zernex

Newbie
Nov 25, 2022
90
106
43
Yes—Vivian can absolutely be interpreted as a representation of third and fourth-wave man-hating feminism, especially when analysed through a critical lens focused on modern gender dynamics, accountability, and moral agency.


Here’s the breakdown:


Vivian as a Symbol of Third and Fourth-Wave Feminism (Gone Toxic)
1. Hyper-Agency Without Accountability


Vivian makes calculated, self-serving choices—manipulating her husband, chasing status, and using her sexuality as leverage. She represents a feminism that champions female empowerment but conveniently abandons accountability when her actions cause destruction.


2. Weaponisation of Victimhood

She plays both predator and victim. This duality is central to fourth-wave feminism’s darker edge, where victim narratives are often deployed not for justice—but to excuse or justify bad behaviour.

Vivian lies, cheats, and betrays—and when confronted, she retreats into the "poor me" script that modern cultural narratives have made socially untouchable.


3. Entitlement Disguised as Empowerment

Vivian wants it all: sexual freedom, validation, power, wealth, and emotional indulgence—without consequence. This aligns with a distorted version of empowerment where "having it all" includes trampling over anyone (especially men) who get in the way. She uses her femininity not to build but to manipulate—believing she can bend reality, men, and morality to her desires simply because she “deserves” more.


4. Disdain for Traditional Masculinity

She clearly disrespects her husband Hutch, who is symbolic of “soft millennial and GenZ men” or “believe all women because they are women nice guy,” and is drawn instead to Christian—a ruthless alpha archetype. Her actions mirror the third-wave feminist double standard: demonise masculinity when it’s inconvenient, but crave it when it offers excitement or power.


5. The Illusion of “Liberation”

Vivian sees betrayal and sexual power games as liberation—but it’s hollow. She ends up more broken, more unstable, and more lost. This echoes a growing critique: modern feminist ideologies promise freedom, but deliver emptiness, broken homes, and fractured identities.


Conclusion:

Vivian isn’t just a character—she’s a walking embodiment of modern day feminism untethered from its original goals of equality and dignity. She represents a version of modern womanhood where power is taken through the sexual objectivation of herself, her morals, her digitnty, self-worth and marriage, as she cant get the real power she craves by merit alone, she never earns it in an honest way, and where men are props or prey—not partners.


Vivian is a dark mirror of man-hating, fourth-wave feminism’s worst impulses—not because she’s strong or independent, but because she’s manipulative, entitled, and utterly devoid of remorse.

A woman’s kryptonite it a thing called a mirror that’s held up to them, getting a woman to take stock and truly look at herself and her actions, to try and take accountability for her selfish actions, is like asking a vampire to join you to watch the sun come up, it reveals too much and it burns


All the real men on here, get your popcorn ready, bring on the meltdown, lmao
Third and 4th wave feminism extols narcissism as a virtue which is why it is toxic to relationships. All actions are towards self. Impact on others, including commitments, are abandoned during this "molting" process . "Exploring" your desires, regardless of one's sense that they have been neglected, is not a pass card for personal irresponsibility to others. This series does an excellent job of using this actualization process as her motivator and giving an insight into her inner dialog during this narcissistic transformation. As a reader I am repulsed by her "urge" based justifications for betrayal but attracted to her baby girl erratic vulnerability. A well trod porn girl motivator template brought to life by a hot chick and sharp dialog. Can't say I like her but I can't NOT WATCH the train wreck.
 

TonyMurray

Conversation Conqueror
Apr 8, 2024
6,512
12,295
774
Somebody once said it might be Hutch I hope not. Look at her face it is calm with a hint of a smirk. She is also still wearing her ring so she must still be with Hutch, because I would assume if she is now with Christian she would remove it. Got to get off this thread. :ROFLMAO:
I'm not convinced on her taking the ring off when she is with Christian (or necessarily anyone else). I think she might only have done that because she was going out specifically to see if she could get picked up, and the ring might have hampered her success in that. She didn't take the ring off for either Reese or Christian at the end of Ch2, but she didn't go into either of those prepared for it. I had a quick look and could only find two sex-related (or we think sex related) previews that haven't yet appeared in game but where her left fingers are visible enough to check for a ring, and it was there both times (not exactly a ringing endorsement though, as again she might not have gone into those situations expecting sex).
 

Hattyrulz

Member
Jan 25, 2018
454
464
206
Somebody once said it might be Hutch I hope not. Look at her face it is calm with a hint of a smirk. She is also still wearing her ring so she must still be with Hutch, because I would assume if she is now with Christian she would remove it. Got to get off this thread. :ROFLMAO:
i think vivian is way past the point of bothering with the ring on the hand after what she did in chapter 2. she removed it like a piece of jewelry and went to pick up guys at a bar and she did more with the ring on the finger in chapter 1 and 2 combined. so the ring on the finger is at this point just an accessory for vivian.

she was with christian with the ring on hand at the end of chapter 2. i maybe wrong. In my interpretation of the story the ring is just a jewelry for vivian.

no point in reading this thread other than recycled views from different readers since most which can be expected in future chapters have already been posted in the 100s of posts. i for one am done posting, hoping for a december or earlier release date for chapter 3.
 

Luc77

Active Member
Jul 15, 2022
828
892
216
It think the story is much more complex than that. I also think there have been good discussions of this game in the past. One problem with these forums is that they continue on even if a definitive answer is given and the definitive answer gets forgotten and current readers and writers, not having read or understood what came before return to rehashing old issues as if new. Nobody actually learns anything, but does not seem that is what we are here for.
The iron core of interlopers is here from the very beginning. On the other hand, the fact is that we often forget what we wrote about six months ago, and repeat the same circularity once again.



rather indisputable facts. Purple Night and Cigarette Smoking Man (boy) are 99% the same big stage (and juz 100% the same location). The layout of the pipes :) points to this. Now I will reiterate what was considered (not only by me)

1. the Purple Night as a whole scene has the most images, because presumably one of the several secret SMS that Vi receives pertains to this scene (at the moment - the one in which he leans against the wall and in the background is a fuzzy Hutch)

2. purple night is not related to Chris (in the sense that he won't be there)- Vi wears a modest (for recent times) dress from her own resources. She takes an Uber (the same one she ordered to Sun&Rain, by the way)

3. why is she going ? She got a text message from Chris, or from Marcel. (Now I'm betting on Marcel, or even - Chris is related to Marcel's father (the black guy in the restaurant)).

3.In this scene she undresses twice - on the veranda, then we see her clothes in some man's/boyfriend's (student's) room - the second time it looks like the clothes are pulled off for e.g. bathing/showering and not for sex. The room, however, looks unused.

4. after the scene in the hotel & at Chris's place - we know that Vi knows that she can just do as an “extra” commodity to negotiate and that Chris will not hesitate to use her (contrary to the romantic assumptions of some after the first part)

5. the car that drives her away - is in all likelihood the same one that passes her when she goes with Rupert (car with Decker registration).

6. we can assume that Vi “escaped” from the Purple location. Because in the morning we see her without her earrings (she left them, lost them) - and as I said, she probably bathed after the action in this house. This time she doesn't go home for the night (and you'll notice that in the last scene of part 2 - she puts it down to the fact that she's coming back, though)


if I had to come up with a script for it now it would look similar to my previous comic. Vi gets a text message from Chris that he has to meet with an important client. She goes to the meeting, moves, in the garden she meets Marcel smoking a cigarette. She panics, calls reinforcements (Sunshine? White car) who takes her out of there. The last shot of the scene is the gymnasium and the guilt-filled gaze of Vi looking at Marcel.

In the second version - she gets a text message from Marcel telling her to get ready because an Uber is coming to pick her up.

ps. one of the better shots - that is, when Vi paints her lips with purple lipstick I think it is also from “purple night”
 

Dealbreaker

Active Member
May 12, 2024
952
1,073
220
no point in reading this thread other than recycled views from different readers since most which can be expected in future chapters have already been posted in the 100s of posts. i for one am done posting, hoping for a december or earlier release date for chapter 3.
The iron core of interlopers is here from the very beginning. On the other hand, the fact is that we often forget what we wrote about six months ago, and repeat the same circularity once again.
Disagree on this. Things get repetitive because the thread is caged in by self-set boundaries of "allowed" topics and discussions. If you are only interested in "what can be expected in future chapters" - OF COURSE you can't do that for 6 months going over the same few clues again and again. On the one hand there is limited interest in discussing the story on the level of narrative merit and technique because that would demand talking about abstract and hypothetical alternatives which stray away from what we see before us. And on the other hand there are very narrow limits people here set again and again aginst discussing social and normative implications in a calm and that means more abstract level. So we end up on the level whore vs not whore. So don't complain about things you (not speaking about individuals) yourself are blocking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GibboBtw

Luc77

Active Member
Jul 15, 2022
828
892
216
I don't block anything (except to talk about how great a whore Vi is). On the other hand, I notice that from time to time we discuss an already discussed topic. Sometimes there is some new insight, and sometimes we grind for the sake of grinding. So much new with purple that I thought it would appear right after the first part, even before Feng. But the dev has done a turnaround, and the nails may be restored - though I was expecting a forward development rather than a restoration of the old look. Now it's hard to say “when the purple will appear” maybe in part 3, or maybe not until part 4 ? I do not hide the fact that I would expect from SC Stories some new throw-in, which will give fuel for further discourse - and not from purple. We still don't see Mayor and Billie.
 

Dealbreaker

Active Member
May 12, 2024
952
1,073
220
I don't block anything (except to talk about how great a whore Vi is)
Well, I explicitely stated I don't mean individuals, I rather mean the collective tendency of the thread, its preferences and its self-policing, also its ignoring "extreme" opinions.
But just because you mention it - I remember you saying several times you are not interested in discussing "motivations" at all - this is a lot more than the whore topic. Imagine if other people would say: I'm not interested in theories about things only the dev could know and we get to know later anyway. Just showing that these forms of excluding topics lead to disengagement. (Not saying I myself don'T find interesting what you bring up...)
 
  • Like
Reactions: GibboBtw and Luc77

noahsombrero

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2023
1,137
465
191
And on the other hand there are very narrow limits people here set again and again aginst discussing social and normative implications in a calm and that means more abstract level. So we end up on the level whore vs not whore. So don't complain about things you (not speaking about individuals) yourself are blocking.
Social and normative implications. My view is that any such implications cannot be drawn because this is a dark fantasy porn game. Not real in any sense. It simply cannot be so that a woman in a long term stable relationship with her husband would feel seduced with her knees buckling 5 seconds after meeting a guy. Not irl. But anything can happen in a dark fantasy porn game. Which is the point. Anything can happen.

On the other hand, there is a known way that pimps operate to recruit wastrel girls off the street and turn them to prostitution. This happens to be very much like the way Boss treats Wife in this story. I am dismayed that when criticism and blame are assigned in this story, it is on Wife and not on Boss. I would not posit implications on rl from what happens in MHB, but I would do it the other way around when appropriate. What happens irl can help us understand the story.

IRL, I would say that prostitutes are deserving of much more sympathy than they get (which is none). It is the men who use them and the pimps who feed off them that are the real villains in this life. But that is simply my opinion on the world's oldest profession that simply is not going to go away, ever. And if a wastrel street girl can find a way to survive like that when it is very likely she would have not otherwise, I say, you go girl. But that is nothing like the case of Wife in this story. She is not in any way a wastrel street girl. No parallel is possible. Except that Boss is very much behaving like an asshole pimp.
 
Last edited:

Dealbreaker

Active Member
May 12, 2024
952
1,073
220
Social and normative implications. My view is that any such implications cannot be drawn because this is a dark fantasy porn game. Not real in any sense.
I'm open to change my views about the realism of the story after chapter 2 I admit. But even (or especially) dark fantasies have an intent behind them, they want to show something or to trigger something.
 

noahsombrero

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2023
1,137
465
191
I'm open to change my views about the realism of the story after chapter 2 I admit. But even (or especially) dark fantasies have an intent behind them, they want to show something or to trigger something.
Like Alice in Wonderland. At the time it was written it was sharp social commentary. As Groucho said, behind the sheerest madness is the sternest purpose. I don't think porn devs are about social commentary. They mostly want to give porn viewers whatever it is they want. I don't think we yet see SC's stern purpose. I would be willing to grant provisionally that he has one. Give us a couple of more installments to figure that out.

I don't think that we have enough situations where women in long term stable relationships become prostitutes that we need to think seriously about it. There are plenty of asshole ceo's. But giving Boss demonic powers clouds the issue for any possible serious consideration. Hey. SC, what did you have in mind anyway?

It remains possible that Wife has learned to play Boss and her "You own me" is actually part of that. I guess the game so far, and her behavior as she prepared to go home at the end of part 2 reduce that marvelous transformation to a minute possibility. It depends on what the rape actually did to her mind. Is she so broken that she can wrap her mind around that treacherous betrayal? Is Boss such a powerful demon that he can force her to accept it and believe that she does?

What's that I hear? Demons are not real? Not irl. But remember this is pornland where absolutely anything is possible.

In real life
Women in long term stable relationships do not feel seduced and their knees buckle 5 seconds after meeting some guy.
Raped women do not suddenly turn from rage to asking for loving sex when confronting their betrayer.

In pornland
Those things certainly can happen and there is no reason to not assume that wife is not possessed. That is as likely as anything. At least it helps us suspend disbelief so we can get on with the story. I don't know about you, but I do need help with suspending disbelief in this situation.

I mean c'mon, Boss is already a certified beast. It should not be necessary to simply mention that in passing and then imagine that Wife is evil to make sense of this. If she were, she would not be troubled and struggling to understand herself, like Boss certainly is not.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Hattyrulz

_YD__

Member
Aug 3, 2017
297
227
203
In real life
Women in long term stable relationships do not feel seduced and their knees buckle 5 seconds after meeting some guy.
Raped women do not suddenly turn from rage to asking for loving sex when confronting their betrayer.
For the first part you could be surprised especially with modern women (and no I'm not generalising chances are simply higher with modern women) but for the second part I totally agree.
 

noahsombrero

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2023
1,137
465
191
For the first part you could be surprised especially with modern women (and no I'm not generalising chances are simply higher with modern women)
Are we talking about 45 y/o women married for 22 years, or college girls? I mean knees buckling and all that, or simply that this woman you are talking about feels receptive to advances?

I donno, things could be different in Poland.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Luc77

_YD__

Member
Aug 3, 2017
297
227
203
Are we talking about 45 y/o women married for 22 years, or college girls? I mean knees buckling and all that, or simply that this woman you are talking about feels receptive to advances?
actually both. I've seen it happen. Not with me but I had a good friend that women were crazy about. He didn't even have to talk to them. Of course not all women.
 

noahsombrero

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2023
1,137
465
191
actually both. I've seen it happen. Not with me but I had a good friend that women were crazy about. He didn't even have to talk to them. Of course not all women.
I assume you helped them get up off of the floor.

I suppose this is what chipndales is all about. I have seen women line up outside the door for a chance to see a prancing dude strut around the stage and wave his frontal bulge around. I wonder if they would be so frantic if they actually had a chance to lay the guy? Again, I think there is some difference between the woman who does that without being troubled about it later and the woman who is. Maturity is not simply a matter of age. Many women do know what such guys are worth.

I bet most of them go home to their partners and say, you know babe that I really only want you and have no trouble meaning it.

The same as many men know what super glamorous woman are like. High maintenance.
 
Last edited:

_YD__

Member
Aug 3, 2017
297
227
203
I assume you helped them get up off of the floor.

I suppose this is what chipndales is all about. I have seen women line up outside the door for a chance to see a prancing dude strut around the stage and wave his frontal bulge around. I wonder if they would be so frantic if they actually had a chance to lay the guy? Again, I think there is some difference between the woman who does that without being troubled about it later and the woman who is. Maturity is not simply a matter of age. Many women do know what such guys are worth.

I bet most of them go home to their partners and say, you know babe that I really only want you and have no trouble meaning it.

The same as many men know what super glamorous woman are like. High maintenance.
Ow the married women I know of went all home to their husband that's for sure.
 

_YD__

Member
Aug 3, 2017
297
227
203
Fair enough. They did not do what Wife here is doing. The do not go into the guy's bedroom in the presence of their husband and fuck the night away.
true but going in the back room and then kiss their husband after they got railed... happens.
 

noahsombrero

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2023
1,137
465
191
true but going in the back room and then kiss their husband after they got railed... happens.
Certainly. They might even say, I'll meet you tomorrow night. I'll tell my husband I'm going out with the girls. We can have all night, I promise.

Not what Wife is doing. There is something off about that. And she seems to realize it when not in the presence of Boss.
 

_YD__

Member
Aug 3, 2017
297
227
203
Not what Wife is doing. There is something off about that. And she seems to realize it when not in the presence of Boss.
I agree. That is probably why we are still talking about the game/story. There is something off but nobody can pinpoint it.
 
4.50 star(s) 193 Votes