I don't know, man. The fact that all the girls who got fucked so far, even Kayla, got creampied too by almost anyone but the MC doesn't make an ounce of sense or an even remotely convincing argument proving you don't prefer one route to the other, story and content wise speaking. As funny as it may sound, in some renders the MC's dick looks smaller too, even after Yana pointing out how supposedly 'big' his dick is, while Kayla said the fat fisherman's was bigger, so yeah...
Another thing I'd like to know is how the fuck did that fat ass fish faced fisherman get on the boat without it sinking with them and nobody noticing anything.
C'mon man, there's 9 crew members and 6 grown-ass, smart, gorgeous women on board, and nobody saw the literal elephant in the room pretending to be an oversized NTR ninja throwing his dick around nutting in hoes' pussies trying to impregnate them instead of kunai and shurikens ?? Really ??
Seriously now, I understand a petite girl like Yana pulling off a ninja kinda stealth technique to stay hidden there right under their noses, but him too ?? This is very hard, almost too ridiculous to believe, just like it's very hard to believe that Kayla wouldn't know there's another guy other than her BF fucking her twice, more so since hygiene doesn't seem to be something the old fart gives a shit about and she felt his dick being bigger. And let's not forget the biiig 'revelation' about Corin... instant facepalm.
Well, there's one MC against 6 other crew members (excluding the captain, he already got the cuck treatment and
something real disturbing as a 'reward' for what he's done) and 4 other non-crew members (Hank, Jack, the creepy, rapey fisherman and the old fart in this update), which makes it 10 rivals (!!), fighting for the girls' affection and the love between their and a few side girls' legs... don't sound like much of a fair challenge to me, especially since the MC has nobody to back him up, actually trust, or act as a wingman and all the emphasis put on him watching them get fucked, if you pick that option.