Me neither.
I would have killed Selena, given the choice.
But killing her innocent sister which has nothing to do with it and was a victim to the same guy which hurt Eliza seems like a classic 'chaotic stupid' choice.
I get Buu's reasoning, that this would hurt Selena more than killing her...but yeah, if i want hurt Selena i hurt her directly, no need for killing innocent.
Please don't get me wrong guys, maybe I didn't express myself correctly but
once again I put all the blame on the dev. I totally agree with all the above posts,
I didn't want to have the choice of killing Selena's innocent sister, it's the dev's choice, not mine, I just wanted a choice to get back at Selena for what she did and what she harshly said to Eliza in jail, and that's the only choice I was offered.
I play this game as the
MC, not as myself, so let's see everything from MC's eyes and the context he is in:
- He sees both his dad and mom savagely murdered.
- He is taken away from his friends (and especially from Alice) and trained by a stranger for
10 years.
- He only lives and suffers for 10 years for only one goal:
REVENGE.
- The stranger who trained him dies, MC promises him that he will find his daughter.
- He finally meets Eliza, the daughter of the man who saved his life and trained him for his goal: revenge.
- Being in contact with Eliza, he changes, he now has 2 goals: avenge his parents and protect Eliza at all cost.
- He fails. Eliza is very badly hurt, she almost died.
- New goals: avenge his parents and avenge Eliza.
-
Only 2 choices offered by the dev: kill Selena's sister or let Selena go unpunished, free as a bird.
(And please don't tell me that Selena's fate is to be decided by Eliza. At this very moment in time MC doesn't know what Selena will really do. Will she visit Eliza for her mercy and risk being killed? (stupid right?) Or will she flee with her sister? Please note that a week later, MC contacts Eliza, he asks for news about everyone and, even if you let Selena and her sister go unharmed, Eliza does not mention any visit from Selena at all. It's been a week already, just saying.)
See what I meant from the beginning? MC is not living in a world full of beautiful rainbows and unicorns, he lives for REVENGE. Wether you, as a player, choose the
light or the
dark path does not really matter for the moment, MC has a shitload of darkness inside him, and for a damn good reason.
Sorry for the long post guys, I really enjoy this game and that's why I really enjoy exchanging opinions with you. Who is right and who is wrong doesn't really matter in the end, it's the dev choices I'm discussing here, not ours.