MrDude1977

Member
Jul 24, 2024
293
415
I didn't like Eliza's hair down, I didn't like the bang's and the hair was to short, her hair is much longer. She didn't look like Eliza to me. If you do more scenes with her hair down lose the bangs or shorter bangs and make her hair longer. EDIT: The hair was longer than i thought, but i still don't like it. Need to go back to her normal hair even on dates. Just doesn't look like Eliza with it down.
 
Last edited:

MiltonPowers

Twins Basil! Twins!
Donor
Jul 26, 2023
12,829
27,966
I didn't like Eliza's hair down, I didn't like the bang's and the hair was to short, her hair is much longer. She didn't look like Eliza to me. If you do more scenes with her hair down lose the bangs or shorter bangs and make her hair longer. EDIT: The hair was longer than i thought, but i still don't like it. Need to go back to her normal hair even on dates. Just doesn't look like Eliza with it down.
I agree with you brother.

Classic Eliza hair is the best. :love:

screenshot0001.png
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
851
866
cause there is no rational or valid reason to do so yet ( for me) other than Selena :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
For me there is. And it’s not just about how your first thing with them went - the more I’m around them the less I like them (and I disliked them on first meeting - before we set sail). At this point it would just be satisfying to know that I’d never see them again. Besides, I don’t see her as a Li yet really, but my second favorite in the game is Brenda - and it would be fun for her.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,938
19,759
For me there is. And it’s not just about how your first thing with them went - the more I’m around them the less I like them (and I disliked them on first meeting - before we set sail). At this point it would just be satisfying to know that I’d never see them again. Besides, I don’t see her as a Li yet really, but my second favorite in the game is Brenda - and it would be fun for her.
lol Brenda surprised by that I actually would kill her if I could . Assuming im not mixing characters up but she if she is the one that tried to kill the pirate sisters. Then yeah id kill her as I think she is too risky to leave alive , I wouldn't be able to trust her but I could at least trust the sisters even if I do dislike Kira.

But going back to your first point I get not liking Kira on your first meeting but not Peral , cause I didn't like Kira then gave her a chance and she just got worst for me.
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
851
866
lol Brenda surprised by that I actually would kill her if I could . Assuming im not mixing characters up but she if she is the one that tried to kill the pirate sisters. Then yeah id kill her as I think she is too risky to leave alive , I wouldn't be able to trust her but I could at least trust the sisters even if I do dislike Kira.

But going back to your first point I get not liking Kira on your first meeting but not Peral , cause I didn't like Kira then gave her a chance and she just got worst for me.
Well I gave them a chance, I mean there was a time when this was new and I didn't know anything about them - I was just going to help Eliza but I found them annoying from go, and never at any point grew more fond of either of them - then I wanted to kill them both - then, instead of that, I'm now on a months long voyage to help them. I would absolutely take them out if I could. Basically, in the fight between Brenda and the Pirate Twins, I'm on Brenda's side. My top 5 are Eliza, Brenda, Sylph (because she's Eliza's friend), the Barmaid (who I like enough that I'd let her milk cows) and Lucid because she seems like the most fun of the gods. After that it falls off pretty sharpish (I don't like the rest enough that I'd let them milk cows on my farm.)
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,938
19,759
Well I gave them a chance, I mean there was a time when this was new and I didn't know anything about them - I was just going to help Eliza but I found them annoying from go, and never at any point grew more fond of either of them - then I wanted to kill them both - then, instead of that, I'm now on a months long voyage to help them. I would absolutely take them out if I could. Basically, in the fight between Brenda and the Pirate Twins, I'm on Brenda's side. My top 5 are Eliza, Brenda, Sylph (because she's Eliza's friend), the Barmaid (who I like enough that I'd let her milk cows) and Lucid because she seems like the most fun of the gods. After that it falls off pretty sharpish (I don't like the rest enough that I'd let them milk cows on my farm.)
For me Brenda id kill , Sylph I find to annoying can't stand her, The Barmaid isn't bad but she is nothing more than a wench to me if she a character was a with some character deveolopment id probably like her. Lucid is a tricky one for me not sure if she is a LI or not I like her character alot .

Overall id say I like Eliza , Amelia , Luna , Peral and Alice about the same

But honestly for me I just think killing the pirates twins is too harsh of a punishment at this point even if I didn't like them ( I don't like Kira) , only reason I would kill Brenda is because I can't trust her to betray the MC or the pirate twins and she did try to take over looters bay and kill the twins.
 
Last edited:

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
851
866
For me Brenda id kill , Sylph I find to annoying can't stand her, The Barmaid isn't bad but she is nothing more than a wench to me if she a character we some character deveolopment id probably like her. Lucid is a tricky one for me not sure if she is a LI or not I like her character alot .

Overall id say I like Eliza , Amelia , Luna , Peral and Alice about the same

But honestly for me I just think killing the pirates twins is too harsh of a punishment at this point even if I didn't like them ( I don't like Kira) , only reason I would kill BrenThis product promotes war between the United States and Canada. While it doesn't say so explicitly that is what 51st state implies. da is because I can't trust her to betray the MC or the pirate twins and she did try to take over looters bay and kill the twins.
Yeah, that's what made me like Brenda - and at this point it's not just punishing them for before (though that too) - I'd kill them just so they wouldn't call me anymore. Edit: I should note though, that I don't really want to kill anyone else. I wouldn't save most of them if I could, but I don't want to kill them either.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,938
19,759
I'd kill them just so they wouldn't call me anymore.
now this part is a hard disagree for me but it's just my personal stance when a topic like this comes up in other games. I don't like it when a character is erased from a story just because someone doesn't like them even when off their path. Unless of course there is a narrative / story reason for it. I much rather just have their screen time limited when not playing a path but wanting to get rid of a character without a real reason or story reason to me feels disrespectful towards a dev. To me that's what it feels like when you say you want to never hear from them again and see them in the story anymore if you can help it. I only can accept killing Peral even tho I hard disagree but I do understand your pov.

This is why part of my reason for not liking your stance of wanting to just kill the pirates and why I also find it too harsh of a punishment since I don't think they did anything worthy of death yet in the story. Yeah I said I would kill Brenda given the chance but I don't want it to happen either just cause I don't like her I rather Buu creates a story reason if it's going to ever become an option.

I don't. I wish more women in the game were like Kira was at first. Too many female characters just drool over the mc without any agency of their own. Kira seemed capable at had a personality other than thinking the mc was hot.
I mean I agree with this but doens't make her any more likeable lol
 

Pixillin'

Active Member
Oct 8, 2024
851
866
now this part is a hard disagree for me but it's just my personal stance when a topic like this comes up in other games. I don't like it when a character is erased from a story just because someone doesn't like them even when off their path. Unless of course there is a narrative / story reason for it. I much rather just have their screen time limited when not playing a path but wanting to get rid of a character without a real reason or story reason to me feels disrespectful towards a dev. To me that's what it feels like when you say you want to never hear from them again and see them in the story anymore if you can help it. I only can accept killing Peral even tho I hard disagree but I do understand your pov.

This is why part of my reason for not liking your stance of wanting to just kill the pirates and why I also find it too harsh of a punishment since I don't think they did anything worthy of death yet in the story. Yeah I said I would kill Brenda given the chance but I don't want it to happen either just cause I don't like her I rather Buu creates a story reason if it's going to ever become an option.
Yeah I have both a story reason, and a I find them really annoying reason. Anyway, I’m looking forward to hearing what Brenda has to say - I’ll happily help her take Looter’s Bay and give her the Twins if that’s what she wants. I’m not really looking for story reasons for anything because this isn’t really a story-first game anymore.
 
3.90 star(s) 97 Votes