I wasn't really sure whether I should post this cos it's pretty critical and might rub some people up the wrong way, but I figured what the hell. This is just my personal impression of a part of chapter 9 that... didn't really work for me.
I'm one of the ones who likes Allison, but I felt pretty disappointed by Ian and Allison's weekend away. Maybe I just imagined it a bit differently, and/or was too hyped after the wait for chapter 9's release so thought too deeply into it, but...
I didn't really like how critical Allison was of Ian's actions during the sex. Don't even get me started on her saying she wanted one thing but meaning something else entirely (in regards to the 'cum inside me') it may have been roleplay but that was just stupid - that sort of thing is already annoying enough when people do it in real life. All the fault she was finding killed the mood.
I also felt like she was dictating how things were meant to go to a degree that didn't really feel consistent with the way she acted in previous scenes (more submissive, and more eager to please, I guess?). Not that a person can't change, or rather, reveal more of their character as they grow more comfortable with a partner, but this felt like a bit much at once. I was also slightly bummed that Ian couldn't take control and continue with the whole dom/sub angle that it had had in the 'barking' scene (which was a fun surprise back then). That's a personal preference, but it felt strange not to have the option considering the scenes before.
But more then anything I really didn't like how Ian brought up anal and Allison said 'I don't have lube', so he just goes in dry. No. No no no. Why were we never given the chance to say, 'you know what, let's wait until we have lube before we try it'. We could also choose the alternative, but for god's sake, give me the option there! Like, what the hell?
I mean, Allison was already weird about anal before that, so her deciding to try it if Ian asks was a pretty big deal, so why the hell would Ian mess it up by not using lube and so ensuring it's gonna be a horrible experience for her? It also felt kind of out of character for Ian to just go ahead with it anyway, considering he's always been a pretty empathetic character who has gone out of his way to ensure his partner was having a good time in bed -- even on the occasions when he acted more dominant -- whilst never coming across as weak-willed (something that I loved about his character). He always seemed to know how to please whomever he was with. To me the tone felt really off with most of that sex, and the anal bit was the worst. It actually made me clench my butthole in discomfort just from reading it. TMI, but there you go. lol.
IDK, I'm still working it through in my head, but the whole weekend just felt really unsexy and off-putting to me. I also was looking forward to a bit more personal connection between Ian and Allison beyond the sex (and beyond Allison's complaining), but there wasn't really any of that.
I'm not sure if it was just how it came across to me, whether I just had too-high expectations (which could well be the case, I do tend to drive my expectations up pretty high when I wait), or if others may have felt that way too. It's hard to feel enthused about the pairing after that though, especially because I felt like the chemistry between them there felt forced in comparison to how natural it was starting to feel before that, where Ian was finally getting comfortable with sleeping with someone he'd previously only looked at as a friend.
All I know is that I didn't come away from that weekend with the same optimism both of the characters obviously felt.