Ren'Py - Completed - Milfy City [v1.0e] [ICSTOR]

so this is my first review on f95, nice feature that i figured id try out. i didn't play through the game that much but i downloaded a mod and i think saw most of the sex scenes. the big sister and the mommy are really hot and juicy. they have a solid feeling to them and don't look too much like dolls. but some of the scenes are unrealistic and awkward and it's impossible to get it on. people just don't do stuff like that irl even when they're being kinky. like the thighs fucking, asscrack fucking, no one above 14 actually cums from doing that stuff lol. need a warm wet hole or 15+ minutes of fapping as a general rule. blowjobs, fingerbangs and pussy licks in very uncomfortable positions and locations, don't try that at home kids itll end in tragedy. still i liked in general. the story is really dumb and there's too much of it. it just drags on with the mommy weighing the option of fucking her son, just do it already we're here for it anyway amirite. and the teacher laughing at a kid proposing to her followed by revenge rape is really stupid and awkward. no way a teacher gets away with doing that in public to a kid, and no way the kid gets away with blackmailing her like that. in conclusion i give it a three out of five.

after 3 years of incompetent. this score is as good as it can be. the game begin very well and much thought planning, with the introduction of every available girls and every main girls in the game. but as story expanded, so is the fans dwelling on. yet after the waiting and all the rumors, it all went sideways for this project to be ever finished.

Content , models , and even the story are all good. Main issue is that the dev takes forever to update. I def understand having writers/creative block but I agree with most people here that he should pause the subscription fee for his supporters if there will be a long delay. If it ever gets finished I may change my rating to 5 stars.

Milfy City deserves a couple stars for the quality of it's graphical renders, but that's about the best I can say for it. I won't get into it's tortured development history, the game thread is about 3k pages worth of it...but now the story which was solid has been chopped at Patreon's behest.

It's sad to see something which was once so promising end up as the equivalent of a slow moving car wreck...but here we are.

My recommendation at this point is to give it a pass, it was perhaps worth 5 stars in 2018, but unlike a fine wine, it hasn't aged well.

This was my first AVN <3 its what got me here in the first place. i really enjoyed the characters and story. gameplay was easy. nice game. def recommend and was a good jumping off point for me. i'm looking forward to going back one day and doing another playthrough. hope yall give this one a chance if you havent already.

It's another sandbox-type torture, time-management-waster, multi location (convoluted free roam to cover lack of content) game with "young man finds himself living with his step-mother's best friend's landlady's neighbour" cliche story. An unplayable, boring grind with the most predictable story ever and grainy models you've seen in many other games. It offers nothing new or fresh in the genre repeating the same sandbox torture setup with repetitive and meaningless grind that's been already reused a million times.

The renders and characters are all good but I just wish there were more gameplay elements.

Its one of those games with very little and linear experience in terms of gameplay and its quite common in h games and other similar games but I just wish it had more in the gameplay department with these types of games.

If you don't care about gameplay and just want to see and experience these scenes then give it a go.

The developer has no intention of updating this game if history is any indication. Game started out really well, with having one of the best animations. Sadly, with no updates since 2+ years and game still not tagged as abandoned has left bad taste.

This was a pretty good game. Unfortunately the developer has bent the knee to Patreon's guidelines so he can make an extra buck by scrubbing the game clean of the content we enjoyed. There's now no reason to continue supporting the devs. It was a good run.

This game is pretty awesome.

+ The dialogues are very good and the characters are believable.
+ The animations and graphics are nice.
+ The story is actually interesting.
+ I haven't encountered any bugs so far.
+ The Incest is pretty on point. almost as good as Dating my Daughter or Dreams of Desire, Almost.

- My only problem is the exaggerated models. that kinda ruins it for me. the ridicules butts and chests and waists! they used the one-piece measurements for women in this game! Gigantic butts and busts and tiny tiny waists! lol

The game used to be decent, even solid, but it never gets updated. The developer only updated the game once in over 2 years, with a rubbish update, just to no longer have the abandoned tag. In reality, this game is abandoned and not worth playing. And definitely not worth supporting the developer.

I kind fo enjoyed this game whe i played it 1000 years ago, but in the end, the payoff was so non existent, that the experienced kind of rewrote itself with a bitter ish taste.
So i didnt even care back then to write a review, it was that forgettable, it even took me time to played it after this later release 7 was published.

I dont know if there is a expression like sell short por the opposite, but if it would happen to exist, in this particular game, this dev is definetly doing it, and i dont understand the praise. I played some other game of his and the memory is quite better overall, but looking at this work, he is far from being a genious.
For starters body proportions are broken to the point where, if it used regular human like poses, for instace lying on bed, you would probably watch the girls hips touching shoulders. A simple to to pose as that is done with the girl suporting her weight on the knees and elbows with the belly clearly floating. Nobody with a healthy back can do that sticking out the butt, but this genius does it that way.
Another pose lying on the side with the weight over the thighs, but hte hip kind of floating, well there are a lot more of this lazy posed renders.

And then we have this MC and his level of poetry is "she looks more beautiful than the stars in the sky tonight" and other corny poetic lines straight from the twilight saga.

And then we have a story that is suposed to be canon incest, but many times someone is telling reason for something not being posible and "its my brother, or mother" or whatever is usually the last thing mentioned. If you wanted her to phrase it like that kind of as a joke or sarcasm, maybe she could say something like "and did i mention that he is my brother?"

I dont know, the game tries, i guess it tries to make eveyrthing it does but keeping the length and words to the minimum required for it to kind of work, but if you actually are paying attention while you are playing it you can quickly feel that its kind of bland and boring.

Also i dont know if the dev notices that the school is empty since the beggining of times, and seeong work in pogress messages make your game look cheap. In the end the overall feeling o the game matches with these things, you kind of feel the same lazyness vibe.

And in this latest update, i gave the phone number to Lily. Later the mc dosnt mention it when he is outside the room, after arguing with Sara. He do mention it during the fight though. Once again, another thing that kind of makes you think that the dev maybe is not really caring, but why would he?
This is definetly not his best work, adn the animations that he sells like the most groudnbreaking shit ever, are actually decent, but thats it, they do the job, but like everything else in this game, it dies halfway.

I this is one of your first ames ever, or maybe you are around 20and you are more honry than me and you like specific characters, maybe you wont see flaws and enjoy what its there. For me it doesnt work at all, with exception of some moments that didnt seem staged and preplanned and preditable.

I've played through this game a few times over a span of a couple of years. What started out as a promising game with great renders and a solid world has turned into a bit of an incoherent mess. The renders are still fantastic and the love interests are super hot, but the second half of this game seems stilted and rushed. The plot kinda just drifts along at this point. There's a ton of content, which is one of the few positives.

Good character development, beautiful models and fast paced gameplay. I like the story and i specially enjoy most of the sex scenes. My favorite character is Sara because she seems appropriate for the age of the protagonist and she looks really young. Although I'm not a fan of Milfs i gotta admit the models used in this game make me desire a milf

Graphics: 3.5 / 5. During his first outing he was one of the best. Now he is just above average.
History: 2/5
Animation: 3/5. Same as for graphics.
Sound: 2/5. Ambient sounds and music are generic
Update: 0/5. Only one update of 400 renders and 40 animations in 2 years.

Conclusion:
(3.5 + 2 + 3 + 2 + 0) / 5 = 2.1 / 5

When it was first released, this game was among the best. Unfortunately, the developer's policy is detrimental to this game. I am very pessimistic about seeing this game end one day.

Updated from original review on August 9, 2021, when the game was in "abandoned" status.

It may be that I would have lower expectations if the game hadn't been around so long. The funny thing is that Milfy City was actually a stellar example of what porn games were capable of, just 4 or 5 years ago, but the genre has moved on and other developers have really raised the bar. Playing Milfy City today just isn't as exciting, but I'm glad ICSTOR completed it and hope that maybe he'll go on to something new (allegedly he has another game well along in development).

I gave this game 4 stars in 2021 shortly after it was abandoned. I never imagined it would be completed. Now that it is and I've played through it, it's probably 3 or 3.5 stars. On the plus side, ICSTOR's visuals remain strong, even if the overall look is rather dated now. The character models are unique--never seen them anywhere else--and the girls are hot. Sara, Caroline, and Linda are among the sexiest porn game characters anywhere. The finished game is very similar to the last version from a few years ago, but there is quite a bit of new content, too. Some of that new content is quite good. The resolution to the story with the lesbian aunt and her wife was super hot, I thought, and the scenes with Judy, the psychologist, and Lily, Sara's "best friend," escalate nicely.

Some content from the original game was removed or changed significantly, as well. I assume this was done primarily to make the game acceptable for sale on Steam. For example, the mother-daughter neighbors are now just the neighbor woman who wants nothing to do with the MC. There's one brief scene with her but it's hardly worth it at all. One tone shift was made by replacing all references to "school" with "college," presumably to eliminate any doubt that the MC and Sara, in particular, might be underage. While understandable, the word change appears to have been done literally by using the find-and-replace feature in Microsoft Word, as the word "college" is used even when it sounds really awkward. Like Linda will ask the MC "Are you going to college today?" which no one would ever ask. Another change that made me laugh is that the MC is no longer really trying to blackmail Celia. Instead, she asks him to pretend to blackmail her and make her feel she's being coerced, etc., because she enjoys it. "And you better be convincing," she tells him. The problem is that the entire rest of the blackmail plot continues to play out exactly as it had in the original. MC was so convincing it caused Celia to forget it was all an elaborate game, apparently.

Despite this, the MC is still a psycho cat burglar rapist who fondles women in their sleep, then thinks lovingly of them when they're awake. That and several other aspects of the story are contradictory and ultimately nonsensical. The plot and many characters are clearly meant as parody.

The gameplay is a bit frustrating and should have been updated. Most other devs making these kinds of sandbox titles have built in time savers, like fast travel, while Milfy City really looks like a game from 5 or 6 years ago. My biggest frustration was trying to accumulate in-game money. The MC can work small jobs, but mostly must earn money by playing endless rounds of rock-paper-scissors or a memory-style card flipping minigame. The most challenging version of the memory game earned $50 each win but I found it usually impossible to win in the time allotted. So I could usually only manage $25 per win. When a late game quest required me to cough up $1000 to proceed, I was extremely aggravated.

And the game is buggy. Just one example: there is a new nighttime booty call feature, but the only character I was ever able to call was Caroline. Sara and Linda remained grayed out.

Bottom line, despite everything, the game still has some really hot characters and delivers some very erotic scenes. There is a ton of content here for people picking it up for the first time. Getting to that content will occasionally be annoying, but most players should find the effort worthwhile.

Great start with lots of different characters (Sara is best), and a rare (in incest games) fun dad. Proper UI, nice graphics, mini games for money grid. The work what is in the game is visible. Story is kinda usual but we didn't come for greek tragedies.
AND that's the past sadly.
Now, constant fall of quality both in writing and graphics. Inconsistent with the previous stories. Interlaced artifacts on video. Creator always lie about updates and release dates. Do not count on proper ending.

High quality renders. Original and imaginative story. Experienced developer, pioneer of this industry. What to say more. Go for it.
Well, all of that is correct, but it has to be added, developer lacks commitment. He can start a story, grow fan base, but somewhere in middle of development, he gets bored. And we get empty promises, sporadic releases... Anyway, this is still a good game with lot of content.

Milfy City [v1.0b] [ICSTOR]

With this version, the game has undoubtedly gotten worse, but it certainly doesn't deserve a star.
During development I had put 5, later lowered to 4 for the "dropped" now I lower it again because you notice that it was picked up quickly and just to give a continuation to the subscribers.

Errors noticed (I don't want to try again the new version released recently, in theory from what is written in the changelog they should have solved the bugs):
- Store music that overlaps with the current one;
- Taking a bath without thinking about anything makes the screen go black (which also happens a few times on other occasions);
- Celia's new route which I was unable to carry out, except for the initial scene, which is horrendous considering that after the initial scene of the new route I was able to do the classic route, creating meaningless dialogues.

The added story unfortunately isn't done well for any character.
The pool girl has the worst scenes in the game (subjective).
Liza has some nice scenes, but the development is too rapid compared to the previous story.
Linda and Bob not appreciated, obviously due to personal taste.
In short, I continue to recommend the game but it was really a disappointment.

Good:

• Unique Interesting characters
• Colorful bright renders
• Fun believable situations

Bad:

• Too much animation ( To me it diminishes the effect of the still renders and most of them aren't memorable and feel uncanny). I think the dev would have probably completed the game by now if he dropped the animations. But seeing as it was one of the game's major selling points , understandably , it would have been hard to make such a decision.

• Some parts of the game feel incomplete or untweaked ( for example the money making system or the ladder climbing mini game which I find extremely annoying.)

Overall I feel like no other game can replicate milfy city's feel. The story is simple but the execution amazing. Because of that I find the characters and situations they find themselves in very memorable.

However I feel like the development of the game stagnated for too long and a lot of the magic is gone as well as the passion from the dev.