Ren'Py - Completed - Milfy City [v1.0e] [ICSTOR]

The game that most people play right? I always see it mentioned all over the place when people talk about games. But there's a definite reason for that. It's a pretty solid game from top to bottom. I haven't had many issues and the scenes are good and the girls are hot. Fun times

Pretty awesome game. Aunt is sexy as hell, and I like the options to be loyal to your dad's company or not. Looking forward to more updates as it can't get updated fast enough,but that's always the case when a game is done well!

2 starts is the best I can give this game. Was initially planning on giving it a one star because of how shady the dev is but the content the game currently has deserves a bit more love. The story is sub par at best, the only good thing about the game are the renders. Game development is practically abandoned. While there are far better games on this site with more involved devs, this game is undeserving of anything more than 2 stars.

This game has fantastic models (best imo are Linda, Caroline, and the teacher) and animations. Great writing with good pacing, no grind but decent buildup while still keeping each scenario unique and fresh.

I definitely advise using the incest patch, which makes more sense given the living situation presented.

I can't wait for this game to be a complete product; aside from being my first in this genre, it could be the G.O.A.T porn game for me.

To much searching around for events/content and days grinding for my taste. desent renders, lack of story and in general boring sandboxfeeling. Could be better could be worse. the animations are quite good and I love them, but at this point its not worth the "work" to get to them.

I've followed this game closely and played it off and on. It is still my favorite go to game.

I like the story and fetish. The scenes are done really well, definitely up my alley. I've played several versions of the game since development and this continues to be my favorite.

I'll be honest, this is my marker in terms of gauging other games. I just compare any new game I play with this one. I've tried the slaves of rome versions and that's the only other game that is comparable. I may not have played that many either - so take that into consideration.

I hope others will find this game as entertaining and satisfactory.

Overall the game is one of the better one's I've played, but with updates seeming to come out at least 6 months to a year or longer I can only give it a 2 star rating. The models that are used get 4 stars and the storyline only 3.5 star rating. Maybe if the storyline was fleshed out more I would bump it up to a 4 stat rating. I know that no all devs can work on their games full time because of other obligations in real life. I used to really like the game until I noticed that updates are few an far in between without any consistency.

Review of v0.6e...

I wanted to give this game 5 stars, but a few things held it back for me.

Pros:

• The Character Models - This is kind of a double edged sword. I'll explain in the cons.
• The characters are likable for the most part, except for the ones that are supposed to basically be evil like the teacher Celia or Caroline's ex.
• The animations are good.

Cons:

• The Character Models - Most of the women are hot, but some of them have the big balloon tits with big butts.
• The PC is a bit more naive than I would like. There is a part where he discovers his mom reading a book titled "How To Date You Son" and he still acts like he doesn't understand what is going on.
• The majority of the sex in the game so far consists mostly of oral, tit jobs, and foot jobs. So if you tend to get bored with these before too long then you might get bored with the game before too long as well. There are only maybe 2 or 3 sex scenes for probably only 2 or 3 characters so far and it takes a while to get to those points.

I would also recommend playing with Lain's Mod. I found it improved the game overall.

A note to fellow reviewers; Please, for the love of god, keep your reviews focused on the scope of the game and leave out commenting on any imagined "misogyny" you want to pretend is there simply because you don't like what happened with a single character.

This game has been one of my favorites for a while, I would've given it five stars if the story seemed more fleshed out and realistic, it's a little light. The animation is fantastic though, probably some of the best. Overall, despite the lack of a good complex story, I think it's still worth playing, I don't know what the future holds for this game, but what's here so far is stimulating enough. I would definitely recommend it.

EDIT: Dropping it to three stars, because the last few updates seemed rushed, ICSTOR has gotten more and more unreliable with regular updates, and he seems to be rushing this out the door, to make room for a new project I think. I wish he gave more work to this, but alas I fear it’s not to be.

This is the best example of "landlady + 2 roommates" type of games. Everything is greatly designed. Renders are top quality, animated sex scenes are breath-taking, each story of females are fun, even if they're not completed yet. At the end, you just stare at the screen with sad eyes and beg for more. Absolute masterpiece.

I'm gonna be realistic and honest, I'm just gonna rate the game just the videogame, And to be honest is one of the greatest I've ever played. It has beautiful models, cool enviroments, it's easy to play and a nice story that would make you help the main character. So I rate this game with 5 stars, since it's amazing and it's not even complete.

Was a great game I really liked the art and animations. I also really liked the story and having to work toward getting to the main female character. There were a few scenes though that made it a little confusing but altogether it is a great game.

damn this good. I used to play this since back then, and now it's getting increasingly wonderful... good job dev. please finish this really fast. I want to see the ends of this game already. I hope the ending will show those 3 wonderful girls enjoying bed together peacefully

Recently tried this game again after a year, and know what I found? Almost nothing new. In my opinion the only thing of value in this "game" is Caroline. The story, MC, renders, gameplay, and everything else are all average to sub-par at best. This game is NOT the best game on this site, but you see a lot of people out there that pretend it is.

Edit: Oh look, it's been a year since I wrote this review. Has anything been released or done to change my mind? No. Zero progress, zero work, and zero content since this review was written. It's now been a year and a half since he updated it. That "update" took half a year and was 10 minutes of content. Regardless, you still see people pointing to this trash as the best thing on this site. This game is a scam. Amusingly this developer still has over 6000 patrons willing to pay him to produce NOTHING. So, what they say about a sucker being born every second is accurate.

[Review of v0.6e]

Forgive me if I think that Milfy City is just another 3DCG VN about a "community college" kid fucking his "landlady" and "friends who live in his house." It's got a fair bit more content than the rest of the nuclear-family-fucker subgenre, so I'll give it that, but I can't say that any moment or character in Milfy City jumps out at me as being original or memorable in the sea of games exactly like it.

I have no idea what I'm missing here. Does the familiarity of the same setting and characters across every VN lend comfort to the errant pervert? Is there something about the vacant, dead way that a render of a J-cup RealDoll stares at you that sends blood directly to dick? Does the wish-fulfillment fantasy of being Chad McHighschooler really hold that much appeal to the H-game audience? Was Freud right about how everyone wants to fuck their moms?

Whatever the case, I found Milfy City disappointing in its gameplay, its writing, its art style, and all the tedious stuff it made me do before showing me more pictures of tits.

Review on v0.6e
Really conflicted on this one, some good stuff but IMO also a lot of bad stuff.

Pros:
+ Great visuals, including good rendering and good sex animation
+ Heaps of different women to have storylines with
+ Sandbox style where you can choose which storyline to pursue first

Cons:
- The MC looks like an underdeveloped preteen without any sort of muscles or body hair and is like half a head shorter than many women in the story, really offputting to me (plus his weird Justin Bieber hair, yuck, just makes him look like a girl)
- Because of the sandbox style, the storylines of the different women seem just not interconnected enough, for example, the relationship with one sister should at least somewhat inform the relationship with the other, but there's none of that which gives it a really unrealistic vibe, the polyamorous nature of the MC never really being explained or rationalised.
- Personally, just not a huge fan of the inherent ickiness of incest, don't know why apparently so many people like it, but especially so if that sort of dilemma is the only thing that sustains these incestuous relationships; characters seem to discuss nothing else than how problematic their relationship is. If you're gonna do incest, just do it, don't spend the whole game fretting about it.
- Same sort of thing, the whole revenge thing the MC has going on with the teach, yeah, not a huge fan. In these cases, the misogyny of the dev just jumps too clearly out to me. The teacher might be a bit too gleeful in her rejection of the MC, but still, the rejection is simply the most realistic part. For him to go on his frankly disturbing revenge quest (even proposed by his therapist, like what? Has the dev ever actually been to therapy?) is just not warranted and I can't get into it.
- Seems like this game has been in development since forever, not looking like there'll be new updates, so unfortunately many of the storylines are just cut off at a weird moment.
- If you're not using Lain's mod (which I would recommend), look forward to a lot of pointless grinding with memory games. I don't hate grinding, but it really depends on the amount and on the inherent enjoyability of the activity. Wasn't really well done in this case.

Might continue with this game if there were any more updates, mainly because of the good graphics, and the hints that future sexual partners are neither family members nor will the MC pursue them by revenge, but I don't see myself replaying the game otherwise.
It's in any case not better than so many other games like it. Try Man of the House if something like this is your thing. Or literally dozens of other, better ones.

A Great game and I really enjoyed it, good renders, great animations, girls look real good. On the negative side from what I have read it looks like the game will be never finished which is such a shame it really does deserve to be finished and not end up another abandoned project. Despite the later comment its still worth a play so I still recommend it.

I'll be brief since the game is not yet completed. I strongly feel MC is the weakest link of this game. I feel he is bipolar cause his actions and reactions alter so rapidly within seconds. Top of that he has no shame in corrupting his baby sister but gets all flustered and gets into moral dilemmas while it's with his grown ass mother who is more than willing to jump his boner. Apart from this major let down, sex scenes (animations) are top notch and I really like the rendered female models.

One of the best lewd games around. The story is good and the sex scenes have enough anticipation to make them very impactful. It's one of the greats around. It's a shame that many games are copying its art style and its story.

Overrated. One of the most overrated games that I've ever see in my life! And by no means it deserves to be in the Top Trending Games. It is just beyond my comprehension why it gets so much attention.

Is Milfy City bad? No. But it is a mediocre game at best. Why? Because it has almost no originality (you can literally find dozens of other games out there that are exactly the same, but with different names and better art style). The plot and writing are, again, poor and unoriginal, you can clearly see where the game goes even before it starts. Models are fine but the animations are very simple, like the ambients who are also extremely simple . The minigames are dumb and screams laziness (on the first day I got almost 1k in just a few minutes exploiting the rock-paper-scissors minigame). And list of mediocrity goes and on...

Thing is, this game it's not that bad, it's mediocre and you can still fap to it, but there are plenty of games out there who are way better than Milfy City and don't earn the same recognition, and this is for me heartbreaking.