Thank you for the suggestion. It looks like something to keep an eye on but I don't really see this game going very far. It hasn't been update in well over a year, and after watching the gameplay it looks like it's more of a simulation than an actual game. There's no story or gameplay, you just walk around and look at animations. The models look good and the animations are fluid but that's about all that's there right now.
Last update from creator is very recent (on last page). He/She claims a new version in the works and will be out for the public in two months.
About Sins of her Father's male MC, it's more of a "choose your gender" than a true male x female route, and the dev said the amount of futa content would remain the same and they would simply redo the scenes to fit the alternative male MC route.
Sure.
I couldn't have said it better myself.
I was under the impression that Summoner's Legacy was going to be left alone, but if that is true I'll put that game in Silver as well.
This might be a dumb idea, but maybe gold tier should be for games that can be futa focused, that is, including games that are focused on futa scenes if the player picks a futa protagonist. I mean, those games fit the gold tier condition if the player wants them to. And most people bothering to read the list probably would make that choice after all.
Sure, I was just under the impression he misunderstood what the dev wanted to do. I have no pretention of changing the way this thread works, he's already doing all of the work of maintaining it.
I understand where you're coming from but I can't take into account player agency. A lot of games allow players to pick and choose which sex scenes they want to see. For example, if I wanted to, I could play Seeds of Chaos and avoid all scenes that aren't futa in a playthrough. Even though there are only a few futa scenes, I would therefore have to put the game in gold tier because 100% of the scenes I saw were Futa. However, in proportion to the rest of the game, there is barely any futa. If developers want to make a game where the majority of its sex scenes are futa then the game deserves to be Gold tier, if not then they don't. That being said, the tier system doesn't account for quality. There some games in bronze tier that are better than games in the gold tier. But they didn't create their games with the intention of it being futa focused.
It's all good. In my post there was no implication whatsoever that you wanted to take over the thread; I simply tried to clarify OP's metric to you, because given your post it was obvious that it was you who misinterpreted their categorization and not the other way around.
Right on. Their statement of "but maybe gold tier should be for games that can be futa focused" is way too open-ended and subjective. Like what are the criteria? How much individual scenes and story focus is needed to fit that criteria? It is a whole can of worms in terms of how to weigh all those variables, and I think you made a good case with your examples.
Off the top of my head, Inner Growth is futa protag and the story starts with with a pregnant girl that you can have sex with.
