This game is all over the place. I mean realy, A heads up on the time line would be good. Or pick a lane and stay in it.
Says the dude pushing for character renaming as a necessary game "feature"? 99%+ of games on this site already allow character renaming and y'all whining the one time there isn't. You're the one pushing for this game to change something I like, its called conversation no need to get so defensive. And did you even read my comment? I literally stated several downsides.Yet again, someone is certain that the way they consume media is the only proper way, and no one else could possibly have a valid opinion about it. You're also making the same invalid comparison I see time and time again. Movies/TV shows/porn videos are NOT the same as a video game where you make choices for the main character. Video games inherently involve a more interactive mindset, and that means that there are a lot of people who choose to immerse in the MC of a video game they're playing, and want to customize that MC a little bit (and changing the name is an easy way to do that). It's not even necessarily self-inserting, it's closer to minor character creation. As an example of major media that does exactly this: Many of the Final Fantasy games, including games with very strong characterization (e.g. FF6 and FF7), allow renaming of some characters.
Beyond that, some people just prefer not to see certain names, and some people prefer to see certain specific names. There's at least one game where I have to change one of the LI names because it's a weird misspelling of the name that just annoys me every time I see it (Ursela, it just sounds dumb). Other times, I don't find the name at all attractive, but I don't want that to detract from the LI. In other instances, I've heard people mention that an LI shares a name with a hostile ex and they'd rather not see her name, and so on.
That the game has lewd content does not change any of the above whatsoever, particularly for people who play these games for the story rather than for the porn.
As for your "can't think of a single upside", that's a 'you' problem. In fact, there are no downsides to having the option to rename the MC. It's (usually) one extra screen for people who don't want to rename the MC, while it helps the people who do want to rename them in every scene where the MC's name is used. As for referencing the character in conversations? If you talk a lot about a given porn game that has a changeable MC name, they either use the default name or they just say "the MC". It's really that simple.
If you assume I said something I didn't, sure, it might seem more frustrating. The downsides you mention are trivial at best, and you completely ignored the answer I gave to the one downside you mentioned. Also, when I talked about renaming characters other than the MC, I specifically mentioned URM, which requires zero effort from the dev, and has literally zero effect on other people playing the game.Says the dude pushing for character renaming as a necessary game "feature"? 99%+ of games on this site already allow character renaming and y'all whining the one time there isn't. You're the one pushing for this game to change something I like, its called conversation no need to get so defensive. And did you even read my comment? I literally stated several downsides.
As I've said, by allowing renaming the devs is kneecaping himself from tons of writing possibilities based on it since all names must now make sense storywise. It objectively hurts story integrity, unless everyone even loved ones start referring to the MC as their last name like in Mass Effect, which makes no sense. That much really isn't an opinion.
You downplaying my opinion or story concerns doesn't make them trivial and I never even mentioned renaming characters other than the MC, so you're on your own on that tirade. None of my comments we're even close to aggressive and I never outright shat on your tastes like you did. I'm done here, no point in keeping this going in these conditions. Good job on cherry-picking the flattering part of your first comment thoughIf you assume I said something I didn't, sure, it might seem more frustrating. The downsides you mention are trivial at best, and you completely ignored the answer I gave to the one downside you mentioned. Also, when I talked about renaming characters other than the MC, I specifically mentioned URM, which requires zero effort from the dev, and has literally zero effect on other people playing the game.
I mentioned that I was frustrated by not being able to rename the MC. That's it. I didn't "push for" it. I mentioned it as something I was frustrated by. When I went to talk to the dev on his Discord, I discovered that, with absolutely no input from me, he was already implementing it in this version. That's hardly kneecapping his "writing possibilities". (The post you were responding to was me mentioning that character rename was already coming, because that's what the dev told me, and this version proved that he was not lying. My literal first post in this thread, I said this: " Name Change: While I strongly dislike not being able to rename the MC, URM rename and some code editing makes that a lot easier.", which is explicitly saying that while I'd find it nice, I can work around it.)
Also, you do realize that name variables exist, right? Renamed MCs can still be referred to by the name the player chose for them. And are, regularly, in a multitude of games (including this one, now). Do you really think, in the vast majority of western AVNs that let you rename the MC, literally NO ONE says the character's name, EVER? Yes, that would be weird. That is also not the case. But, yeah, it's very, very easy.
Hell, the dev of Stormside even has a neat little feature where, if the name the player entered is one of a set of names that have common nicknames, one of the girls will ask if it's okay for her to call the MC [nickname associated to the name entered] if there is one.
And I'm honestly just baffled that you went on such an aggressive and uninformed rant about how other people play things that don't affect you in the slightest.
The entirety of the section about MC renaming from my first post in this thread:Good job on cherry-picking the flattering part of your first comment though
So that's a nice little lie about cherry-picking.Name Change: While I strongly dislike not being able to rename the MC, URM rename and some code editing makes that a lot easier. If the dev reads this: Using a static family name is relatively common, but using a static given name is not appreciated by most fans in harem games.
The funniest thing about all of this is that there is one already, in this version. Starting a new game allows renaming the MC (and you can change it on an existing game by using a console command or URM to update theYeah. We need a renaming system in this game.
player_name
variable). The three very-similar names I called out in my original post have also now been fixed, with the less-important two of the three names being changed (Ayase is the unchanged one, which makes sense with her prominence in the story so far).