VN Ren'Py Nephilim [v0.4.5] [BuuPlays]

[BuuPlays]

That's not a very good argument, Buu. First, because you should expect your players to bring their 2024 morals to the story. We're playing it 2024, right? If you want us to apply a different lens to the events in game, it's up to you to establish that perspective within the game itself, not in a rant on a third-party forum. We've had plenty of time to show that polygamy and affairs are commonplace or that women recognize their lot as second class, but I can't recall any instances of that.

If anything, the impressions we get are the opposite. Kelly's mom was eager to defy her husband so that Kelly could live her own life. King Bennen has only a single (female) heir and (AFAWK) never took additional concubines/wives to supplement that, nor does he consider taking a second wife as an alternate means of securing the kingdom. Queen Merida pontificates at great length how disappointed she was when her 'fairy tale' marriage turns out to be less than romantic, which strongly implies love and devotion are the ideals people espouse publicly - even if reality falls short of the ideal.

Second, on every other subject, the behavior of almost every character in the game is thoroughly modern. Women may join - and even lead - guilds without issue. The King is eager to dispense with formalities when meeting with the MC. No one bats an eye when the Queen entertains a male stranger in her bedchamber. That isn't how medieval society worked, either. Combine these discrepancies with literal magic and non-human races and I frankly see no reason why we would guess society in Nephilim isn't just as egalitarian as our own, to say nothing of it being dramatically less so.

Basically, if you want the MC to play the field without coming of as a cad, you need to do a better job establishing the norm.

I wholeheartedly disagree. I guess we'll have to leave it at that.

 

[Meehaha]

I wholeheartedly disagree. I guess we'll have to leave it at that.
[/QUOTE Someone seems to have not noticed this is not a medieval game, but a fantasy game. Don't really seem to remember anything about Nephilim's, Fairy's or people openly using magic in my reading of history. Liking what you are doing and guess fantasy morals apply which are decided by you as the developer. If it was truly medieval half the cast would be burnt at the stake.

 

[Wolfeszorn]

That's not a very good argument, Buu. First, because you should expect your players to bring their 2024 morals to the story. We're playing it 2024, right? If you want us to apply a different lens to the events in game, it's up to you to establish that perspective within the game itself, not in a rant on a third-party forum. We've had plenty of time to show that polygamy and affairs are commonplace or that women recognize their lot as second class, but I can't recall any instances of that.

If anything, the impressions we get are the opposite. Kelly's mom was eager to defy her husband so that Kelly could live her own life. King Bennen has only a single (female) heir and (AFAWK) never took additional concubines/wives to supplement that, nor does he consider taking a second wife as an alternate means of securing the kingdom. Queen Merida pontificates at great length how disappointed she was when her 'fairy tale' marriage turns out to be less than romantic, which strongly implies love and devotion are the ideals people espouse publicly - even if reality falls short of the ideal.

Second, on every other subject, the behavior of almost every character in the game is thoroughly modern. Women may join - and even lead - guilds without issue. The King is eager to dispense with formalities when meeting with the MC. No one bats an eye when the Queen entertains a male stranger in her bedchamber. That isn't how medieval society worked, either. Combine these discrepancies with literal magic and non-human races and I frankly see no reason why we would guess society in Nephilim isn't just as egalitarian as our own, to say nothing of it being dramatically less so.

Basically, if you want the MC to play the field without coming of as a cad, you need to do a better job establishing the norm.

Based take. And i agree with all of it. On top of that, directly after you pick the Harem option during the talk with Borri, you lose a trust point with him and he explicitly tells you that "Entertaining multiple women never ends well" and to "follow your heart to find the one for you cuz that´s the most pure and intense emotion you´ll ever feel ".

That doesn´t sound like polygamy is the norm in this universe, but whatever The dev "wholeheartedly disagrees" without a counter argument so all the points you brought up have to be wrong

Whatever.... still like the game even with those logic errors

 

[Dessolos]

This is how I see the whole harem thing or whatever is im somewhere in the middle where I agree both with Buu and the people that have an issue with it. As I do think it should of been showcased alot earlier in the story as Eliza's dialogue / her thougths does feel like it kind of go against the whole it's normal for men to have more than one partner in their society. As well as it does feel a bit weird for the MC to sleep around with how in love he is with Eliza and some of the things he says to her. As well what Borri tells the MC if you pick the harem option.

The thing is those are her thoughts but she doesn't know the MC is sleeping around. Which is why I think Buu is planning and having Alice and Eliza have some kind of conversation. To show how she is fine with it and isn't a big deal and doesn't mind sharing despite that was her thoughts with Selena. I think why Eliza never showed any concern with Alice even tho she should of worried about Alice more than Selena if this was a modern society . Simply because Alice was a childhood friend and always acted kind and innocent and not coming onto the MC while clearly Alice is in love with him which I assume Eliza could tell. While Selena came onto the MC strong before ever getting to know her or the MC and she just never liked the way she acted.

As well we only have a small sample size to compare to. Only one where Eliza is jealous and one she is not until the pirates show back up or someone else comes into play it's hard for me to say Eliza has a problem with sharing or not and it goes against what were told what the norm is for their society until we do. As I think even in such a society probably normal to not like or feel jealous of 1 or 2 partners here and there. As well Eliza never did or said anything to Selena or the MC on how she doesnt want to share or is jealous. Since I think actions matter more than personal thoughts cause it's easy to have personal thoughts that go against something but still accept it with your actions.

Anyways that's my thoughts on the whole thing. I see issues but I don't see enough of an issue to disagree with what Buu as told us either.

 

[Grumpy Old Aussie]

This is how I see the whole harem thing or whatever is im somewhere in the middle where I agree both with Buu and the people that have an issue with it. As I do think it should of been showcased alot earlier in the story as Eliza's dialogue / her thougths does feel like it kind of go against the whole it's normal for men to have more than one partner in their society. As well as it does feel a bit weird for the MC to sleep around with how in love he is with Eliza and some of the things he says to her. As well what Borri tells the MC if you pick the harem option.

The thing is those are her thoughts but she doesn't know the MC is sleeping around. Which is why I think Buu is planning and having Alice and Eliza have some kind of conversation. To show how she is fine with it and isn't a big deal and doesn't mind sharing despite that was her thoughts with Selena. I think why Eliza never showed any concern with Alice even tho she should of worried about Alice more than Selena if this was a modern society . Simply because Alice was a childhood friend and always acted kind and innocent and not coming onto the MC while clearly Alice is in love with him which I assume Eliza could tell. While Selena came onto the MC strong before ever getting to know her or the MC and she just never liked the way she acted.

As well we only have a small sample size to compare to. Only one where Eliza is jealous and one she is not until the pirates show back up or someone else comes into play it's hard for me to say Eliza has a problem with sharing or not and it goes against what were told what the norm is for their society until we do. As I think even in such a society probably normal to not like or feel jealous of 1 or 2 partners here and there. As well Eliza never did or said anything to Selena or the MC on how she doesnt want to share or is jealous. Since I think actions matter more than personal thoughts cause it's easy to have personal thoughts that go against something but still accept it with your actions.

Anyways that's my thoughts on the whole thing. I see issues but I don't see enough of an issue to disagree with what Buu as told us either.

Good points Dessolos as always.

For me, the MC is a Nephilim, and as a Nephilim, he doesn't necessarily act or think like 'normal' people. Its a fantasy world so BUU can build it the way he likes it, it doesn't have to suit 24th century norms or even medieval norms, that is the beauty of fantasy worlds and the danger of fantasy worlds. Its a fine line. Its BUU's world and he is building it with his vision. Readers don't have to like it and we are free to walk away as I nearly did with the Eliza-vampire thing. I didn't want to see one of my fav characters become a heartless killer. It wasn't for me, but now we have a choice.

In saying that, I'm not a fan of cheating in most scenarios. The MC being a Nephilim who does act differently, will have to come face to face with how the 'normal' world works and/or how Eliza sees their relationship, that is yet to come in the game. So for now, the MC is doing his thing and I'm interested to see how that plays out.

 

[motseer]

I'm betting not a single LI will give up her place in the harem for any reason whatsoever - unless MC sends her packin'. Any takers?

 

[Krytax123]

That's not a very good argument, Buu. First, because you should expect your players to bring their 2024 morals to the story. We're playing it 2024, right? If you want us to apply a different lens to the events in game, it's up to you to establish that perspective within the game itself, not in a rant on a third-party forum. We've had plenty of time to show that polygamy and affairs are commonplace or that women recognize their lot as second class, but I can't recall any instances of that.

If anything, the impressions we get are the opposite. Kelly's mom was eager to defy her husband so that Kelly could live her own life. King Bennen has only a single (female) heir and (AFAWK) never took additional concubines/wives to supplement that, nor does he consider taking a second wife as an alternate means of securing the kingdom. Queen Merida pontificates at great length how disappointed she was when her 'fairy tale' marriage turns out to be less than romantic, which strongly implies love and devotion are the ideals people espouse publicly - even if reality falls short of the ideal.

Second, on every other subject, the behavior of almost every character in the game is thoroughly modern. Women may join - and even lead - guilds without issue. The King is eager to dispense with formalities when meeting with the MC. No one bats an eye when the Queen entertains a male stranger in her bedchamber. That isn't how medieval society worked, either. Combine these discrepancies with literal magic and non-human races and I frankly see no reason why we would guess society in Nephilim isn't just as egalitarian as our own, to say nothing of it being dramatically less so.

Basically, if you want the MC to play the field without coming of as a cad, you need to do a better job establishing the norm.

I agree with everything but Bennen, im pretty sure he's gay? Thats the only reason i can see why he only had sex with his wife once for specificly one heir

 

[Tokenugget]

As well we only have a small sample size to compare to. Only one where Eliza is jealous and one she is not until the pirates show back up or someone else comes into play it's hard for me to say Eliza has a problem with sharing or not

To be fair... Eliza was jealous of a couple other girls. One statement she made was pretty telling...

Spoiler: Bar lady

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Slyph

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I agree with everything but Bennen, im pretty sure he's gay? Thats the only reason i can see why he only had sex with his wife once for specificly one heir

I thought the queen admitted that.. Their marriage was just a cover for him being gay. I'd have to go back and replay that scene to be sure.

 

[EKG]

yeah that's my favorite way to play nice and calm then scorched Earth when it comes to Eliza lol.

Anybody else on Light path feeling like they may have to break rank and pick the Dark choice when it comes to Taron?

I don't think I've hated a VN character this much since Acting Lessons.

 

[ename144]

I'm betting not a single LI will give up her place in the harem for any reason whatsoever - unless MC sends her packin'. Any takers?

No way I'm betting against that! Even sending them packing will probably still feel like a harem based on the way Kira's courtship played out.

I agree with everything but Bennen, im pretty sure he's gay? Thats the only reason i can see why he only had sex with his wife once for specificly one heir

Yeah, the game is pretty clear Bennen was desperate to quash rumors about his homosexuality. But my point is that I still find that explanation inconsistent with the world Buu alleges. How effective a beard can a single wife (who produced a single female heir) be if promiscuity is the accepted birthright of all men (much less a king)? I'd think it would take something more akin to Christian Bale-as-Bruce Wayne antics to ward off suspicion in such a hyper-masculine world.

 

[Joshy92]

Good points Dessolos as always.

For me, the MC is a Nephilim, and as a Nephilim, he doesn't necessarily act or think like 'normal' people. Its a fantasy world so BUU can build it the way he likes it, it doesn't have to suit 24th century norms or even medieval norms, that is the beauty of fantasy worlds and the danger of fantasy worlds. Its a fine line. Its BUU's world and he is building it with his vision. Readers don't have to like it and we are free to walk away as I nearly did with the Eliza-vampire thing. I didn't want to see one of my fav characters become a heartless killer. It wasn't for me, but now we have a choice.

In saying that, I'm not a fan of cheating in most scenarios. The MC being a Nephilim who does act differently, will have to come face to face with how the 'normal' world works and/or how Eliza sees their relationship, that is yet to come in the game. So for now, the MC is doing his thing and I'm interested to see how that plays out.

I'll tell you how it ends Grumpy the girls find out about the mc banging all of them and after an update or two they are all fine with it that's how harems work.

 

[Grumpy Old Aussie]

I'll tell you how it ends Grumpy the girls find out about the mc banging all of them and after an update or two they are all fine with it that's how harems work.

True, but I'm still interested in the journey to get there. Its the journey not the destination my perverted friend.

 

[burbero]

I love romance, but don't you think you're overdoing it a bit? They're making love all the time, like teenage new lovers.
They even made love the whole time since version 3.0.

 

[burbero]

God, there'll be another kissing ritual.

 

[AlexMpog]

I love romance, but don't you think you're overdoing it a bit?

Nope, the more wholesome moments - the merrier

 

[Dessolos]

Nope, the more wholesome moments - the merrier

same here I could play an entire AVN from start to finish if there was no sex if it was wholesome as fuck. There are some games out there I love all the wholesome moments to the point I could careless about anything else but that with those character even tho I do want my MC to have sex eventually cause of their slow burn nature.

 

[Nezron]

finished 0.4.1, and it was very good. I was one of those that HATED what happened to Eliza... so much so that I almost did not download this update. However the dev said he was going to give Eliza a choice with the barmaid... so I played and yep there is a choice now. And through the story Eliza is still the sweet girl I really like, and by the end of the update I feel pretty good about the direction now.

So thanks dev for not ruining one of the best female characters. And on another note.... I hope the Harem thing works out because my MC has been fucking every girl

Peace

 

[burbero]

Nope, the more wholesome moments - the merrier

 

[SSiKK]

Hi, to start I wanted to say that I enjoy the game.
I like the story, especially the "heel turn" twists of the NPCs which add depth and personality to them.
For the moment I'm only interested in the romance with Eliza and don't particularly want to test the others except Kira.
I like the fact that I'm given the choice between simple romance or harem because I personally don't like the second option. However (even if I understand why it was done this way since it was explained in the developer's note) I don't really like the open door aspect of each relationship. You can be neutral all the time but go with a choice indicated as romance. Especially since at times these choices seem logical to me and without ulterior motives (from my point of view, but I'm nitpicking badly)
I can't wait to see the end of this story. I understood that it was going to take some time ^^ but I think it will be worth it. It's for this type of story that I would like to give a little something to the developer but I don't appreciate the monthly payment via patreon.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

The renders are of really good quality, even if some at the beginning made me laugh, Eliza sometimes makes alien faces. Some "thinking" passages are not always indicated but this does not harm the understanding of the story.
So yes, the olé olé scenes are not numerous (in the case of a unique romance with Eliza, the only path I took) but honestly I don't care.
There are these games whose story is so gripping that we forget to brush up on Chinese (French expression, " se polir le chinois " , it's for me, it's a gift) and there for once I didn't even think about a only time at that. Yes it's erotic but it's well balanced.

In short, it's a story that I find nice, finally characters with realistic shapes and depth in their personality, GG

 

[DevinHesi]

Preview: v0.4.2!

You must be registered to see the links

Time for a little reunion with Meredith the lovely alchemist! Surely nothing too lewd will be happening with Amelia present? ... Right?



Available now for Ascended members and This Friday for S:Rank members!