In case you didn't realise, most devs don't visit this site for random opinions.
If it makes you feel better, that choice doesn't matter at all, because nothing come out of it.
It was in fact a very interesting idea and has tons of potential if expanded upon, but end up without any meaningful followups, like most ideas in this game.
In fact, choices in this game don't matter, in that you either have the "right choice" so the game continues, or the "wrong choice" that lead to paths that sooner or later will be abandoned by the dev.