite! Once I discovered it, I binged through it in it's entirety in about 3 evenings. You've really done an outstanding job with your character growth. <3

I do have some thoughts, feedback and suggestions that I hope you'll find useful or intriguing. (Keep in mind I haven't read all almost 300 pages of this forum so please ignore if any of these are repeated ideas or previously addressed things)

- I really had to scratch my head with Imry's character being the 7th main girl. She popped up out of no where, for no reason, and in such a lore driven game she feels extremely out of place. (Comparatively speaking.) I liked her twist with Meg, but I can only hope that she gets development that brings her up to par with the other women in the harem. To me, she even went far enough as to feel like an interloper who stole Missy's rightful spotlight~ (seguing into that) I do hope Missy deserves to get her own spot in the main harem, it's certainly been floating around in dialogue long enough.

-It would be a huge quality of life update if you could revamp the image selection system for the digital poster frames you can upgrade the MC Bedroom with. Having 1 Frame offer different images from Frame 2 causes quite a bit of disappointment. All the images I like are offered on the poster above the bed, while all the images offered by the other one are 'acceptable' at best, and given how often I have to stare at them (and cannot unequip them) it's a constant eyesore.

-Related to the previous point, as a professional photographer, I think it would be really cool if you could offer a rudimentary photoshopping tool. You already have all the studio photos with a completely white background, so if you just offered a choice of like X different backgrounds that can be greenscreened, and allow people to create and save their own combinations into their digital frame posters, that would be SO COOL.

- For any women who use glamours, I sometimes find myself craving one form vs. another. Being able to ask them to put one on or take one off I think would be a really neat addition.

- There was a lovely quantity of small scale side events in this game, but after you experience them the world quickly feels empty in their absence. I think a low-effort solution to this, would be to go through those events, and just alter the dialogue before repeating the event animations. For example, walking through the park and then you run into Fran again. Rather than looping from the beginning where she curses you out, you could have her greet the MC before offering a repeat blowjob of last time. That way, walking through the park doesn't become an empty location like the bookstore. (On this same topic I will just say, if you were able to create like even just 2 other possible dialogues that the game chooses from at random, this would go a LONG way to creating the appearance of dynamic interaction. "Hey, I thought that was you so I decided to jog over" + " I was thinking about you so I decided to go for a run" + "Every time I run through here it makes me feel naughty". ) This way you can reuse the most time consuming elements while dressing up the reuse as an intended repeatable event that avoids the COMPLETELY lazy repeatable events where dev's loop the events as if they never happened in the first place. (I.E. Fran doesn't recognize the MC and curses them out every time)

As a continuation of this, I would also suggest allowing permanent revisits for the city map locations you've visited. Like Claire's yacht, or Amber's mom's house. This would give easy, lore appropriate timesinks. (Assigning a schedule or even a randomized one, where you might find Amy, Claire, or Sam at the yacht.)


Thanks for reading! You've done an amazing job already and I can't wait to see how this game continues to develop!
 

PTGames

Developer of Lunar's Chosen
Donor
Respected User
Game Developer
Sep 17, 2018
2,314
3,862
I would just like to say, I think you are making a truly beautiful game. You've totally hit the nail on the head with your goal in making a porn game that has an actual plot! Out of all the porn games I've played, I think Lunar's Chosen has become my favorite! Once I discovered it, I binged through it in it's entirety in about 3 evenings. You've really done an outstanding job with your character growth. <3

I do have some thoughts, feedback and suggestions that I hope you'll find useful or intriguing. (Keep in mind I haven't read all almost 300 pages of this forum so please ignore if any of these are repeated ideas or previously addressed things)

- I really had to scratch my head with Imry's character being the 7th main girl. She popped up out of no where, for no reason, and in such a lore driven game she feels extremely out of place. (Comparatively speaking.) I liked her twist with Meg, but I can only hope that she gets development that brings her up to par with the other women in the harem. To me, she even went far enough as to feel like an interloper who stole Missy's rightful spotlight~ (seguing into that) I do hope Missy deserves to get her own spot in the main harem, it's certainly been floating around in dialogue long enough.
Imry will get more story and actually weave in with the other characters a little more. In fact, I'm actually rendering a scene right now where a connection is made with another character. She's new, but hopefully will get a lot more content.

-It would be a huge quality of life update if you could revamp the image selection system for the digital poster frames you can upgrade the MC Bedroom with. Having 1 Frame offer different images from Frame 2 causes quite a bit of disappointment. All the images I like are offered on the poster above the bed, while all the images offered by the other one are 'acceptable' at best, and given how often I have to stare at them (and cannot unequip them) it's a constant eyesore.
The images differ because of the size/shape and angle of the two screens is different. So you can't just use the same image on both pictures. Each image was chosen based on which screen it fit best.

-Related to the previous point, as a professional photographer, I think it would be really cool if you could offer a rudimentary photoshopping tool. You already have all the studio photos with a completely white background, so if you just offered a choice of like X different backgrounds that can be greenscreened, and allow people to create and save their own combinations into their digital frame posters, that would be SO COOL.
This would be an incredible amount of work to create for something that's a really small gain unfortunately.

- For any women who use glamours, I sometimes find myself craving one form vs. another. Being able to ask them to put one on or take one off I think would be a really neat addition.
I've considered this in the past, but then it just becomes a case of any character can look like any other character. Which sounds fun, but quickly makes anyone lose any uniqueness of seeing different characters in different situations. Why have 7 main characters when you could just have one that changes how they look constantly?

- There was a lovely quantity of small scale side events in this game, but after you experience them the world quickly feels empty in their absence. I think a low-effort solution to this, would be to go through those events, and just alter the dialogue before repeating the event animations. For example, walking through the park and then you run into Fran again. Rather than looping from the beginning where she curses you out, you could have her greet the MC before offering a repeat blowjob of last time. That way, walking through the park doesn't become an empty location like the bookstore. (On this same topic I will just say, if you were able to create like even just 2 other possible dialogues that the game chooses from at random, this would go a LONG way to creating the appearance of dynamic interaction. "Hey, I thought that was you so I decided to jog over" + " I was thinking about you so I decided to go for a run" + "Every time I run through here it makes me feel naughty". ) This way you can reuse the most time consuming elements while dressing up the reuse as an intended repeatable event that avoids the COMPLETELY lazy repeatable events where dev's loop the events as if they never happened in the first place. (I.E. Fran doesn't recognize the MC and curses them out every time)

As a continuation of this, I would also suggest allowing permanent revisits for the city map locations you've visited. Like Claire's yacht, or Amber's mom's house. This would give easy, lore appropriate timesinks. (Assigning a schedule or even a randomized one, where you might find Amy, Claire, or Sam at the yacht.)

Thanks for reading! You've done an amazing job already and I can't wait to see how this game continues to develop!
These are all things I want to do later. For now, many of the events (such as Fran) don't repeat, because their content is not complete. So there's no point in adding repeatable scenes that would make no sense in later contexts. Once their content is fully fleshed out, more repeatable events will be coming. I'm trying to add a couple of repeatable events each update, but main story content takes precedent.

I am considering a tech and repeatable events update soon, where I only add a small amount of story content and instead focus on them to flesh out the world a bit more.
 
3.90 star(s) 87 Votes