DownTheDrain

Well-Known Member
Donor
Aug 25, 2017
1,761
3,959
The most important parts aren't cliche, outside Sara. Yeh, it's mom milf + two daughters (big sister, little sister) that BB and everything else does, but the progression and the character with mom and big sister is just utterly and completely different from the norm. Plus the overall feeling the game gives isn't the normal cliched shit.

And let's face it, like 75% of this shit produced is incest. It's not something that on its own will make you successful.
As far as I can tell there's nothing particularly unique about the setting, it's pretty much business as usual but with higher quality renders and animations than almost everyone else.
That's alright though, I wouldn't try to reinvent the wheel either. Giving people what they want is what got them their reputation and that sweet monthly paycheck.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Hyped

RC-1138 Boss

Message Maven
Apr 26, 2017
13,771
21,033
As far as I can tell there's nothing particularly unique about the setting, it's pretty much business as usual but with higher quality renders and animations than almost everyone else.
That's alright though, I wouldn't try to reinvent the wheel either. Giving people what they want is what got them their reputation and that sweet monthly paycheck.
Pretty much. His renders are the only thing that stand him apart from other ren'py incest game.
 

DownTheDrain

Well-Known Member
Donor
Aug 25, 2017
1,761
3,959
Pretty much. His renders are the only thing that stand him apart from other ren'py incest game.
To be fair, it's not the only thing.
Milfy City is pretty slick overall. Good UI, virtually no grind, tolerable writing, no dead ends, no pointless idling or overly complicated events to trigger.
The game provides a very pleasant experience. It's not inventive, but it doesn't have to be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nulldev

MikyChan

Newbie
Oct 1, 2017
35
9
There's a very small scene where Linda lifts up Sara's panties for you, and a mini-scene with a new goth girl giving a blowjob to the headmaster (I quite like her, hope we see more of her), but other than that, it's 100% mom.
Ty <3
 

AlterSack

Member
Aug 28, 2018
264
413
To be fair, it's not the only thing.
Milfy City is pretty slick overall. Good UI, virtually no grind, tolerable writing, no dead ends, no pointless idling or overly complicated events to trigger.
The game provides a very pleasant experience. It's not inventive, but it doesn't have to be.
while i agree on all your points you have to admitt he did get out of his comfort zone with this game as most of the characters don't act their usuall way. almost all his previous mc's were huge assholes, raping and blackmailing their way throughout his games. i really like the change in this one
 

DownTheDrain

Well-Known Member
Donor
Aug 25, 2017
1,761
3,959
while i agree on all your points you have to admitt he did get out of his comfort zone with this game as most of the characters don't act their usuall way. almost all his previous mc's were huge assholes, raping and blackmailing their way throughout his games. i really like the change in this one
Oh I agree that it's a change from most of his previous titles, though he kind of mellowed out a bit before, probably because people told him how much they hated his MCs.
It's just not particularly inventive for an incest game. All the usual suspects are present, there are no huge upsets or plot twists so far, nothing that really took you by surprise. This discussion started out with how clichéed Milfy City is or isn't, not how much ICSTOR changed and improved over the years.
 
Last edited:

User #19006

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2017
1,185
2,282
while i agree on all your points you have to admitt he did get out of his comfort zone with this game as most of the characters don't act their usuall way. almost all his previous mc's were huge assholes, raping and blackmailing their way throughout his games. i really like the change in this one
yes a good evolution after all guess that made him get some points back , also that hopefully he won´t rush the end !
they acted like the german comic "alter sack und kleines arschloch" ( old sack and little asshole) but agree this one is a good gaming expirece, also i don´t really bother about that the other caracteres were disabled and not int their rooms, (it would be a massive complaining from some players about dead ends other wise )
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlterSack

DD0

Member
Jan 13, 2018
233
284
Many thanks to all you noble souls who came through on fixes for us poor mac users.
On another topic of discussion, I can say that I did NOT come for the incest. That is not what makes this one of my regular downloads, as I find it gross.
It is the quality renders, lack of grind, and decent animation. They are good enough that I ignore the crappy word swaps the dev was forced to use to meet Patreon guidelines. While I hate censorship on principle and feel for the developers victimized by it, I would never have glance or contribute to a game that had non-optional incest as a focus.
The quality of the art is what makes this game.
 

Vaassaa

Member
Feb 17, 2018
240
561
Oh I agree that it's a change from most of his previous titles, though he kind of mellowed out a bit before, probably because people told him how much they hated his MCs.
It's just not particularly inventive for an incest game. All the usual suspects are present, there are no huge upsets or plot twists so far, nothing that really took you by surprise. This discussion started out with how clichéed Milfy City is or isn't, not how much ICSTOR changed and improved over the years.
Well I disagree, because the pretty much ever-present thing of incest games is the mom (or big sister) progress - at first she's just close to you, you perv on her, she pervs on you a little bit and feels disgusted, she pulls back, eventually something happens and she comes to terms with it a little bit, then you push her, etc. etc. and it ends with her admitting her love for you and then pound town. Then the dev cuts the game because he's utterly bored with it.

Milfy city pretty much starts at the end, with Linda, and progresses from there. Caroline is also outside the cliche, a little, because she's not your usual tsundere big sister who you bring around through showing her who's boss.
 
3.70 star(s) 456 Votes