Comics Collection Melissa N. Collection [2024-06-23] [Melissa N.]

MyraTSF

Newbie
Dec 22, 2023
83
251
Inspired by a true story?



"He went to bed as a man but woke up as a woman. For 20-year-old Mujahid, life took a drastic turn when he was deceived into undergoing gender reassignment surgery. This was orchestrated by another man in collusion with doctors from a local medical college in Uttar Pradesh's Muzaffarnagar."
That shit is wild. It's just 2 days old news, any more news to it so far?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jackjons

Jackjons

Member
Dec 1, 2023
145
195
That shit is wild. It's just 2 days old news, any more news to it so far?
And I am more surprised I am from India and I never watched this news in any news channels, I will dig into it ... I was proud of my current affairs but I now I feel shame on myself
 

Jackjons

Member
Dec 1, 2023
145
195
I COPIED THE FULL ARTICLE HERE , YOU CAN READ HERE THE FULL STORY

NewsIndia NewsUP Man's Genitals Removed, Sex-Change Surgery Done While He Was Sleeping
UP Man's Genitals Removed, Sex-Change Surgery Done While He Was Sleeping
This was orchestrated by another man in collusion with doctors from a local medical college in Uttar Pradesh's Muzaffarnagar.

India News Edited by Samiran Mishra
Updated: June 20, 2024 12:42 pm IST
This sensational case has sparked outrage and led to protests by the Bharatiya Kisan Union.

Muzaffarnagar: He went to bed as a man but woke up as a woman. For 20-year-old Mujahid, life took a drastic turn when he was deceived into undergoing gender reassignment surgery. This was orchestrated by another man in collusion with doctors from a local medical college in Uttar Pradesh's Muzaffarnagar.
This sensational case has sparked outrage and led to protests by the Bharatiya Kisan Union (BKU).

The incident took place at Begrajpur Medical College in Mansoorpur. Mujahid, 20 and resident of Sanjak village, alleged that he was deceived by Omprakash on June 3. Omprakash allegedly convinced the doctors at the medical college to perform surgery on Mujahid, which involved the removal of his genitals and a forced gender change.

Mujahid claims that Omprakash had been threatening and harassing him for the past two years. Mujahid was falsely told that he had a medical issue requiring hospital inspection. Accompanied by Omprakash, he visited the facility where the hospital staff allegedly administered anaesthesia and performed the sex-change operation.

"He brought me here, and the next morning I had an operation. When I regained consciousness, I was told that I had been changed from a boy to a girl," Mujahid recounted.


Omprakash allegedly told him that he would now have to live with him, adding that no one from his family or community would accept him anymore. Omprakash also threatened to shoot Mujahid's father and seize his share of the family land.

"He said, 'I changed you from a man to a woman and now you have to live with me. I have prepared a lawyer and prepared a court marriage for you. Now I will shoot your father and the land of your share will be named after me and then I will sell it and go to Lucknow'," Mujahid recalled.
In response to the incident, BKU workers, led by farmer leader Shyam Pal, staged a protest at the medical college, demanding immediate action against Omprakash and the involved doctors. The police have assured the demonstrators that a thorough investigation would be conducted.

According to Shyam Pal, this incident points to a larger issue of organ trafficking in the hospital. He claimed that there is a racket operating within the hospital that targets individuals for organ harvesting and gender reassignment without consent.

"It is very unfortunate. We want this illegal business of selling body parts to be stopped immediately. All those involved, including the hospital management and those who facilitated this crime, should be held accountable and punished," Mr Pal demanded.

Mr Pal said that Mujahid's father had filed a police complaint on June 16, which led to Omprakash's arrest. However, Mr Pal criticised the police for their lax attitude and called for stricter action. He also demanded compensation of at least ₹ 2 crore for Mujahid, whose life has been severely affected by this traumatic incident.
All the allegations made by the family and the protestors will be thoroughly investigated, and appropriate legal actions will be taken against those found guilty," Senior Muzaffarnagar police officer Ramashish Yadav said.

Besides arresting Omprakash, the police are also investigating the hospital staff involved in the case.
 

Thalantyr

Member
Dec 1, 2023
273
931
I COPIED THE FULL ARTICLE HERE , YOU CAN READ HERE THE FULL STORY

NewsIndia NewsUP Man's Genitals Removed, Sex-Change Surgery Done While He Was Sleeping
UP Man's Genitals Removed, Sex-Change Surgery Done While He Was Sleeping
This was orchestrated by another man in collusion with doctors from a local medical college in Uttar Pradesh's Muzaffarnagar.

India News Edited by Samiran Mishra
Updated: June 20, 2024 12:42 pm IST
This sensational case has sparked outrage and led to protests by the Bharatiya Kisan Union.

Muzaffarnagar: He went to bed as a man but woke up as a woman. For 20-year-old Mujahid, life took a drastic turn when he was deceived into undergoing gender reassignment surgery. This was orchestrated by another man in collusion with doctors from a local medical college in Uttar Pradesh's Muzaffarnagar.
This sensational case has sparked outrage and led to protests by the Bharatiya Kisan Union (BKU).

The incident took place at Begrajpur Medical College in Mansoorpur. Mujahid, 20 and resident of Sanjak village, alleged that he was deceived by Omprakash on June 3. Omprakash allegedly convinced the doctors at the medical college to perform surgery on Mujahid, which involved the removal of his genitals and a forced gender change.

Mujahid claims that Omprakash had been threatening and harassing him for the past two years. Mujahid was falsely told that he had a medical issue requiring hospital inspection. Accompanied by Omprakash, he visited the facility where the hospital staff allegedly administered anaesthesia and performed the sex-change operation.

"He brought me here, and the next morning I had an operation. When I regained consciousness, I was told that I had been changed from a boy to a girl," Mujahid recounted.


Omprakash allegedly told him that he would now have to live with him, adding that no one from his family or community would accept him anymore. Omprakash also threatened to shoot Mujahid's father and seize his share of the family land.

"He said, 'I changed you from a man to a woman and now you have to live with me. I have prepared a lawyer and prepared a court marriage for you. Now I will shoot your father and the land of your share will be named after me and then I will sell it and go to Lucknow'," Mujahid recalled.
In response to the incident, BKU workers, led by farmer leader Shyam Pal, staged a protest at the medical college, demanding immediate action against Omprakash and the involved doctors. The police have assured the demonstrators that a thorough investigation would be conducted.

According to Shyam Pal, this incident points to a larger issue of organ trafficking in the hospital. He claimed that there is a racket operating within the hospital that targets individuals for organ harvesting and gender reassignment without consent.

"It is very unfortunate. We want this illegal business of selling body parts to be stopped immediately. All those involved, including the hospital management and those who facilitated this crime, should be held accountable and punished," Mr Pal demanded.

Mr Pal said that Mujahid's father had filed a police complaint on June 16, which led to Omprakash's arrest. However, Mr Pal criticised the police for their lax attitude and called for stricter action. He also demanded compensation of at least ₹ 2 crore for Mujahid, whose life has been severely affected by this traumatic incident.
All the allegations made by the family and the protestors will be thoroughly investigated, and appropriate legal actions will be taken against those found guilty," Senior Muzaffarnagar police officer Ramashish Yadav said.

Besides arresting Omprakash, the police are also investigating the hospital staff involved in the case.
Is this publication a credible source as far as you know? Or more like a tabloid?
 

Jackjons

Member
Dec 1, 2023
145
195
Is this publication a credible source as far as you know? Or more like a tabloid?
It is one of the India's leading news channels! You can trust it's sources! They are genuine, and I also research little bit about it , all of the leading news channels cover this incident! They published their articles about it but not showing on tv ! Well it acceptable, they cannot show this on tv !
 

Jackjons

Member
Dec 1, 2023
145
195
Now I understand, why that guy Omprakash easily did srs to mujahid guy ! ....I mean the cost of surgery.
But know I saw this article, the actual cost of srs in india
.
 

Jackjons

Member
Dec 1, 2023
145
195
Maybe Omprakash got his inspiration from Melissa's comics? Or the other way around?

Jackjons is it possible to track down any photos of these individuals?
I tried, but there is not , well, it is not surprised, this kind of things may influence many other cases, transgender case is very sensitive! So , they may doing everything without showing anything!
 

Alicia Mae

Newbie
Dec 13, 2023
32
86
How is this level of racism considered acceptable in the year 2024?
The written dialect makes me uncomfortable as well. I know the cultural change is meant to be contribute intrigue and excitement, but I wish she was easier to understand. Melissa uses different color text to represent voice changes, so that would’ve been enough for me.

“You bu-rough’ me ou’ of de pu-bu” took me awhile to decipher. Humiliation and force feminization porn has an unfortunate tendency to be pretty racist. But when you’re talking about culture changes as well, it’s almost guaranteed. The fetishization of the culture is a highlight for some people. It also doesn’t help that Nabi’s only change in “culture” so far is in voice and appearance.
 

MyraTSF

Newbie
Dec 22, 2023
83
251
Because of the accent? In that case, Mirror would be racist as well.

I honestly would like to know exactly how it's racist instead of saying "it's racist". I feel like my different cultural background (not-american) makes it hard for me to see the racism in it so I'm soft-locked out from this viewpoint.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LadyBoyJay

Oled65cxpua

Newbie
Dec 2, 2023
48
74
Because of the accent? In that case, Mirror would be racist as well.

I honestly would like to know exactly how it's racist instead of saying "it's racist". I feel like my different cultural background (not-american) makes it hard for me to see the racism in it so I'm soft-locked out from this viewpoint.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: varkanon

MyraTSF

Newbie
Dec 22, 2023
83
251
Hmm, how would you rewrite this scene to still keep a korean accent? I'm genuinely curious because with english being my second language the only thing I could write with accent is either eastern european or just some badly structured sentences which would make no sense to anyone in a culture swap story.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: rebirth095

misseva88

Member
Jul 5, 2017
130
368
Hmm, how would you rewrite this scene to still keep a korean accent? I'm genuinely curious because with english being my second language the only thing I could write with accent is either eastern european or just some badly structured sentences which would make no sense to anyone in a culture swap story.
Culture swaps are obvious when the author leans into the stereotype to emphasise the change. The stereotype is deemed racist by some, insensitive by others. The problems derived from this is why I don't care for culture change or race swap stories. But those who do generally don't consider the stereotype to be a negative.
 

Thalantyr

Member
Dec 1, 2023
273
931
Don't take the bait. Oled, aka jehaknaboom, isn't actually concerned about racism. You should see the shit he posts on E-H.
I have no idea why he's pretending to be offended here.

(The subtitle on the cover, which was obviously edited and NOT how it was originally posted by Kannel)
(The top comment. Honestly I don't know where to begin with this one...)
(The original title that Oled used for this comic, which you can see in gray below the current correct title. Other users had to petition to get the title corrected multiple times because Oled kept reverting it back to his preferred title every time he updated it with more pages)

He disowns most of his uploads, so unfortunately you'll just have to take my word for it that #1 and #3 are him too, since I saw those when jehaknaboom's name was still on them. And for those of you who don't know how to access this site and just see the sad panda, (warning: racist and transphobic comments).
 

rebirth095

Member
Jul 25, 2021
187
547
Hmm, how would you rewrite this scene to still keep a korean accent? I'm genuinely curious because with english being my second language the only thing I could write with accent is either eastern european or just some badly structured sentences which would make no sense to anyone in a culture swap story.
Regardless of the intentions of how this discussion got kicked off, I do think there's value in learning about different perspectives and different ways of presenting things. To be constructive, I do want to dissect and discuss this a bit.

1) In general when you're writing accents, tone it the fuck down! It's a pain in the ass to read, and you really risk losing your non-native English speakers (if a person fluent in English has a hard time deciphering the accent, how the hell is a non-English speaker supposed to figure it out?). Now stories can differ than comics. In a story, you can write the text out properly, and then describe in text that there's an accent. In a comic, that doesn't have narration, you can imply the accent by choosing to apply it selectively. For example, rather than writing every single word with an accent, just apply the accent to the most difficult to pronounce words in that language.

I'll note, an accent is different from unfamiliarity with the language. If, for example, you have a Chinese accent but also are showing unfamiliarity with the language, the occasional (well researched) grammar mistake is perfectly acceptable and reasonable. For instance, making the mistake of switching -ing and -ed.

2) If you're gonna write out the accent, then be accurate and consistent about it. I'll note that a personal gripe about the accent shown here is that there's some inconsistencies/inaccuracies. 577 is a good example. So the T in don't is dropped, but the same sound at the end of THAT isn't dropped. Koreans do struggle with the 'th' sound, but rather than coming out as an 'f', it's more of an 's', since 'f' sounds are also something that Koreans can struggle with.

As a counterpoint, I'll note that this story is weird in that there's meant to be a "realistic" reason why our MC has a speech impediment. I'm not sure if the accent is actually supposed to be accurate, or just that there is an accent that the ignorant Americans are just gonna eat up. Not to mention, I don't think we really know if this is gonna effect their ability to speak Korean (or sing for that matter) so this plot point is weird regardless of whether you find the portrayal offensive.

3) Frankly speaking, most transformation erotica is offensive by nature. Most feminization stories are offensive to trans people, feminists find bimbofication stories sexist, and most race change stories are written by people that have minimal knowledge about the cultures they're writing about and are just fetishizing it. Ultimately intent does matter. If you're writing a story where part of the degradation is the character becoming a stereotypical WHATEVER, then just take ownership that "yes, as an author I am writing a cariculture of a group of people". People who take offense to that are likely not your target audience and also aren't understanding that the cariculture is part of the degradation.

On the flip side, if you start writing where the cultural change itself is the degradation... I mean, you're probably a racist let's be frank :ROFLMAO:. Especially if 1) all your work has those same themes, and/or 2) the story treats every other member of that group as also inferior.

Basically, I think a general lesson to remember is that you should be aware of what you're doing. If you write a cultural change and don't do any research on portraying that culture accurately, and are only using depictions you feel like you recall from XYZ show/movie/etc... then it's probably going to be a stereotypical cariculture. If that's all you need, then accept that it's a shallow and potentially offensive to some depiction and move on. But, if you're really trying to show a change and treat it as an authentic change, then do the research. And for the love of god, please don't write the story pointing out basic things as if they're a huge revelation just because they were something new you learned. I nearly died from second hand cringe from all the mistakes and "hey! I'm going to point out this thing I learned when I researched Japan and yet somehow still got the details wrong!" from Cheryl Lynn's Tokyo Bound (mispelled Tokoyo Bound on fictionmania, as a cherry on top :oops:).

You'll never please everyone, but at a minimum, there's ways to do it with integrity.

This story (Kpop) is weird for me because the transformation is rooted so many "realistic" mechanisms. But then kinda contradicts itself (or rather sets itself up for scrutiny that doesn't really hold). For example, right at the start of this part, Nabi is introduced as "barely speaks English". But... the procedure didn't hypnotize Nabi to forget the grammar or have difficulties comprehending English. Really, Nabi just has a speech impediment. And so the story plays up the mispronounciation since that's the only tool this transformation had to sell this "barely speaks English" plot... but she still comprehends it perfectly. So... where's the payoff to this?

To be honest, Mirror did this better where Elena is struggling with English and it's showing how Andrew's lost a bit more of himself. For me personally, I wish that was reflected on more.
 

MyraTSF

Newbie
Dec 22, 2023
83
251
Don't take the bait. Oled, aka jehaknaboom, isn't actually concerned about racism. You should see the shit he posts on E-H.
I have no idea why he's pretending to be offended here.

(The subtitle on the cover, which was obviously edited and NOT how it was originally posted by Kannel)
(The top comment. Honestly I don't know where to begin with this one...)
(The original title that Oled used for this comic, which you can see in gray below the current correct title. Other users had to petition to get the title corrected multiple times because Oled kept reverting it back to his preferred title every time he updated it with more pages)

He disowns most of his uploads, so unfortunately you'll just have to take my word for it that #1 and #3 are him too, since I saw those when jehaknaboom's name was still on them. And for those of you who don't know how to access this site and just see the sad panda, (warning: racist and transphobic comments).
Makes more sense now. Actually disgusting. I've seen some of Jehaknaboms uploads and all of them were pure malice. Especially redoing one of Kannel work, adding racism to it and then say "it was the artist, dont attack me". What pissed me off today was when I saw this the artists is already uploading her work on E-H, but jehakna is doing it now as well BUT!!! (also check out the original artist AnyaArt, shes pretty good and has a cute comic going)
1719271303105.png
 
Last edited: