Dessolos
Message Maven
- Jul 25, 2017
- 14,665
- 19,321
I never said she knew about the ring. I was just talking about blackhearts violent behavior which Kira knew he was rather violent , more than your average pirate.
Then that would be the same as commiting suicide wouldn't? That's like trying to jump the guy mugging you. A sensible person isn't going to do that. Case in point she figured that the mc would be sensible and not try to fight blackheart
He's violent, but we've already discussed he hasn't been shown to kill being indiscriminately.
- Jul 26, 2023
- 12,440
- 26,986
I don't think you know what selective memory is. I'm using the dialogue we are given, you're using your interpretation of what she was thinking and worked out.
Kira knowingly put MC in danger (as proven by the screenshots). It's a 50/50 chance he would get hurt, he answers or he doesn't. But, she is still putting him in that danger. She knew there was chance. No matter how much you try and spin it that she expected him to fold, she was still putting him in danger.
It's selective memory because your claiming stuff that happened didn't happen. You said Kira never shows any remorse. She actively showed remorse. Then you ignore the fact that she mentions that Blackheart wouldn't hurt him if he doesn't withhold information.
The only way there was a chance is if the mc directly goes against her advice but she's literally telling him how he can make it through the encounter unharmed. So yes how you spin it matters a lot. If I tell you to go through the bad part of town with a body guard and a police escort would you still blame me for putting you in danger even though I'm actively trying to protect you?
- Jul 26, 2023
- 12,440
- 26,986
I'm out. I'm not getting caught up in one of your endless debates again. I have nothing more to add.
I'm out. I'm not getting caught up in one of your endless debates again. I have nothing more to add.
Then what's the point in commenting?
Imo I don't think Kira believed mc was in any real danger and I don't think Kira did anything wrong in that moment other than lie to the mc.
I am not ignoring, I mentioned at the end. She give the kiss, put MC in ice and started to prepare finishing blow, she did not walked away there. Before she managed to hit the finishing blow, he melted the ice.
They weren't fighting there, she hit him out of nowhere while he was trying to explain the situation. You can't count that. Also, when he made her flying out, she was not able to get up and MC started to talk there, giving her time to recover. For double knock out, as I explained, he gave significantly more damage. If he did not heal her, she could die. So I gave the point towards him.
I really don't agree with this one. I was as fair as you and looked at it objectively. If anything, you skipping MC's holding her by her neck part was unfair. That really was an end to the fight. He could have break her neck there. They even have eye locking romance thing. MC had a chance to say how beautiful she is (she is gorgeous btw) and so on. You did not give any point to MC there.
It is clear victory for MC whichever point of view you look at and anything else being said on the topic would be coping.
Blackbeard literally threatened to kill MC on the spot. MC should not be in there if Kira did not brought him there by lying. What could she do more beside literally backstabbing MC there? I do like these types of discussions on forums but I feel like you are saying things just to say things.
He did not threaten to kill mc on the spot he jokes and says "should I embrace you as a father in law" or "hang you for laying eyes on my daughter" when he notes that Kira and Pearl both seem to have a crush on him. Then he laughs all mc's responsibes no matter what he says and lets him go.Blackbeard literally threatened to kill MC on the spot. MC should not be in there if Kira did not brought him there by lying. What could she do more beside literally backstabbing MC there? I do like these types of discussions on forums but I feel like you are saying things just to say things.
She literally turned around and started talking to him
She literally got directly up again, she wasn't even fully knocked down like the mc was earlier just hunched over and trying to regain her balance
Which is like maybe 3 seconds? The whole time she was actively struggling and fighting against him and managed to break free? Why would you count a chokehold as a win if a person manages to break free? And again why does that count as a win but not being frozen?
This point doesn't make any sense at all. Mc literally admits that he would have died twice in there fight without his regen ability. She also stops to talk to him while he's in a block of ice. It just seems like you're applying a lot of double standards here.
Mc did not inflict more damage, Both their attacks were enough to knock the other one out. Diana inflicted more damage but Mc has a faster recovery time then wasn't able to keep up any more and her final attack was enough to knock him out for good
Last edited:
Dessolos
Message Maven
- Jul 25, 2017
- 14,665
- 19,321
jadepaladin
Well-Known Member
- Mar 9, 2020
- 1,251
- 2,561
Why would the MC believe her here? Why would anyone believe a known pirate here?
Pixillin'
Active Member
- Oct 8, 2024
- 776
- 774
And who cares anyway. It wasn't part of the arrangement, it is still a betrayal. "Give him what he wants and he won't hurt you" doesn't make it any less of a betrayal.
Why wouldn't you believe her here? Blackheart's her dad and mc knows his reputation. And even if not why wouldn't you believe a pirate on how to behave in a pirate base? I don't even understand why you would doubt anyone there pirate or not? There are some situations where it makes sense to assume someone is lying.
i'm wondering why its been awhile since we've had a light and dark path choice. the last light and dark path i can remember is when the mc's girl becomes a vampire and you can encourage her to become a cold heartless blood draining monster, or try to have her try to resist, since im on a dark path i chose to encourage her darker side, but atlas that choice was doesn't matter because i've gotten to the tribal island now and she's a goody two shoes who drinks either my blood with permission or what i assume is artificial blood. now the drinking my blood with permission i get, but if i encourage the darkness within , then it should show.
Dessolos
Message Maven
- Jul 25, 2017
- 14,665
- 19,321
The moment we landed at Looters Bay my first time when it was revealed it wasn't the agreed upon destination , I didn't believe her or trust her anymore. Infact I thought she was setting the MC up to be killed or something considering she is a pirate. Before the whole cave portion I was waiting for the chance to kill her as I figure best get rid of her as soon as possible. Tho the cave part did change my mind about her. She went from kill to dislike.
But again that doesnt any sense. They could literally just kill mc there why go through the trouble of lying to the mc if they're just going to kill him anyway. Not trusting Kira in general or not it's literally just a situation where it make zero sense to lie. Heck she didn't even have to tell him that she was taking him to see blackheart if she was actually setting him up to be killed. Just tell him that she's stopping to resupply or something and wants him to come with her.
Dessolos
Message Maven
- Jul 25, 2017
- 14,665
- 19,321
I mean at the time I made the assumption they were gonna set the MC up and try to kill him but either Blackheart wanted to do the job, question him or something first. As I got the impression there was something Blackheart related first before they take him out. So assumed Kira was lying but acting like she wasn't by making it seem like we would be fine if we do what Blackheart wanted.
But they could just torture him, or do what I said and not even tell him that they're seeing blackheart but that they just stopped at the bay for a pit stop. It just logically doesn't make any sense to lie here.
xapican
Devoted Member
- May 11, 2020
- 11,054
- 17,065
MC needs the rings to prevent Baltasar being reborn, all rings have magic and belonged to the Magicians who banned him, iirc
Dessolos
Message Maven
- Jul 25, 2017
- 14,665
- 19,321
Called deceiving someone to make them think they are fine but they are walking into a trap without knowing. Which is why i thought Kira bringing up Blackheart's name was a sprinkle of truth but not the actual truth just to make it seem believable.
yeah I am talking about that was revealed tho
I mean that's my point though. If it was really a trap why warn the MC that he's going to meet blackheart at all? She doesn't have to tell him the reason they're going to Looter's bay. She could very easily lie about why they are there then trap him when he doesn't suspect it.
I don't really see how mentioning blackhearts name helps at all if its a trap. It just seems like your logic is that it's a lie because she lied before and not thinking about whether it actually makes any sense to lie.