xapican
Message Maven
- May 11, 2020
- 12,798
- 20,607
- 998
Hey we need story, we need good and evil, we need protagonist and such...
So Brenda gets to play a bit of a bitch, until she IS properly fucked...
Last edited:
jadepaladin
Engaged Member
- Mar 9, 2020
- 3,502
- 7,299
- 646
The harem must grow. I won't like Brenda being in the harem but I'll accept it if it happens. In a story where the MC apparently seduces anyone just being in the area, it would be nice to have a female antagonist that isn't phased by it.
Wouldn't be shocked if we somehow swing Eliza's mom to our side.
Wouldn't be shocked if we somehow swing Eliza's mom to our side.
Pixillin'
Well-Known Member
- Oct 8, 2024
- 1,906
- 2,397
- 341
Honestly I think that's the root of it. Eliza is somewhat believable when she falls for you right away - because she's been alone, and then you saved her, and there's a kind of instant connection I think because the same person semi-raised you both. You are both heavily influenced by her father. So somewhat believable. Alice is a little believable but harder, because you were close when you were little but you vanished when she was 10 years old - on the night your parents were murdered - and she's just been waiting for you to come back the whole time - also semi-believable but somewhat creepy if true. The rest are just sort of automatic, they are absolutely, deeply in love with you on sight because you exist and have a penis. It's not believable, and it's boring.
Quetzzz
Well-Known Member
- Sep 29, 2023
- 1,457
- 2,128
- 387
But why did Pearl get away with betraying the MC?
A few days earlier the MC could have killed Selena's sister to take revenge on her for betraying their trust, effectively killing someone who was innocent. But when Pearl does the same, he's not even angry.
I probably wouldn't have killed Pearl, but I would've loved actual choices on how to handle her. Like, for instance, treating the twins like their daddy did in a dark path playthrough.
Just refuse her?
There's still something fishy about the whole Eliza situation. She was wandering the woods wearing stilettos. It's really surprising she survived years doing that.
Kidding aside, I do agree with you. At least if the player engages with her romantically. If he doesn't, I honestly don't see the progression. This MC would keep Eliza at arm's distance the entire time, but still moves mountains for her.
It's also kinda funny how you can pick all the negative choices, and then just agree to be with her when the major choice appears, then it'd be like they've always been that way.
xapican
Message Maven
- May 11, 2020
- 12,798
- 20,607
- 998
Id liked to see her dry sucked hull like with Serena,.....
xapican
Message Maven
- May 11, 2020
- 12,798
- 20,607
- 998
jadepaladin
Engaged Member
- Mar 9, 2020
- 3,502
- 7,299
- 646
Dessolos
Post Pro
- Jul 25, 2017
- 20,768
- 29,825
- 936
the Pirate the tried to kill the twins and take over Looters bayWho the hell is Brenda?
Because I don't consider Pearl as having betrayed the mc. She didn't know about Eliza and was told that Kira was going to die if she didnt steal whatever the mc was after and she immidently jumped ship.
I also don't really have a huge hate boner on Selena and would probably be able to look past everything if it didn't result in Eliza getting paralyzed. The biggest difference between Pearl and Selena is that no harm came out of anything Pearl did
Dessolos
Post Pro
- Jul 25, 2017
- 20,768
- 29,825
- 936
not just that for me up to what I played ( ive yet to play chapter 5) Peral felt really bad and way more remorseful than Selena imo. It was to the point she didn't think she should be allowed around the MC anymore
That's nice too. But remember how to made the green monster in What a Legend after 2 years of hate, one of the most loving characters of the game ?Id liked to see her dry sucked hull like with Serena,.....
Everything is possible... Dry fucking her skull with or without her body is an option too...
Oh, thanks. I thought you may talk about that barmaid because I am not a huge fan of her.
Dessolos
Post Pro
- Jul 25, 2017
- 20,768
- 29,825
- 936
I sorta of liked the Barmaid but she has some mommy Milkers so hard to say no to her
Quetzzz
Well-Known Member
- Sep 29, 2023
- 1,457
- 2,128
- 387
I don't know if we can assume that. In later content it's clear that MC & Pearl had a lot of things to say to each other in the two weeks they were traveling to the island.
What if Blackbeard had used the chalice before MC got there? What if these pirates were actually a bit more capable?
No harm came out of anything that Pearl did because the MC was there to fix things. It's not a good argument, because you could say that no harm resulted from anything Selena did either because the MC put things right.
The whole "daddy made me do it" is just too easy of an excuse. I can honestly understand that Pearl betrays the MC to keep Mira safe. What I don't understand is that Pearl later boards the ship to attack Mira, saying that their father ordered her to get rid of her. That she attacked to chase Mira off... What was her plan? "Hey sis, I beat you, so now you have to sail away and never come back"? As if that would've worked with a firecracker like Mira.
That the MC doesn't even have stern words for her is ridiculous, specially when the story gave us plenty of information on how the MC views betrayal, and how a dark-path MC would handle it.
Quetzzz
Well-Known Member
- Sep 29, 2023
- 1,457
- 2,128
- 387
Honestly, I want her to hook up with the cousin. Maybe he grows up a bit after getting laid.
You mean Kira, right?
According to Pearl she did not attack Kira to kill, she did it to chase her away to save her from her father's wrath. Also, even if they feel close to MC, they'd choose, both of them, their own twin over MC everyday. So that also made sense. We honestly don't know how powerful was Blackbeard, MC dealt with him with ease. (Probably because his lack of potential to become an LI) But Pearl feared him, Kira too. So if he threatened Pearl to kill Kira, that really make sense.
If you are comparing that to Selena. It really is not. One of them puts their so-called friends in active danger. Even after she denies it, she is very well aware Taron was going to kill both MC and Eliza. That's active betrayal. Not even counting she was part of the ambush that Eliza got kidnapped and it was her who lured Eliza away from MC for the ambush. On top of that, she gloated at the cell. She even mentioned how not either MC or Eliza survive the situation. I am still salty that MC can't kill her and let her sister go. She deserved the worst.
In Pearl's situation, she took a chalice to save her own twin sister. It was just another trinket a pirate stole, nothing more. Yes, MC do believe it could help someone she does not know, a person she never met. She did not know if the chalice would work, even if it works would Eliza accepts it, Eliza (a person she only know as MC's friend, if Pearl even know that much) was not going to die, if Eliza did not get the chalice there could be another way to help her too. Her sister was in greater danger than somebody she did not know.
Also, another huge difference, Pearl did not follow through the plan, she helped MC and Kira. Selena did followed through the entire plan, gave MC and Eliza on a silver platter. She was not regretting when MC caught her, she would do all over again for under the same circumstances while Pearl was regretting and she noticed she could have choose another path.
Last edited:
duckydoodoo
Active Member
- Nov 9, 2023
- 756
- 1,155
- 276
its only creepy out of context.
the classic love before puberty that never dies trope is kind of a real thing. ive a soft spot for a neighbor girl when i was a child. now ive no intention of ever dating her, looking for her, so much as checking her name on facebook and see what pops up. but i always think of her warmly and in a slightly romaticized way. people do that it seems, and i know its not real but whatever when i think of her it happens that way. we were very close, her brother and i were good buddies and he little sister was a mouse of a girl when she wasnt being a total bitch. their family moved before we were teenagers.
for alice specifically, living in a small village where every man was like a creepy uncle or her brother, and no one really leaves, who else is she gonna pine for? in fact the fantasy that MC somehow survived and is out there somewhere, one day to return. think it would be easy for childhood friendship to turn into romantic loved, one sided or not.
its crazy how real life a childhood friendship can evolve into a romantic love and get sealed in ones heart. its only creepy when the person experiencing it turns it into an obsession and never goes on with their life. alice wasnt that, she was already looking at leaving the village, having a life. she just always hoped MC was out there too, to the point that believing him dead and gone would be a betrayal to her own heart.
i still prefer eliza, but keep alice around, she will be necessary to help herd all of MC and Eliza's whelps
Pixillin'
Well-Known Member
- Oct 8, 2024
- 1,906
- 2,397
- 341
I can kind of see that in your case, but in a medieval(ish) setting I still find it weird. Life expectancy was much lower and people die frequently. I mean in a very, very early context that's kind of what the Winter Solstice celebration (later Christmas) was about - you gather the family and have a huge feast before dipping into winter because there's a decent chance not all of them will see the spring. So I can see her holding on to him as a kind of fantasy, but whatever happens in that setting you suck it up and move on with life. So I still find the idea of her just sitting there and waiting for him for a decade and then just sort of being "finally, there you are - well, let's get on with that adventuring" to be ... unhealthy at the very least.