First off, let’s address the obvious: it’s hard to win a war when your most lethal attacks amount to little more than a tickle. The spell preventing lethal combat is, without question, a problem if you aim to claim a decisive victory. It’s not a resolution—it’s a forced armistice, a ceasefire held together by magic rather than mutual understanding. Your analogy to sewing a dieter’s mouth shut is apt, but only in the sense that it prevents immediate harm without addressing deeper issues. That’s why this ceasefire presents an opportunity, not for sunshines and rainbows, as you so flippantly suggest, but for dialogue. If the dialogue fails, the solution is simple: bring down the spell and let the war resume in earnest.
Now, let’s address your larger point. You speak as though I’ve chosen to overlook the dangers and darkness of this world. That’s not the case. I’m under no illusions about the monstrous nature of many of these beings or the centuries of atrocities committed. I don’t avert my eyes, I calculate the risks. The spell doesn’t erase their desires or capacity for harm, and I’d never assume otherwise. But it does provide a unique opportunity to assess those who might submit to human law and those who won’t. To fail to explore that option before resorting to total annihilation is not strength; it’s recklessness.
As for your warnings about the capital and beyond, I’ve heard them loud and clear. Proper caution is warranted, and I’ll take it. But caution doesn’t mean closing the door entirely on coexistence where it’s feasible. And make no mistake: should these monsters prove irredeemable, should their desires outweigh any possibility of coexistence, I will be the first to advocate for breaking the spell and returning to war. Mercy has its limits, but it is not weakness to offer it where it is deserved.
Finally, let’s dispense with this notion that I approach this media with an 'expectation of innocence.' That’s your assumption, not my perspective. Innocence isn’t my concern, peace and humanity’s survival are. If peace can be achieved through dialogue and submission to human law, I’ll take it. If not, then I’ll bring the war to their doorstep with every ounce of strength I possess. It’s as simple as that.
Fair points, It just felt to me like you were ignoring some things, glad that's cleared up though
yhea thats problems for most monster girl games which dose not really have any easy solutions.
like point of 90% of game is that monster girls are better then human woman its just time game at that point
It's a question that's never going to me answered, or maybe it seemply goes with that, human woman are just extinct, or have a marginally lower population. MG porn games aren't going to address these since i guess people don't care, you play a mg game to fuck exotic looking women, who cares about the real ones at that point? World building is definitely the weakest aspect of all porn games, a famous example is the unintentional dystopia of nekopara.
Indeed. Even if monster girls could produce normal, healthy human sons, the long-term consequences remain dire. Over time, human women could face extinction if human males no longer needed them to reproduce. Combine that with the fact that monster girls are often stronger, faster, and in many cases even more capable than human men, and the societal and cultural impact becomes devastating. The power imbalance alone could lead to a world where humanity is subjugated, viewed as pets rather than equals. Such an outcome would be intolerable, an affront to humanity’s sovereignty and survival. This is not just a matter of biology; it’s a battle for our very identity as a species.
I'm fairly sure there already have been games like that. I can't name any since they mostly dissappear from my mind, but alot og MG games tend to be on the femdom leaning side than otherwise, though not that there is no maledom.
This is due to those specific natural advantages they have, often leaving them in the dominant position, making humanity either be subjicated as you said, or just exist in very small tribes where they hide as far away from mg as they can.
I think mgq kinda did this? Illias Kreuz raises concern over their strength and natural violence afaik, and to the average person, mg seem to be a big deal. A literal slime appearing in a village causes quite a stir.
there are couple of solutions that can technically work.
best one i would say is segregation something like what is happening to MGD world. monster girl live in there own separate territory and human migration is very limited and controlled
This is true, but clearly not the intention of high authorities. Adventurers are intentionally being sent to the island with debt, who invented this scheme? I said previously I think it's Venerae, other choices could include pro monster factions in the human world we are yet aware of the MG and DQ herself through infiltration of human high command.
And seriously, it's annoying to just see your reply thread be a list of questions. Why don't you speculate as to the reasons for why things are the way they are in MGD and cook up a theory? That's far more interesting than endless nitpicking.
MGD isn't a game that's theory worthy, not in a "I'm not wasting my time on that" kind of sense, but rather that it just doesn't have enough content to make a theory on.
What makes a good theory would be a ration of 60-80% evidence and support the rest with healthy speculation. A game which is 'theory worthy' would be one that's cryptic, reveals alot yet nothing at the same time, constantly leaves simply crumbs for you to find, leaving you to connect the rest. MGD clearly isn't this in the slightest, even the theoriess you could make (conspiracy behind the adventurer guild, venerae's true intentions, who really casted the barrier, who corrupted perpetua and venefica and what are their goals) leaves you.... you guessed it, just questions. First you quesstion, then you theorize, but there's just not enough evidence to even form a theory, and this is jut the result of amateur writing along with thresh not even wanting to make a game like that.
I mean, to change your shape and sustain that change without going Gojo (keeping your power on 24/7) would require some genetic modifications in itself, albeit not on the level of pouring chocolate milk from your own tits. Actually, it would be similar enough. Even something as "mild" as making one's tits bigger is introducing several pounds of fat and previously non-existent weight. Your body is now being told to account for your chest having expanded and at least a few inches more where blood and muscle must travel to sustain. That's a lot deeper than surface-level stuff.
Honestly, when you examine the introduction of an entirely new race a la Venefica and imply their version of body modification is exclusive while also having the magics for body mods exist already, the writing doesn't stand up to scrutiny, which is what it now needs to do. The witches can just be hyper-competent due to excessive exposure and thusly their comprehension of moderate- to high-level magics is that much more advanced to where they naturally lactate a caramel macchiato on command. You just can't expect that an entirely new branch of magic is discovered by an exclusive group and then in the first exposure to it, have the PC/Reader be met with just an evolved form of an existing ability.
I don't disagree per say, but I find Venefica's enhancements more impressive, Vili's boobs are very magical in nature, they literally tempt you and hypnotize you just by existing. It's not as if Vili is specifically casting that magic to make you focus on her boos, no, her boobs ARE literally made up of hypnosis magic. Not to mention how she can easily change her size absolutely zero pain, think about it, she's adding and removing fat while not affecting the structural integrity. That's why I think Vili's body modification in particular is closer to magical than physical, yes you can touch them, but if Vili was completely drained of mana i think that her tits would go with it (I'm completely aware that this is just a wild guess, but that's how i see it). Though complete mana drain tends to kill people, so what would having smaller tits matter at that point.
This is clearly different from Venefica, she can't change her fur color like it's a color wheel, it's a deeper more sophisticated process to change her nature at her core.
Naturally, other beings could do it too, we have little comparisons to draw as the only high tiers on Venefica's level is Sofia, and even then we haven't seen her do a transformation like that, she can only reveal her wings, change her clothes and get a bunch of sick tattoos. We'd need more transformation content to draw a conclusion, not a personal fan, but seems it's popular
I mean, if you feel that way that's cool or whatever, but I think you kinda failed miserably in trying not to be antagonistic, because I've noticed not only here but in other threads, you tend to put a lot of stock in stuff that REALLY doesn't matter. Discussion is fine, but it feels as if you're trying to tell people that a silly porn game has bad writing and that it means anything at all, when it really doesn't. I don't think anyone's here for a pinnacle of storytelling fr, but that could just be me
That so? Well I did say I'd try.
Though I'm not sure I agree about other threads, the only places I complain or discuss like this are games with relevant stories, much more than mgd mind you.
I didn't see any comment that says that, I think that's just stuff you're assuming. And even if someone DID truly think that this game was some Dante-esque masterpiece of storytelling, who even cares dude? You interact with the girls, or don't interact with the girls, and move on with your life. People be on here writing whole thesis statements on why they don't like a porn game. So much energy wasted on something that, again, does NOT matter.
Holding games to a higher standard almost seems illegal here, I'm not expecting life changing writing here, just something decent.
I said in my previous post that just because this iss a porn game or a simple story doesn't disqualify it from criticism, that won't change for me or anyone critical of the game.
I don't think anyone here said they don't like the game?
Oh yeah, I'll be first then, I used to like the game, not anymore though, the more I think about it the lesser I think of it.
