Yeah, I do want to try a more bratty play through someday. First time I played very bold and Dom, then the second play through (current), I played innocent and shy; I just got through with the recent Wedding DLC beta build with a bold character, and I'm starting to see shy Cove again, which I don't
hate~, but I'm wondering if he'd open up more if I revert back to being the shy one? He really took the lead in step 1-3 with my shy MC, and I miss that. I first wanted to play to my personality, and though I've never been shy, I could be considered "introverted" as a teen (an emo phase, actually. I was definitely extroverted as a child), then extroverted as an adult (about 17+); so I played with a bold child, shy crushing preteen-teen, then was going for a bold in love adult, but I think when the game finish out, I'm gonna go back to shy again, for the more "Dom" Cove during the step 4/wedding DLC. I know Cove is shy by default, but he seems to go to the defense when he sees MC "struggling", as you say; I think this is the "Sick MC" Cove you're referring to? (I had skipped the "sick" options
particularly if you mean the boat scene because I never intended to play a character that delicate; but I didn't realize it came with the perks of fun Cove, so I'll have to give it a go.)
On your spoiler bit, I did attempt to stir up some drama that way, just to see how it would feel to get some conflict, but I felt too bad! UnU It felt like I had to be purposefully contentious to kick start it, and it sort of made me feel like I was playing with either a stupid or antagonistic MC, because I had to argue for the sake of arguing, even though I agreed with everyone's sentiments on the subject, (I personally think all involve were being big-ass babies, but I understand why people feel that way—especially at that age—so I wouldn't say it to their face... in that moment.) and that's not the toxicity I'm looking for.
After the game is complete, only to keep it fresh (I don't typically replay games), I might try out your suggestions to see this other side to Cove. Thank you for the tips!