- Jun 2, 2017
- 2,417
- 7,315
Don't forget for perfect NO Preg
Also Izzy ending requires just be friends with Mel
- Thread starter jande21
- Start date
- Mar 15, 2021
- 119
- 1,023
Damn. I've done everything with everyone so far. So no perfect ending for me then haha.
- Jan 26, 2021
- 2,526
- 3,052
I forgot about Izzy.
And yes the perfect ending has no pregnancy. But I wrote it in at the end once the epilogue was over just to fulfill my romantic mindset. I think I added about 4 or 5 extra things to the perfect ending epilogue to the game
- Jan 26, 2021
- 2,526
- 3,052
Nope. Not.Even.Close.
The thing is with this game, to me, it's all about achieving Melody's goals of becoming a singer/songwriter and touring artist. Since the whole game revolves around Melody, that's who I gave all my attention to.
The other girls are there to throw you off that goal.
- Mar 15, 2021
- 119
- 1,023
I better restart then, I want the perfect ending with Melody. Thanks for the heads up!Nope. Not.Even.Close.
The thing is with this game, to me, it's all about achieving Melody's goals of becoming a singer/songwriter and touring artist. Since the whole game revolves around Melody, that's who I gave all my attention to.
The other girls are there to throw you off that goal.
- Jan 26, 2021
- 2,526
- 3,052
Welcome. Check out the walkthrough if you want in the first post. It's 66 pages long, but incredibly thorough
https://attachments.f95zone.to/2019/12/513335_Melody_-_v1.00_Walkthrough_FINAL.pdf
- Jun 2, 2017
- 2,417
- 7,315
It is a bit subjective the good versus Superstar ending. (Superstar is what some call perfect)
If love and family are what Mel truly, deeply wants the good (pregnant) ending is actually the perfect one.
That's why the other is called the "Superstar" ending by the game devs
PEACE
- Jan 26, 2021
- 2,526
- 3,052
I did the GOOD once in the very very beginning, just felt sad and guilty about it, never did it again. No 19-year-old should be knocked up, having to stay at home with the kid while the husband is out achieving HIS dreams of being back on tour. Anyway, that's me.
- Nov 14, 2017
- 65,214
- 32,879
if you are dating mel and her auntie at same time then at some point that will blow on your face.
- Jul 19, 2021
- 445
- 425
- Mar 15, 2021
- 119
- 1,023
Yeah but I just reached the part when MC and Mel talk about what they are to each other(i think it's the breakfast after the party). Does the game care what and who I do before that?
EDIT: Read the WT and it seems that it does.
Last edited:
- Jan 26, 2021
- 2,526
- 3,052
My first perfect ending run in this game I used the PDF WT and the Walkthrough Mod to make sure I got it. Even got the max points at 405. Gave every single girl the cold shoulder except for Melody. It's such a great game in my opinion and easily in my top 5, at this point, probably top 3.
If you want the perfect ending, don't do anything with anyone else, and don't allow Melody to get involved with Sophia and don't allow Sophia to get involved with Xianne and always keep it in your pants unless it's for Melody.
Last edited:
- Feb 14, 2020
- 291
- 887
Not actually prefer but see it as the best alternative route. After all Melody becomes your Niece. Can't complain about that.Am I the only one who prefers the aunt route?
- Apr 7, 2020
- 2,454
- 4,352
If this cheers you up i prefer any route over Melody's. She's such a spoiled get everything easy brat.Am I the only one who prefers the aunt route?
Amy > Izzy > Rebecca.
I get and respect that the main allure of this game is a combination of romance and corruption of a barely legal teen, but I learned quickly that wasn't my thing.
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,803
- 3,214
To be a little more specific with this answer: you can do things with other NPCs up to a certain point. In other words, you can slut it up at the very beginning, and you can do some stuff with everyone. But every NPC has a "not past this" moment, after which you're hurting your relationship with Melody and ruining your chance for the "superstar" ending. The walkthrough is pretty clear regarding the inflection points in each relationship, and I strongly suggest following it by reading forward and noting where things will go wrong for you. Installing the mod makes this easier.
That said, all the endings have their own virtues. (Well, except the one with your ex.) My gameplay suggestion would be to pursue the route in which the MC has three girls at his disposal, making saves at each point that the MC has to decide whether to stay with or dump the ancillary characters, then go back and pursue all the alternative love interests' endings. And then, when you've done that, go back to your first "breaking point" save and play for the "superstar" ending. You'll have seen all the ancillary content, and will then finish with the most rewarding result.
- Mar 15, 2021
- 119
- 1,023
Thanks for the tips! So there are 6 endings to go for, MFFF/MFF, Superstar, "Love" ending with Mel, Amy, Rebecca, Izzy(?), not counting the bad ending with Beth?
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,803
- 3,214
It's been a while since I've played the game, but that sounds about right. There's an Izzy ending, for sure. It's abrupt, but then all the non-Melody endings are, kinda. Only the Amy ending achieves any actual weight, because it's the only ending that makes real-world sense. But one of the two/three Melody endings are pretty obviously where the game's steering you.
The inflection points for all the ancillary characters are laid out in the walkthrough; basically, never get into a situation where Melody finds out you're having sex with her aunt or that you're shedding points to be with someone else. Personally, I see no reason to deny Xianne access to the gorup sex, and in any case the playthrough and ending on the small harem route are virtually identical whether or not you choose to include her.
If you read back a zillion pages you'll see that many people feel the pregnancy ending is morally dissatisfying. I'm one of them. I think it devalues everything the game built. But, obviously, there are always people who disagree. It's a sweet ending, but I don't find it satisfying, and I also think it's a betrayal of the narrative's purpose.
This is why I suggest that you play all the other endings first, before going back and devoting yourself to Melody. The "superstar" ending is worth the wait. This isn't a deeply complex game — that's not what this particular team does — but it's a vastly more mature game than DMD. And the very obfiously preferred ending reflects that maturity. You're rewarded for acting as an adult, unlike in DMD.