VN Ren'Py My Bully Is My Lover [Ch.1 Ep.4 - CV] [NiiChan]

[Jaga Telesin]

yes if you kick even one of them out then it will mess up the harem .....like if you choose "Agree with Aine" instead of "Till death do us part" then the harem meeting won't happen cause the goal of the game is to get all of the girls

but i suggest you should play up til the last update or at least finish Ep.3 to see how the story goes first then come back and give your review cause from all the post i see you haven't even finish Ep.3 yet which is where Aine get her character development and fighting with her own struggle

I'm right on the cusp of finishing it now, all of it. I kept Aine in, god knows why - I still don't like her actions, attitude, and lack of trying to make it up to the MC. I had a feeling not including her warped the Harem, so I went with it anyway.

My previous comments and thoughts still stand, even after seeing all of it - I think Aine's path was too far out of step, her attitude too self-serving, and her contributions to the MC far too lacking. I don't care if she was pushed to do it - she still did it. And the MC asked nothing when forgiving her. Her personality shift after talking to her mother was actually so severe that it was creepy to a fault. I don't like the "new Aine" one bit, even after they got together. Of course, they were only engaged for what, a month, and it took a near psychological breakdown before she gave herself to him - someone to whom she owed so much already, and from whom she did nothing but seek her own comfort, all of the time. It's just not believable in my mind, and unfolded in the wrong order.

But not all games can be for everyone. I just wish this one had a bit more truth when holding people accountable for their actions, for recognizing their own desires and being honest about them, and for making amends to those they wronged.

It is what it is... the story moves on. Not sure if I'll be back for Chapter 2.

 

[Penis Lord]

>"But...but...Shu is a dude"

>"My dick says otherwise!"

 

[ArDZer]

>"But...but...Shu is a dude"

>"My dick says otherwise!"
View attachment 5363355

Whoever takes Shu to bed under the impression he's a she, one only has to imagine the screams the poor snowflake's going to make that particular morning after.

 

[Jaga Telesin]

When it comes to initiative, Aine, on the other hand, didn't wait around for someone to fix things for her. She faced her greatest fear—her mother—alone, and fought to repair the relationship with the person that mattered most to her, YOU. That wasn't an easy choice for her. It was an act of growth, courage, and love. She didn't do it because the MC told her to, she did it because she chose to. To me, that says more about her heart and strength than any sex scene ever could. If you're saying that she hasn't done enough, then I honestly don't know what to tell you.

If that isn't enough to earn her respect as someone capable of leading, then the problem isn't with her, maybe it's with how we measure worth.

Aine talked to her mother of her own volition, yes. But that did nothing to actually solve her problems, or her problem with her mother. It was only after the MC spoke to her in bed, giving her the final words she needed, and finally making love to her that she truly changed inside. It wasn't her doing, it wasn't her mother's - it was the MC yet again, transforming those around him. She didn't have it within her to solve any of her problems on her own - just like Gwen. The MC serves as the catalyst for each and every girl in the group to change, to better themselves. As of the meeting, neither Gwen nor Aine had changed, and Gwen still had the best qualities.

At that time, Gwen was better grounded in and of herself. She was confident, self-assured, outgoing, and knew what the harem needed to be stable. Aine knew nothing of those things, hadn't slept with the MC or been physical with him to give him any kind of pleasure as a harem member, and was quite honestly a split-personality that changed on a dime. That's volatile, not the kind of stability the Harem needed.

I'm still going to stand that Gwen was the best choice for Harem leader as of the time of the meeting, all things considered. If you write with your heart - that's great, more power to you. But I absolutely would have given the MC the choice during meeting dialog to shut Aine down (as I mentioned earlier), and allow Gwen the mantle of leader. Just my .02 Now that we've both addressed it, it'll probably stay as-is, but we both have more information to go on in the future.

 

[Jaga Telesin]

>"But...but...Shu is a dude"

>"My dick says otherwise!"
View attachment 5363355

Everything I've seen tells me deep down that Shu is actually a female, acting as a male. Don't know why - call it intuition as a male of many decades now.

 

[ArDZer]

Everything I've seen tells me deep down that Shu is actually a female, acting as a male. Don't know why - call it intuition as a male of many decades now.

Want to blame someone? Blame God. The protagonist said he made Shu with a woman's body but switched things midway and gave him a penis instead. And I'm curious to see how his relationship with Juno will develop, since she's due to make an appearance in the new place where the protagonist and company moved to due to her living nearby (or know more info of Shu's girlfriends that live abroad).

 

[Jaga Telesin]

Want to blame someone? Blame God. The protagonist said he made Shu with a woman's body but switched things midway and gave him a penis instead. And I'm curious to see how his relationship with Juno will develop, since she's due to make an appearance in the new place where the protagonist and company moved to due to her living nearby (or know more info of Shu's girlfriends that live abroad).

Funny thing - every bit of info we know about Shu's girlfriends is just second hand knowledge. S/he could still be a female acting as a male, who likes females. It's all still just so nebulous that it leaves a ton of unanswered questions. And given we haven't seen Shu without a top on, or even without bottoms on... I'm still going to stick with my gut feeling, at least until we see proof otherwise in the game. Only NiiChan knows for absolute certain at this point.

 

[Jaga Telesin]

Yeah, you really still don't get it. Let's just stop here, it'd be a waste of time and energy at this point.
And no, I will not change anything. Let's move along.

Why do I even bother to prove my point in this site?

Just my .02 Now that we've both addressed it, it'll probably stay as-is, but we both have more information to go on in the future.

Clearly my last sentences indicated I was done with the mentioned item. No need to huff mate. And this'll be the last I mention it or why I posted it.

One thing I try to do is provide factual feedback about things in games to help developers see a point of view from the player's perspective. Clearly mine is not aligned with some others', nor yours, but there it is. It wasn't for my edification or satisfaction, but for yours and to give you a window into how someone perceived it. I do the same with my reviews - they are for developer and player benefit, not to hear myself talk.

The #1 thing for me in an AVN (beyond all other factors), is that it stays true to itself, and believable once it sucks me in. If I feel that it strays from that at some point, I note it for later on. As a point - all my feedback on this particular subject (Gwen vs Aine) was in the forum posts, none of it made it into my review, nor did it affect the score in any way.

I still think it's a good game, if a bit protracted and H-scene thin, but the story engages well. And that's what I wanted to comment on here, nothing more. If I simply wanted to rant and put the game (or you) down, I could have done that with far less effort. But that's not fair - feedback with reasoning is always more useful, and that's my goal: constructive feedback. It's why I used the phrase "with all due respect" - I know you have your vision.

If you do end up finding it useful in some way, great. If not, that's fine too. It wasn't done out of malice, but out of interest in the game and it's storyline. Hopefully it served some beneficial purpose along the way.

 

[NiiChan]

Clearly my last sentences indicated I was done with the mentioned item. No need to huff mate. And this'll be the last I mention it or why I posted it.

One thing I try to do is provide factual feedback about things in games to help developers see a point of view from the player's perspective. Clearly mine is not aligned with some others', nor yours, but there it is. It wasn't for my edification or satisfaction, but for yours and to give you a window into how someone perceived it. I do the same with my reviews - they are for developer and player benefit, not to hear myself talk.

The #1 thing for me in an AVN (beyond all other factors), is that it stays true to itself, and believable once it sucks me in. If I feel that it strays from that at some point, I note it for later on. As a point - all my feedback on this particular subject (Gwen vs Aine) was in the forum posts, none of it made it into my review, nor did it affect the score in any way.

I still think it's a good game, if a bit protracted and H-scene thin, but the story engages well. And that's what I wanted to comment on here, nothing more. If I simply wanted to rant and put the game (or you) down, I could have done that with far less effort. But that's not fair - feedback with reasoning is always more useful, and that's my goal: constructive feedback. It's why I used the phrase "with all due respect" - I know you have your vision.

If you do end up finding it useful in some way, great. If not, that's fine too. It wasn't done out of malice, but out of interest in the game and it's storyline. Hopefully it served some beneficial purpose along the way.

Yeah, I'd rathet not say things here from here on out.

 

[Whiskaz]

As the first timer, which one I need to download first? The 2,4gb one or the 1,6 gb one? I'm kinda low on storage so I can't take all 4gb (8gb after unpacking) all at once. Is there any different between these two version?

 

[Reniere]

As the first timer, which one I need to download first? The 2,4gb one or the 1,6 gb one? I'm kinda low on storage so I can't take all 4gb (8gb after unpacking) all at once. Is there any different between these two version?

Look for compressed

 

[Meiri]

As the first timer, which one I need to download first? The 2,4gb one or the 1,6 gb one? I'm kinda low on storage so I can't take all 4gb (8gb after unpacking) all at once. Is there any different between these two version?

Well if sizing is a problem search for the compressed version, otherwise just download the normal version.

 

[Toubib]

Hey guys. Which version should I play? Does the incest content make sense here or does it feel forced? Same question but regarding the ipatch also

 

[Supreme Breeder]

Yeah, I'd rathet not say things here from here on out.

I mean it's your game at the end of the day. I am sure you have a story planned out and so far it has always delivered. No need to justify or defend your work just because a few guys have issues with it. Those who are enjoying it will continue to do so in future and those who don't will continue to rant and leave. Looking forward to the next chapter

 

[Meiri]

Hey guys. Which version should I play? Does the incest content make sense here or does it feel forced? Same question but regarding the ipatch also

If incest is that important to you, play the original, otherwise go with the new version. Keep in mind that future content will be made with non-incest in mind. If decide to go with the original you will always have to wait for someone to make an incest patch and rewrite the story or make the mental exercise that they are now not family when future content releases.

 

[NiiChan]

I'm patching back the original script. But let's please keep it down here.

However, I'm still writing the future content without the I-word in mind.

 

[NiiChan]

I mean it's your game at the end of the day. I am sure you have a story planned out and so far it has always delivered. No need to justify or defend your work just because a few guys have issues with it. Those who are enjoying it will continue to do so in future and those who don't will continue to rant and leave. Looking forward to the next chapter

Love the Pfp, btw. Which game is it from?

 

[Krytax123]

Love the Pfp, btw. Which game is it from?

Hey man, its not allowed to talk about other avns in this thread, thats disrespectful towards the dev

 

[NiiChan]

Hey man, its not allowed to talk about other avns in this thread, thats disrespectful towards the dev

Fuck the dev. Who's the dev of this game anyway?

 

[VaderExMachina]

Love the Pfp, btw. Which game is it from?

it's a fan-art of Amelia, the mother of Jill from BaDIK.